News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by arethuza on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:53AM (#20102801)
I hardly think this is surprising - countries that use the same reactors for power generation and production of materials for weapons are going to have some cross subsidies of some kind.

What I find surprising is that nobody ever comments on the fact that the UK literally operates US nuclear missiles with warhead designs heavily influenced by US designs. Not to mention the lack of permissive action locks on the UK weapons...

Edit: I should have been clearer that I meant was discussion outside of the UK about these issues.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by ggm on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:37AM (#20102995)
UK literally operates US nuclear missiles with warhead designs heavily influenced by US designs.

The thing being this was a negotiated outcome to prevent the destabilization of a system by the introduction of an independent nuclear source. France was bad enough: the Americans and Russians didn't want Britain making ICBM. (Obviously I doubt the Russians were consulted)

This is why black arrow was cancelled: the US promised Polaris if the UK ceased rocket tests in Australia.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by NotPaidToPost on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:46AM (#20103040)
As a "junior partner" it's good to see that the US allow us a few toys.
Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by ovi256 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @05:59AM (#20102833)
>same reactors for power generation and production of materials for weapons

This is mostly about the engineering capability for building submarine propulsion reactors, not weapons. Note the article never mentioned weapons. Sustaining that engineering capability through the lean years between submarine projects through power generation projects is seen by the pacifict environmentalist groups as a cross subsidy that they don't want to provide.

> warhead designs heavily influenced by US designs

Supposedly the UKs are domestic designs with more stealth and penetration aids.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by arethuza on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:02AM (#20102842)
Ah - my mistake - should have read the article more carefully!

We could always do what we did the last time we forgot how to build submarines and simply ask the US how to do it?

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by lmm on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:30AM (#20102959)
> What I find surprising is that nobody ever comments on the fact that the UK literally operates US nuclear missiles with warhead designs heavily influenced by US designs.

Huh? That's absolutely a common talking point whenever a conversation about "renewing Trident" or similar comes up.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by chrisseaton on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:53AM (#20103069)
> What I find surprising is that nobody ever comments on the fact that the UK literally operates US nuclear missiles with warhead designs heavily influenced by US designs.

The fact that they’re US designs was one of the major discussion points of the recent renewal debate - people from across the political spectrum commented on it extensively for months.

There are no PALs in order to support a credible threat of retaliation. The UK is small enough that it’s possible that the whole country would have been destroyed by a first strike. This is how nuclear weapons ‘work’ - by credible threat.

Re:UK energy bills 'used to subsidise nuclear submarines' by jibbit on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @06:03AM (#20102846)
Not sure what you mean by "no one ever talks about it". Which CND meetings have you been to?