News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by ggambetta on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @07:24AM (#20093893)
I'm extremely interested in the topic (as I get older but happen to like living). However some people seem to think De Grey is a bit of a crackpot?
Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by kristofferR on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:31AM (#20094313)
He's far from a crackpot (negative connotations), eccentric would be a better term. Don't forget that De Grey has been one of the main popularizer of anti-aging science, and largely thanks to him there's now serious momentum behind it.

This recent interview with Aubrey de Grey is really worth listening to: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PMFST20xHwk

He seems to think that anti-aging science has speeded up drastically recently, both in terms of the science itself, the funding and the popularity. I really love what the SENS Foundation is doing in terms of spinning research avenues into startups, since most investors are far more likely to fund high-risk investments than non-profit ones.

He also mentions other positive developments in terms of legislation and advocacy.

Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by nabla9 on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:03AM (#20094537)
His research agenda and goal is outrageously challenging and controversial and he might be a too overconfident. There is good reason to be skeptical, but he is not a crackpot. Attempting to do something that may turn out to be impossible or wrong approach is not crackpottery.

His work of identifying reasons of aging seems really reasonable. Trying to reverse every one of those is incredible challenge. It's the biggest moonshot ever attempted.

Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by solveit on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:55PM (#20100624)
> and he might be a too overconfident

It's pretty much a law of nature that the pioneers in any field will be overconfident. If they weren't, they never would've tried.

Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by Beltiras on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @07:30AM (#20093922)
Well, we've had some wonderful crackpots through the ages. Tesla comes to mind.

Whatever you think about his idea of escape velocity you can't doubt the engineering approach he advocates makes sense. Solve these 7 problems [1] and there will be no reason the organism should die.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aubrey_de_Grey#The_seven_types...

Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by nudpiedo on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @07:52AM (#20094062)
I can doubt of the engineering approach he advocates, because I am aware that people like me is completely an outsider in this branch of science and I cannot differentiate a charlatan from an actual scientist.

You could fool a person ignorant enough in a speciality with statements such as:

- To fly we just need a way to defeat gravity.

- To resurrect a body we just need to insufflate the soul back to the body.

- To make a head transplant we just need to reconnect the nerves and wait the meat to glue.

- An artificial intelligence will solve our company's problem.

This ver same person could be highly skilled or smart in other aspects. The more technical or scientific we sound the more a subject will give authority to the charlatan.

I ignore if these statements made by this person are overall valid, if the list is exhaust and if the things there are additional factors I ignore. Even in such case we also ignore the deepness of the problem and circumstances related.

Most of people, including myself, are no biologist or cryonogists and have not enough knowledge on that level, in addition it is in the human nature to have high hopes in self perpetuating ourselves. Thats the perfect ground for charlatans to grow.

Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by kristofferR on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:53AM (#20094468)
Charlatans sell stuff. De Grey funds stuff: https://www.sens.org/srf-publications/

Pretty massive difference.

Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by nudpiedo on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:09AM (#20095177)
I think funding doesn't qualify or disqualify him, if funding would give extra credibility points, tomorrow all charlatans of the world would fund something. He also raises big amounts of money and offers no results and that fact alone does imply nothing by itself.

P.D. many bluff companies have also lots of publications, papers etc... and that doesn't mean that they are innovative.

Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by Beltiras on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:50AM (#20094439)
Your list lacks detail where AdG includes very specific things to solve.
Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by nudpiedo on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:05AM (#20095122)
First of all, being specific doesn't mean irrefutable, correct or that it makes actual sense. My statements only seem unspecific because they are ridiculous for an educated person in our current century (although many educated people from our century felt for the last one.)

I don't want to turn that example in an exaggerated dichotomy, but my point is that for someone who lacks skill or knowledge on a deeply complex topic, most of the time by using the specific jargon the person will sounds specific, professional, serious,... they will automatically sound like an expert or authority in the subject.

In other words, I don't think most of people here in this forum, and for sure not myself, is qualified enough to say whether the first sentence is more specific or realizable than the second one:

- We need to find a way to fix mutations in mitochondria by looking at the telanoma and several teams of scientists are looking at that.

- To resurrect a body we just need to insufflate the soul back to the body and several teams of sorcerers are looking at that.

And even if my examples are not good enough, this whole thing could be the "detox" fashion that happened a years ago, just on a different level/topic for a different target audience who needs more complicated words in order to be tricked.

Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by WilliamEdward on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @07:37AM (#20093957)
okay thats great but how do i solve these problems? I don't have encyclopaedic knowledge on all things that can cause mutations and cell damage.
Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by naasking on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:52AM (#20094456)
> okay thats great but how do i solve these problems?

de Grey's list is about guiding research directions, it's not for ordinary people to use.

Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by Beltiras on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @08:45AM (#20094399)
It's important enough a "discovery" in and of itself to come up with the definitive list. You can't solve a problem if you don't know what it is.
Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by nradov on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:02AM (#20094535)
Solve those 7 problems and we'll probably find an 8th.
Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by Beltiras on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @09:19AM (#20094691)
Perhaps. But solving those 7 will increase longevity by leaps and bounds.
Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by snvzz on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @10:14AM (#20095219)
This list has been stuck at 7 for a _very_ long time.
Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by ilaksh on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @11:23AM (#20095860)
People were saying he was a crackpot just because he was saying that it was possible to defeat aging before it was cool to say that.

He is the leader who put himself out there and made it possible for all of these mainstream scientists to pursue anti-aging research seriously in the open.

By the way,his theory is still better than a what many of the mainstream scientists propose because he attributes aging to a more comprehensive (and therefore more realistic) set of problems.

Take a look at http://sens.org

Its actually similar to how people claimed Ben Goertzel was a crackpot, just because he was willing to promote AGI research when it wasn't cool. It always takes some 'crackpots' (i.e. leaders) to do something unfashionable before it can become fashionable and accepted.

Notice how this article doesn't mention de Grey. That is another unfortunate social aspect. The true leaders in science often go unacknowledged. Because society operates as a popularity contest, not a meritocracy.

Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by amelius on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @07:32AM (#20093930)
Could be but he also published a well-received paper on graph coloring, so at least he's not stupid.

https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.02385

Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by foldr on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @07:43AM (#20094004)
Newton published plenty of crackpot works on Alchemy and Biblical exegesis in addition to the Principia. Smart people often say the stupidest things.
Re:With greater longevity, the quest to avoid infirmities of... by kkarakk on Tuesday June 04, 2019 @07:29AM (#20093918)
The beard says it all