News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Net worth of Americans aged 18 to 35 has dropped 34 perce... by whatshisface on Saturday June 01, 2019 @04:04PM (#20071310)
>All politics is identity politics.

That's only true if you define the term broadly enough to be useless. What about, say, anti-war demonstrations during Vietnam?

Re:Net worth of Americans aged 18 to 35 has dropped 34 perce... by spamizbad on Saturday June 01, 2019 @05:00PM (#20071663)
It’s less literal than that.

You can think of the whole cosmopolitan urban vs salt-of-the-earth rural aspect of American politics as one example. Or southern identity/culture. “As a veteran who served”/“As a parent”, or the cross-denomination “moral majority”— it’s all based around the idea that your lived experience as something shapes your political perspective and is intrinsically valuable to the political conversation.

And even Occupy: was occupy simply making a statement about economic politics or was it the identity of “the 1%” or “Bankers” vs the rest of Americans? These categories were somewhat arbitrary and basically represented which group you identified with.

Re:Net worth of Americans aged 18 to 35 has dropped 34 perce... by whatshisface on Saturday June 01, 2019 @05:19PM (#20071764)
That's what I mean by defining the phrase so broadly it becomes useless. You can say, "I am, and I have an identity, therefore my politics is identity politics." However, identity politics is specifically when the tribal motivations exceed and dominate all other motivations. It's similar to how islands are not called bodies of water even though soil contains water.
Re:Net worth of Americans aged 18 to 35 has dropped 34 perce... by spamizbad on Saturday June 01, 2019 @05:30PM (#20071822)
> However, identity politics is specifically when the tribal motivations exceed and dominate all other motivations.

Then the term "identity politics" shouldn't be applied. But even if we accept that extremely narrow view: there are numerous political segments that are notorious for doing what you describe across the political spectrum. Most notable the rural Scotch-Irish, often criticized for routinely voting against their self-interest and instead choosing to vote for pols who simply provide them cultural validation and do nothing to address their material concerns.

Re:Net worth of Americans aged 18 to 35 has dropped 34 perce... by User23 on Saturday June 01, 2019 @04:07PM (#20071340)
Parent should have been more specific: all politics is identity politics in a multi-ethnic and multi-religious state. The USA of the Vietnam war no longer exists, and isn't comparable to the USA of today.

In a nation state, politics tend to be divided more on ideological and regional lines, because everyone shares an identity.

Re:Net worth of Americans aged 18 to 35 has dropped 34 perce... by scroblart on Saturday June 01, 2019 @06:22PM (#20072064)
This is very weird comment. Are you saying that the USA was not a multi-ethnic/multi-religious state in the 1960s?

In a nation state, politics tend to be divided more on ideological and regional lines, because everyone shares an identity. There has never been a "nation" where everybody shares an identity in the sense discussed above.

Re:Net worth of Americans aged 18 to 35 has dropped 34 perce... by hyperdunc on Saturday June 01, 2019 @07:45PM (#20072513)
The comment makes sense, but the US isn't best example. Although last century the US was somewhat dominated by one identity (which is now waning and leaving room for others to grow) it has always been multi-ethnic and multi-religious.

A better example would be European nations like Hungary, which have reinforced their national identities in the face of the recent migrant crisis.

[dead]
Re:Net worth of Americans aged 18 to 35 has dropped 34 perce... by dang on Sunday June 02, 2019 @03:06AM (#20073988)
We've asked you repeatedly to stop doing ideological flamewar on HN. A crazy number of times actually. Would you please really stop now so we don't have to ban you?

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Net worth of Americans aged 18 to 35 has dropped 34 perce... by spamizbad on Sunday June 02, 2019 @01:23AM (#20073637)
If you define "British origin" to include Irish Protestants, which is reasonable.. But the country was barely 50 years old by the time that cultural hegemony started eroding as German, Dutch, Irish-Catholics, etc poured into the country.

There's even an infamous 1899 political cartoon that asks "Why should I let these freaks cast whole votes when they're only half American?"[1]

The fact is, the US has spent a majority of its existence feeling like there's an immigration and/or integration crisis, starting in the mid-1800s with Irish-Catholics and stretching to the modern day with Latin-American immigrants.

[1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/b9/Hy...

Re:Net worth of Americans aged 18 to 35 has dropped 34 perce... by selimthegrim on Saturday June 01, 2019 @11:01PM (#20073194)
Uh, Pennsylvania Dutch much? Regular Dutch in NY, for that matter? German as the national language being a possibility?

If you want to mourn the WASPs Stewart Alsop might ring your bell better.

Re:Net worth of Americans aged 18 to 35 has dropped 34 perce... by scroblart on Sunday June 02, 2019 @02:46AM (#20073912)
American, which is an ethnic group of British origin lol. Why would you ever say this?

Charitably, I assume that you are a troll out for giggles, rather than an actual white supremacist.

Re:Net worth of Americans aged 18 to 35 has dropped 34 perce... by dang on Sunday June 02, 2019 @03:07AM (#20073990)
Would you please stop posting uncivil and unsubstantive comments to HN? We ban accounts that do that.

Instead, please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here. We'd appreciate it very much.

Re:Net worth of Americans aged 18 to 35 has dropped 34 perce... by scroblart on Sunday June 02, 2019 @03:15AM (#20074014)
Please examine the post to which I replied.

===

Edit: sorry I see that you did. Thanks