News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by elil17 on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @11:55PM (#20101343)
That’s really unrelated. I get that it seems analogous to you, but it’s weird to me that a cats claw is similar to a foreskin in your mind. Declawing is much more like cutting off the cats fingers
Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by balfirevic on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:18AM (#20101441)
They are both bodily mutilation of powerless non-consenting beings/individuals. I wouldn't call that unrelated.
Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by cheerlessbog on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @01:25AM (#20101719)
Isn't castration/spaying, too? Arguably that's in their own interest but we don't do it to non consenting humans so clearly there's different rules. Heck we keep them in captivity.
Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by balfirevic on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @01:32AM (#20101751)
It is. But rules are not arbitrarily different - they are, if anything, more protective of humans than cats. Which is why it's weird that declawing is not acceptable while circumcision is.
Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by serf on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @11:58PM (#20101357)
>That’s really unrelated.

it's a state-allowed form of mutilation for the sake of convenience, and very rarely medically indicated.

the furthest reach is that one is a human practice -- the rest of it seems pretty relatable.

Does the fact that cat declawing has no religious adherents bother you with regards to the comparison?

That's understandable, but it doesn't make the two less comparable, just more sensitive to argue about.

Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by hanniabu on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:30AM (#20101501)
Not quite the same in my book either. This would be more analogous to cutting off the tip of each of your fingers to the first knuckle.
Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by basementcat on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @11:49PM (#20101302)
Sometimes less controversial problems may be less important but easier to solve.
Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by p1necone on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @11:42PM (#20101274)
That's another, separate problem to be solved and doesn't make this change any less good.

Although I guess it is vaguely relevant as NY does have a large Jewish population.

Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by rurban on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @01:18AM (#20101685)
The Knesset outlawed it, and the fine there is a 1 year prison term, not just a minor $1000 slap.
[dead]
Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by elil17 on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:00AM (#20101366)
I think it’s pretty disingenuous to suggest that not allowing foreskin amputation nullifies all of Judaism. Many Jewish people whose parents decided not to circumcise them grow up to have fulfilling spiritual and cultural lives. No one does a dick check when you walk into synagogue.

There are many ways to maintain the symbolic importance of circumcision without resorting to unnecessary amputation, such as cutting a small mark in the foreskin to symbolize circumcision.

Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by MagicPropmaker on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @01:16AM (#20101677)
Sorry. It is a requirement for a male Jew. No other "method" is acceptable. For non-Jews, there's rarely a reason for it.

Any Jew who doesn't circumcise is operating outside the context of Judaism, and is doing something very non-Jewish.

Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by robin_reala on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:02AM (#20101376)
This really isn’t the forum for a religious discussion, but I have to say I’ve never understood this part. If you disengage Judaism from ethnicity to be purely a religion then, assuming freedom of religion, shouldn’t it be down to the child to make that decision at some point when society deems them capable of making a decision on their own (typically 16)?
Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by MagicPropmaker on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @01:17AM (#20101679)
Do you let your child decide if he should brush his teeth?
Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by TheAceOfHearts on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:19AM (#20101445)
Why not wait until they're adults and they can consent to the procedure?
Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by hanniabu on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:34AM (#20101518)
In addition to what the others have said, it's less painful and easier to have done when younger. This is like saying parents shouldn't be allowed to make kids go to school, they should wait until they're old enough to make the decision themselves. Sometimes parents need to make a decision for their children, it's only logical.
Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by dbtqgoat on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @01:43AM (#20101789)
That’s such bullshit reasoning. It’s weird, sick, body mutilation of a child without their consent.
Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by hanniabu on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:03PM (#20105756)
It's not bullshit at all. Let's look at it a different way. If a child has some physical mutation such as webbed feet, an extra finger, or some other physical difference that they wouldn't affect their health, you're telling me a doctor shouldn't ask if a parent would like to have something done about it and instead the child should grow up with that until they are old enough to give consent? When is a proper age for consent?
[dead]
Re:Cat Declawing Is Banned by New York State Lawmakers by andy_ppp on Wednesday June 05, 2019 @12:42AM (#20101557)
I think it’s correct that unnecessary operations should only be done with the full consent of those participating... and even then I’d question the reasoning behind them. Just saying ah fuck it, we just chop bits of your penis off without asking you because a made up book says to, is equivalent to saying individuals have certain inalienable rights to decide for themselves what is done to their bodies is beyond insane.