News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by dpeck on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @10:49AM (#20155904)
Easy, you simply make the decisions within the confines of the shadow hierarchy that exists within all flat organizations.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by adrianmonk on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @02:07PM (#20157932)
A slightly radical theory: flat organizations are set up to foster that intentionally.

Suppose your company has the idea that they want to identify and reward natural leaders and/or those who test limits and push through boundaries.

One way to do it is to tell people your organization is flat, then watch for the people who don't buy that and instead see an opportunity to take charge.

You create a situation with a little bit of an artificial and completely intentional power vacuum, then you watch who takes it upon themselves to step in and fill it. By holding a bit of a vacuum, you encourage these people to show themselves. (And I'm convinced management is actively watching to see who takes that bait.)

I'd say these are the most common responses: (1) never reach awareness that it's happening and continue to take flat at face value, (2) see it as opportunity and take advantage of it, and (3) see it as unnecessary game-playing and dislike it.

Whether 2 or 3 is better is an interesting question. It might separate the practical people from the idealists, or maybe it separates the self-interested from the more community-minded. I can see some of both, personally.

EDIT: I don't necessarily want to be completely dismissive of the idea. There's something to be said for creating situations that allow for people to stretch and try out new roles. That's how people develop. This is informal and stealthy, but it is a way to do that.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by munchbunny on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @04:18PM (#20159150)
I'm glad you brought this up, even though I disagree with your analysis.

In my experience, in the power vacuum there are several types of people:

1. Those who are blind to it

2. Those who want power and have charisma

3. Those who want power and lack charisma

4. Those who do not want the responsibility that comes with the power, but take it to save the team

5. Those who do not want the responsibility and explicitly avoid it

The problem is that those five categorizations are independent of competence, in terms of technical skills but especially in terms of leadership skills. So if you do this sort of social experiment, what you get are people who want power regardless of competence.

Now if that's what you're looking for, then by all means, do it, but I'd bet that you're actually hoping to find the capable ones, not the power seeking ones.

I don't have a good answer for how to set up a self-sustaining organization that consistently surfaces excellent leaders, because I've never seen one, but I'm pretty sure the power vacuum won't do better.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by dpeck on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @03:22PM (#20158659)
You may be overestimating how much management is paying attention. As long as things are shipped reasonably close to time and no one is filing lawsuits most stay more concerned with their own goals than that of their staff.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by adrianmonk on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @04:25PM (#20159204)
You raise a good point. Flat probably doesn't always work this way. It wouldn't be a good idea to assume that every flat organization is doing what I describe.

While I'd personally argue that people development is an essential duty of management, they may not see it as important. Also, in some cases, management may just see it as a way to be less rigid.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by blotter_paper on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @03:49PM (#20158907)
I like your cynical take, but I'm not convinced it's actually the goal of management in all cases. I could see it drifting in that direction over time regardless. That said, some founders are actually idealists. I frequently discuss this topic with people who are aware of the invisible hierarchy problem and are interested in potential solutions. I think there are well-meaning attempts at this, even if they don't work perfectly.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by veddox on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @04:17PM (#20159139)
> the invisible hierarchy problem

I'm not in favour of flat systems for exactly this reason. I think they try to solve the problem of bad leadership structurally, by simply pretending to abolish leadership. IMO, it would better be addressed personally - e.g. by investing in leadership training or vetting candidates for leadership roles more thoroughly.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by blotter_paper on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @04:45PM (#20159363)
I think some people, myself included, are coming at this with an ideological lense. The problem we want to solve isn't bad leadership, it's leadership in general. Hierarchy is a problem for us, and it's just as valid a problem to pick as human suffering or anything else. Coming at things from this angle, investing in leadership training is addressing a different problem entirely. I suspect that the "flat" organizations we've seen, such as Valve, have some pretty major shortcomings. I could see there being solutions to some of these shortcomings through technology and game-theory (decision making apps with specifics I don't know the details of), and I also think there might organizational structures somewhere between the traditional hierarchy and a flat structure where small hierarchies exist in a flat higher-level organization (I get how an interpretation of this can converge on the current higher-order ecosystem of corporations, but there are other directions you can take it).
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by wayoutthere on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @12:56PM (#20157215)
Exactly!

