News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by mushufasa on Sunday June 02, 2019 @06:37PM (#20078818)
1 - no. The constitution explicitly only applies to US citizens / on US soil.

That's the legal rationale for a lot of 'bad behavior' such as PRISM -- they can intercept undersea cable traffic to legally spy on foreigners, as foreigners lack constitutional rights. Nothing new there.

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by jMyles on Sunday June 02, 2019 @06:55PM (#20078926)
> 1 - no. The constitution explicitly only applies to US citizens / on US soil.

Why on earth do you say such things? Like, seriously, what's the point of saying something so easily refuted? Is this just to be inflammatory for the sake of it?

The suggestion that the US Bill of Rights only applies to citizens is so unbelievably toxic and contrary to the history of the country I am saddened to even read the words.

The Bill of Rights intentionally does not even include the word "citizen" and instead uses "people."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Bill_of_Rights

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by nothrabannosir on Sunday June 02, 2019 @08:16PM (#20079373)
> Why on earth do you say such things? Like, seriously, what's the point of saying something so easily refuted? Is this just to be inflammatory for the sake of it?

I imagine your reply came from a good place and you're genuinely trying to improve the knowledge out here, but I just want to take a moment to address something that comes up often: this tone is very combative and it makes it incredibly hard for someone to yield and turn to you. What is OP supposed to say to this? "Oh I guess you're right. Thanks for taking my pride and putting me down. I see your point now." -- this is not how people work.

Or, from another angle: you can usually tell a sarcastic question is off, if the honest answer is readily found, and defensible. In this case: OP said such things because they thought it was true. The point was to share information with someone else and contribute to a conversation.

If you think they're wrong, there's more productive ways of getting that point across than calling into question good faith.

For the record: I thought it as well, so there were at least two of us, out here ;) and now after Googling, and judicial rabbitholes far beyond my expertise I still can't tell whether it's limited geographically or also meant to apply world-wide, or how I was meant to know, to avoid getting told off for being toxic if I ever daresay something else about it...

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by jMyles on Sunday June 02, 2019 @08:44PM (#20079493)
You're right of course.

But I also think that there is a palpable and strange injection into the zeitgeist a notion that non-citizens are less human - and it comes at the same time that a lot of racism and anti-immigrant ideology is reaching its way into public policy.

I'm finding myself with decreased patience for it than I might have for other falsehoods making their way through echo chambers.

But yeah, that's probably my bad.

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by refurb on Sunday June 02, 2019 @08:22PM (#20079388)
Sorry, having good intentions means nothing when you’re spreading falsehoods that could easily be checked with a quick google search.

The one thing I appreciated about HN is the signal to noise ratio. Plenty of comments are actually insightful, but the one in question is just noise.

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by mushufasa on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:36PM (#20079973)
after reading through your comments, I'm not convinced that I was spreading a falsehood. The fact that there are some legal policies on treatment of non-nationals is not the same thing as non-nationals being fully protected by constitutional rights. They are not. Other comments above have also said this. (I submitted simultaneously as someone who gave a better phrased answer but couldn't figure out how to delete my redundant comment).

> palpable and strange injection into the zeitgeist a notion that non-citizens are less human

I did not and would not ever suggest that non-citizens are less than human. I am puzzled and saddened that my words were taken that way. If anything, I was attempting to point out that the US policies have a problematic history of prioritizing its own citizens at the expense of human rights globally. That's a longer conversation, and this thread is one example.

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by tagrun on Sunday June 02, 2019 @07:11PM (#20079021)
Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by jMyles on Sunday June 02, 2019 @07:16PM (#20079041)
Kleindienst v. Mandel does not take a stance on the matter of the reach of the Bill of Rights to foreign nationals and was instead decided on different grounds.

The fact that the government can be compelled to allow US citizens to cross the border irrespective of any enumerated standards is orthogonal to the reach of the first amendment to non-citizens. These are entirely different legal matters, and the case you're linking to was decided entirely on the former and not the latter.

