Re:If 'Big Tech' Is an Antitrust Problem, Why Are We Ignorin...
by SmirkingRevenge on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @09:35AM
(#20104155)
I just check my block, and it's claiming 5 providers. Realistically, we have Spectrum, and that's really it.
It even claims we have AT&T fiber! Nearby neighborhoods do have it (along with google fiber) but not this one.
Re:If 'Big Tech' Is an Antitrust Problem, Why Are We Ignorin...
by paulddraper on Friday June 07, 2019 @12:44AM
(#20121715)
Everything I quoted was 2+ providers. I never claimed 5+ was common.
"Two long-term competitors are not enough for meaningful competition."
That is a legitimate argument.
The link below is for a NJ suburb , and lists 6 ISP competitors. But three of them are just satellite services and two are Verizon. In practice, there are exactly two competitors here: the phone monopoly and the cable monopoly, but the FCC would point to this to say that there's robust competition!
Here's another one I just picked at random, in a suburb of Oklahoma City.[2] The FCC lists 9 different providers. 3 of them are Satellite, 2 are Cox Cable, and 4 are AT&T. Again, there are exactly two competitors here: the phone monopoly and the cable monopoly. Look around yourself.
Two long-term competitors are not enough for meaningful competition. Duopoly competition has the same strategic profile as the Prisoner's Dilemma. When you have the same two players in the game over a long period of time, they learn to cooperate. See Axelrod (1980) etc...
Regulatory capture, juking the stats, crooks and liars all.
[1]: https://broadbandmap.fcc.gov/#/location-summary?version=dec2...
[2]: https://broadbandmap.fcc.gov/#/location-summary?version=dec2...