Business schools use a framework of formal power (job title, authority, etc) and informal power (influence and likability).

The most effective organizations are the ones where the formal power structures are very close to informal ones. People know how to make decisions. Flat organizations end up being run by the loudest voices in the room.

Ironically, flat organizations with largely informal power structures are often slower to make decisions because one person can become a huge bottleneck on decision making without realizing it. It can also be culturally corrosive: informal structures encourage Machiavellian behavior and the most Machiavellian people tend to rise to the top — which creates a terrible work environment for everyone else.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by iguy on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @02:55PM (#20158395)
"The most effective organizations are the ones where the formal power structures are very close to informal ones "

There's a nice parallel here to how parliamentary democracy arose. And conversely, there's no point having a chamber full of the people who you wish had power, if they don't have it.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by wayoutthere on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @03:19PM (#20158629)
I think there’s a more HN-relevant one in the way that founder-controlled companies seem to be capable of more growth. There’s not as much backstabbing and jockeying for power because everyone knows who the top dog is. The founder isn’t going to step down unless things go really well (everyone gets rich) or really poorly (everyone gets laid off) so you can’t stab them in the back and take their role. Founders can make decisions with a single vision — design by committee doesn’t produce innovation.

There tend to be problems when founders step back from the top of the formal power structure. Steve Jobs remains the best example I can think of; he wielded immense influence within Apple in the early 80s, but was ultimately a destructive presence once he no longer had formal power because he would go around his bosses to build his pet project (the original Macintosh) and created a corporate culture of distrust and deception. When he left, Apple fell apart culturally and really had no product vision until he rejoined a decade later and resumed the role of founder-CEO.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by iguy on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @04:40PM (#20159326)
Thanks, now I have this image of Jobs as the chief narco, menacing some UN-approved banana-republic democracy which really only controls a little green zone in the capital...
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by andrelaszlo on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @10:56AM (#20155964)
I agree with your point but in the end the article was more about efficient decision making in engineering teams and less about flat organizations. Up-voted both the article and your comment :)

Reminds me about the stuff I've read about Valve. In theory, and maybe if you have strong healthy de facto leadership it could work. In practice it seems more like an excuse to dodge responsibility, leading to pretty toxic places to work - but maybe there's another side to it.

https://twitter.com/PastelChum/status/1136470238265040896

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by papln on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:16AM (#20156153)
This is a common criticism of Valve's model, and it's fair to say that Valve's model isn't clearly obviously better, but those attack's on Valve don't make the case that the traditional hierarchical model, with its own well-known problems, is better.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by marcinzm on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:54AM (#20156559)
>This is a common criticism of Valve's model, and it's fair to say that Valve's model isn't clearly obviously better, but those attack's on Valve don't make the case that the traditional hierarchical model, with its own well-known problems, is better.

I would say that the key difference is that in the traditional model I can learn about my potential bosses during the interview process. In the valve model I don't even know who my bosses will be during the interview process. As people like to say, interviews are a two way process.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by narnianal on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @02:02PM (#20157877)
Also getting a shitty task might be a lot better than getting no task and then getting criticised for lack of ambition.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by blotter_paper on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @03:55PM (#20158956)
If finding tasks is part of your job that might be a fair criticism.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by EGreg on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @01:40PM (#20157649)
Do you have a good link about Valve’s model and are they a socialist / EMPLOYEE OWNED organization?