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by tagrun on Sunday June 02, 2019 @07:33PM (#20079151)
I have 0 expertise on my own country's law, let alone US law or some specific cases in your (?) country. But that's not what Wikipedia says:

"Speech rules as to deportation, on the other hand, are unclear. Lower courts are divided on the question, while the leading cases on the subject are from the Red Scare."

It refers to multiple cases, not just the one you cherry picked. And it says the courts are divided, which implies that some judges did not agree with your narrative. Now I don't know it's about amendments or laws or some footnote or whatever you call it in legalese. The bottom line is (and that's what would matter to a foreigner), this doesn't sound like foreigners have the same level of free speech protections as citizens do at the border or within the country, and implies that they can be punished in one way or another for what they say. It won't matter to people who get deported or rejected entry whether they were rejected based on nth amendment or mth law, so your point is entirely irrelevant.

Now you can argue that this is probably the case in other nations, and it could well be. But I don't see other people here trying to portray it's all roses in their country.

Again, this isn't about whether some amendment or footnote extends to non-citizens, or some particular case. Those are just details, which won't matter if there's even just one piece of law or regulation (such as this new social media details requirement) that discriminates foreigners. So try to remember what this whole topic is about, and look at the bigger picture, from the perspective of a foreigner.

Edit You apparently prefer to double down on details which don't matter (for people who'll be negatively affected by such regulations), which is fine, but I don't really care enough to write another reply. Maybe if you travel abroad someday in the future, you can try asking how people who got their US visa application denied because of their social media postings "enjoyed" their rights.

Also, you're claiming in your reply that the Wikipedia page is wrong and implying the reference therein is unreliable, maybe you can fix it if you're sure there was no case in the history which makes it unclear, and cite a better reference?

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by jMyles on Sunday June 02, 2019 @07:45PM (#20079219)
"cherry picked"? I pointed you directly to the decision that SCOTUS rendered on this matter.

And I don't understand the point you're trying to make: even the dissent acknowledged that Mandel had no first amendment protections while outside the country - this has nothing to do with citizenship.

Literally nobody - not the majority nor either dissent, said anything whatsoever about citizenship being an issue here.

If a non-citizen were not subject to the enumerated standard test here (ie, if they were a permanent resident), they'd be in the exact same boat as a citizen.

This entire line of jurisprudence has absolutely nothing to do with the question of whether the Bill of Rights extends to non-citizens (and to be absolutely clear: it does.).

> "Speech rules as to deportation, on the other hand, are unclear. Lower courts are divided on the question, while the leading cases on the subject are from the Red Scare."

So let me get this straight - WikiPedia cites Eugene Volokh discussing a matter on which there has been no case or controversy and no court has rendered an opinion, and this is your basis to say that the unambiguous tradition, predating the founding, of rights being enjoyed by non-citizens within the United States is "unclear"? Please tell me that you can see how ridiculous this sounds.

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by AaronFriel on Sunday June 02, 2019 @06:46PM (#20078872)
I think it's more complicated than that, with the constitutional protections from US government action being narrower outside the US border depending on the legal status of the person(s) in question and the context of the imposition on their rights.

So-called unlawful enemy combatants have limited rights and the Supreme Court has upheld all sorts of limitations on the rights of US citizens apprehended in a theater of war, but even foreign citizens have a constitutional right to habeas corpus when apprehended by the government on foreign soil (Boumediene v. Bush).

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by dudul on Sunday June 02, 2019 @06:58PM (#20078944)
The constitution applies to anybody living on US soil.
Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by archey1 on Sunday June 02, 2019 @07:25PM (#20079100)
Try buying a firearm while on a tourist visa.
Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by jMyles on Sunday June 02, 2019 @07:59PM (#20079298)
People in the United States on tourist visas are not prohibited from bearing arms (in fact gun ranges are major tourist destinations in some parts of the country). Purchasing arms is subject to a higher legal standard, but is also not wholesale prohibited, just subject to a few extra rules. For example, a tourist who acquires a hunting license in any state can purchase a firearm.

...and in any case, this is not a citizen/non-citizen issue, as GP claims - lawful permanent residents have the same 2nd amendment rights as citizens.

