Re:On YouTube’s Digital Playground, an Open Gate for Pedophiles
by JorgeGT on Monday June 03, 2019 @12:10PM
(#20084769)
This reminds me of the day I disabled Youtube history, suggestions, etc: I sometimes listen in Youtube to old civil war-era songs from my country, Spain (my great uncle was a partisan who fought against the fascists). Once I left the autoplay engaged and returned to my Youtube feed filled with current neonazi/extreme-right/conspiracy recommendations.
Retracing the browser history, it went something like: historic recordings of civil war/partisan songs -> later recordings by popular musicians of the most vanilla/famous ones -> current renditions of the old songs by extremist groups -> crazy political propaganda from those extremist groups.
As you say, it was a first hand experience of what unsupervised, mindless optimization looks like. Ethics are not factored in the merit function, so they just don't exist for the machine.
Retracing the browser history, it went something like: historic recordings of civil war/partisan songs -> later recordings by popular musicians of the most vanilla/famous ones -> current renditions of the old songs by extremist groups -> crazy political propaganda from those extremist groups.
As you say, it was a first hand experience of what unsupervised, mindless optimization looks like. Ethics are not factored in the merit function, so they just don't exist for the machine.