Update: I read about it and no, they are basically anarcho syndicalist and overall owned by a enligtened/benevolent set of owners.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by hinkley on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @03:19PM (#20158625)
Jeri Ellsworth after she pulled the ripcord:

https://www.wired.com/2013/07/wireduk-valve-jeri-ellsworth/

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by marcinzm on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @10:53AM (#20155943)
And in a company someone has the power to fire or promote you so there is explicit power in play. You can try to distribute it but people are social and clever so they’ll work around any blockers.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by ok_coo on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @12:12PM (#20156748)
In my professional experience, many fiefdoms get created in the shadow hierarchy of flat orgs.

Align/get yourself in one that works and is healthy for your development and you can thrive. If not, then leave as quickly as you can. Just MHO.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by organsnyder on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @12:50PM (#20157163)
In my experience, these shadow hierarchies exist in both flat and structured organizations. However, in structured organizations, there's the added challenge of figuring out how to navigate both the formal and shadow hierarchies simultaneously.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by erikpukinskis on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @10:59AM (#20155984)
There are shadow power structures, but I don't think you are correct that they are necessarily hierarchical.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by pault on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:02AM (#20156011)
Isn't hierarchy intrinsic to power?
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by ravenstine on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:18AM (#20156183)
You can have webs of power, but I've found that organizations that work this way have a lot of dysfunction. That's not to say that a hierarchy can't be dysfunctional, but I do think that well constructed hierarchies without tyrants are preferable to their "webbed" equivalent, since webs are almost always inefficient and serve to mask a lot of the power for the sake of a superficial form of equality or equity.

I won't name names, but a company that I worked for was very web-like, which felt good at first because it seems more "fair" or democratic, but it lead to constant confusion, infighting, communication failures, etc., and I discovered that it lead to two forms of employees: hogs that managed to eat more from the trough through clever maneuvering, and "homer simpsons" who figured out they could be lazy and not suffer serious consequences since their title was nebulous and the chain of command was diffuse(an individual with poor performance didn't reflect that badly on a superior).

The team that I worked on functioned mostly as a web, and that actually worked well because we were only 6 people at most, but an entire company functioning as a web is a nightmare.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by narnianal on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @02:14PM (#20158008)
you assume that organizations with inofficial power webs only have official goals? The inofficial goals might strive very well while the official organisation struggles. For instance I assume even if McDonalds shops struggle financially McDonalds itself is still quite happily collecting rent from them.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by ravenstine on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @05:52PM (#20159850)
Oh, I don't assume that, and you bring up a very good point that goes over most people's heads. In fact, it reminds me of how I learned that most organizations of appreciable size don't care much about efficiency. When things become more efficient, it not only rocks the boat, but people can be put out of work; once the cash-cow has been established, people want things to stay the same, lest they lose access to the udders of said cow. This is despite the fact that such an organization will publicly value "innovation", "creativity" and "hard work".
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by kd0amg on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:06AM (#20156046)
What's the hierarchical ordering of Congress, SCOTUS, and the White House?
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by pjc50 on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:11AM (#20156099)
The President appoints SCOTUS, so has the final say there. The critical fight was done by FDR: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judicial_Procedures_Reform_Bil...

Congress and President have, as I understand it, a mutual veto - but in the case where both are controlled by the same party, they tend to defer to the party organisation, which in turn defers to the President. Where they don't, you get shutdowns.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by icebraining on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:20AM (#20156203)
The President already appointed the SCOTUS before FDR, per the Appointments Clause of the US Constitution.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by SkyBelow on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @02:16PM (#20158026)
President tends to dictate congress when they are popular and congress is of the same party. While there can be some push back, it will become costly come election time. SCOTUS has strongly defined limits on what they can do, but given they are made up of picks by the President and approved by congress the shape of the SCOTUS changes depending upon whom is in power when the existing members leave.

The President is generally immune to congress until they do something that gets enough congressional support for impeachment. This has proven extremely hard to do so far. The President also gets significant say over any issue that doesn't strongly unify congress.

Thus, for an issue that is popular in congress and unpopular with the President, but not popular enough in congress to override a veto, the hierarchy does President > Congress (a > b means a is above b). SCOTUS almost never gets involved when it comes to passing laws.