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by sgjohnson on Sunday June 02, 2019 @08:24PM (#20079400)
Get a hunting licence and you can do that.
Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by archey1 on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:58PM (#20080055)
Well yes, but that is a privilege that the country bestows upon you as a token of good will and faith - not a natural right under the constituion; and I would not expect it either. Should I be allowed the affordances of the 1st amendment while on American soil to advocate for the fall of the American republic? I would be deported very swiftly.
Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by llukas on Sunday June 02, 2019 @07:36PM (#20079166)
You missed "well regulated Militia" part of second amendment.
Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by archey1 on Sunday June 02, 2019 @10:48PM (#20080020)
In the time the constitution was framed, "well regulated" meant properly trained and not "subject to 30 million pages of government control and criminilization".

If you want to cherry pick certain parts of the second amendment - I can do that too: "the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed".

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by llukas on Monday June 03, 2019 @01:34AM (#20080635)
Please stick with weapons available at time constitution was written of not very reliable ~3 shots per minute fire rate. Gunpowder cannons are also OK.

Law evolves along with technical progress and 2nd amendment is not exception.

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by jki275 on Monday June 03, 2019 @02:17AM (#20080805)
When you write your reply on parchment with elderberry ink, seal it with wax, and have it delivered by pony express we can have a discussion on the limitations you are proposing on the first amendment with your long debunked argument.

Also there were repeating rifles, cartridge based rifles, and citizens owned artillery pieces and war ships in the era in which the Constitution was written.

You should read Heller - Justice Scalia wrote a great deal about your argument and why it is absurd.

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by llukas on Monday June 03, 2019 @02:44AM (#20080931)
False equivalence. First amendment understanding evolved since 1789 [1]. Protecting speech of corporations was unthinkable in 1789.

[1] https://www.brennancenter.org/blog/constant-evolution-first-...

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by jki275 on Monday June 03, 2019 @11:46AM (#20084451)
It has to a very small degree.

But not to the point of banning speech.

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by llukas on Monday June 03, 2019 @08:20PM (#20090502)
There were entire areas unknown in 1789 - incorporating them is basically writing law again (see example below). Reliable fully automatic weapons that can do up to 1000rpm belong to same category.

https://mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/1044/communications...

"The 1934 act designated broadcasters as speakers — thus granting them First Amendment rights — but the broadcast media were also treated as possessing a somewhat lesser claim to First Amendment protections than the print media. The Supreme Court’s decision in Red Lion Broadcasting Co. v. Federal Communications Commission (1969) upheld the principle that the scarcity of frequencies put broadcasters under public obligations to present multiple viewpoints, which therefore served as limits on their First Amendment rights."

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by jki275 on Monday June 03, 2019 @10:04PM (#20091093)
Civilians owned cannon, artillery pieces and warships in the revolutionary war time frame.

A machine gun is nothing compared to a strategic asset. If we want to go back to that model, which is what you argue for, I'm getting a Davy Crockett for my front yard, an Iowa class BB for my dock, and a squadron of F22s and F35s.

Who cares about an M16 at that point.

You're arguing something that simply isn't so.

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by archey1 on Monday June 03, 2019 @07:18AM (#20082026)
The framers wanted the people to have access to the same weapons the government did - to allow the people to have a very real check over the overreach of said government.

Benjamin Franklin was an inventor - if you think when they wrote the second amendment they didn't think "gee, maybe guns will shoot faster someday" then I don't know what to tell you.

Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by stOneskull on Sunday June 02, 2019 @06:54PM (#20078922)
They're supposed to be God-given rights
Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by tagrun on Sunday June 02, 2019 @07:16PM (#20079049)
Except they're not, they're man-made laws. (I don't believe in any deity or religion but arguing on delusions is beyond the point.)
Re:US demands social media details from visa applicants by stOneskull on Monday June 03, 2019 @10:49PM (#20091314)
as in people have the right to free speech, not just citizens. in this man-made document for this nation, it says people are born with rights, and so that belief must extend to people outside the nation. they were born too.