When it comes to an issue that is popular enough congress is willing to override a veto and which is popular enough with voters that congress going against the President on it isn't a threat, then congress > President.

I don't think anyone is claiming there is a simple hierarchy that consistently applies regardless of scenario. Even in a classical monarchy the hierarchy can shift for extreme enough scenarios.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by sidlls on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:09AM (#20156080)
There are very clear hierarchies in Congress (Speaker/Majority Leader, Majority Whip, Committee Chairs) and White House (President, Vice President, Cabinet). There is no power structure in SCOTUS: each of the justices is equal and has nobody to answer to.

There are likely shadow organizations in the Congress and White House with their own (unpublished) hierarchy, but probably not in the SCOTUS due to its size and the implicit potency inherent in being a Justice.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by papln on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:19AM (#20156186)
SCOTUS is a nearly-pure democracy. Every issue of substance is put to a vote, and everyone has freedom to act individually in anything not put to vote, along with ample funding for their desires (law clerks for work, and indivual pay for personal perks). (Namely, Q&A in session, and what they write in their opinions.) Their scope of power is sufficiently limited that favor-trading isn't very important. All that remains are the minor traditional formalities of when and where they meet and how they dress.

When your group grows beyond 9 people, that gets harder.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by pmyteh on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:28AM (#20156283)
The internal politics are still interesting, though.

"The Brethren: Inside the Supreme Court" by Woodward and Armstrong looked (amongst other things) at why Nixon's new Chief Justice Warren Burger seemed unable to push the court in a more consistently conservative direction despite more conservative membership. Part of the conclusion was that he just wasn't that great at playing the internal political games required to stay in control.

Incidentally, the main source for that book was eventually revealed as one of the other Justices, Potter Stewart. It's a fascinating read.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by howard941 on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:25AM (#20156242)
Although Justices need not answer to anyone at all with perhaps the exception of defending themselves in their impeachment proceeding, the Chief does have some powers and duties, implicit ones such as designating authorship of a majority opinion when in the majority, and explicit ones such as administratively leading all of the Article II and III courts. The aclu's page is evenhanded and may be of interest. https://www.aclu.org/blog/speakeasy/role-chief-justice
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by fullshark on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:10AM (#20156094)
SCOTUS > White House > Congress but I get your point.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by DanGarthwaite on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:19AM (#20156191)
Only by convention and precedent. FDR's threats to pack the court certainly influenced them and if implemented would have subverted them.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by icebraining on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:28AM (#20156280)
FDR couldn't implement that by himself, though; the bill had to be approved by Congress.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by Retra on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:54AM (#20156555)
Convention and precedent (and tradition) are also forms of hierarchical power. Those who assert them in the course of making a decision exercise power over those who intend to deny them.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by papln on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:22AM (#20156217)
SCOTUS <> White House <> Congress

That's the 3 branches of government with its checks and balances.

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by Retra on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:54AM (#20156560)
Some of those checks and balances never get used.
Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by saltcured on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @01:53PM (#20157774)
I think it is a more practical relationship than something intrinsic. Power (or relative power, really) comes from consolidation and control of resources or agency. Hierarchy is a very efficient and scalable topology for command and control, helpful to manage such a consolidation.

But, other methods might be possible to wield power without hierarchy. An individual with massive wealth can consolidate financial power. They certainly depend on a system that enforces rules and protects financial interests, but can you really call that hierarchy? They might perform significant, world-changing transactions but they do not continue to control the assets once they are traded. It might be a hierarchical distribution in the "trickle-down" sense, but is not hierarchical control nor planning.

Or, if someone obtains some sort of scifi doomsday weapon and uses it to extort others, is that expressing hierarchy?

Re:No Kings: How Do You Make Good Decisions Efficiently in a... by McWobbleston on Tuesday June 11, 2019 @11:51AM (#20156517)
In my mind power is often innate, while hierarchy arises from exercising power. I wouldn't say there's a hierarchy between two entities until one begins to control the other