WHY I INTERVIEW TIM:
1) Eric Ries once told me how a tiny change to a marketing page is worth hours of recoding. I believe there are little changes that have big significance and Tim is good at identifying and explaining them.
2) There are loads of books about health, but his is going to be a top seller. I'm curious about what it is about the way he presents & markets ideas that help him stand out.
3) Tim Ferriss gets a lot of attention. This response would be incomplete if I didn't admit that Tim's name got my other work a lot of hits, and it will continue to. He has fans that still tweet about an interview that I did with him over a year ago.
WHAT I COULD HAVE DONE BETTER:
1) I should have addressed some of his health claims. It's outside the scope of my work to talk about health, but if we brought it up, I needed to talk about opposing research.
2) I might have been too fawning at the end. I always love my guests, but at the end of an interview, when someone sits for 1 hour and answers questions, I'm prone to gushing out of gratitude.
Yet I wonder how I could have become so cynical as to doubt the "socially redeeming value" of an ~author~ who gets a book published by including claims such as:
> YOU WILL LEARN (in less than 30 minutes each):
> How to lose those last 5-10 pounds (or 100+ pounds) with odd combinations of food and safe chemical cocktails.
> * How to prevent fat gain while bingeing (X-mas, holidays, weekends)
> * How to increase fat-loss 300% with a few bags of ice
> * How Tim gained 34 pounds of muscle in 28 days, without steroids, and in four hours of total gym time
> * How to sleep 2 hours per day and feel fully rested
> * How to produce 15-minute female orgasms
> * How to triple testosterone and double sperm count
> * How to go from running 5 kilometers to 50 kilometers in 12 weeks
> * How to reverse “permanent” injuries
> * How to add 150+ pounds to your lifts in 6 months
> * How to pay for a beach vacation with one hospital visit
I enjoy fitness. I've worked out four to five days a week for the past seven years, first at a climbing gym, and then with Crossfit. I've competed in fitness competitions. I've know a number of well-respected high-level Crossfitters. I would call myself, at the very least, a fitness enthusiast.
I think some of these claims are at best, laughable, and, at worst, will give false hope to people who might truly be interested in fitness. Fitness is hard work!
> * How Tim gained 34 pounds of muscle in 28 days, without steroids, and in four hours of total gym time
Muscle memory will allow people to gain significant amounts of muscle in short periods of time, if that muscle has been trained before.
It's why athletes who take rest periods or have injuries are able to come back just as strong in only a few weeks.
It's the source of many of the before/after pictures for "health foods" and supplements.
If you're actually interested in gaining muscle and weight, the easiest way is to eat tons of food and do heavy, compound exercises three to four times a week.
> * How to sleep 2 hours per day and feel fully rested
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyphasic_sleep
Anecdotally, a friend of mine ended up in the emergency room for severe dehydration after trying the Uberman's Sleep Cycle for three weeks.
> * How to triple testosterone and double sperm count
I imagine he's be talking about various supplements here. Supplement science is sketchy, and should always be taken with a grain of salt.
The best way to take supplements is to not take them, but rather, eat more fruits and vegetables.
> * How to go from running 5 kilometers to 50 kilometers in 12 weeks
Pretty simple, actually. There are progressive running plans in almost any running book.
Also, the difference between five and 50 km, at least to your muscles, is much less than the difference between 400M and 5K. It's just training your aerobic system and converting more of your muscle tissue to slow-twitch muscle fibers.
> * How to reverse “permanent” injuries
Eat right and exercise correctly.
If you read the forums for crossfit, or stronglifts, or a number of other fitness websites, or diet websites, you'll see people who miraculously cure their bad back, bad knees or diabetes, just by eating right and exercising correctly.
> * How to add 150+ pounds to your lifts in 6 months
This is almost guaranteed to happen when someone goes from an untrained state to the beginning of a trained state. It has to do with muscles learning to be used, rather than significant strength gains.
When I started Crossfit three years ago, I could barely deadlift 135#. Three years later, my last 1RM deadlift was 455#. Going from 135# to 300# was _so_ much easier and faster than going from 300# to 455#, because my body had always been able to do it, it just didn't know it.
You're talking 5 intense months to safely train minimum, for a person who can run 5 km.
Training for a 50 km isn't "just aerobics", it's also about strengthening your bones and ligaments and developing the mental tools you'll need to finish. It's about learning what your body needs to stay hydrated. Learning how to minimize calorie use. Learn how to run through the walls (yes, plural, there's normally two of them on a 50 km run). How to eat on the run without throwing it all up or squirting it out from your shorts. Aerobics is the least of it, IMHO.
12 weeks is a laughable claim.
And yes, I've run 50km (and far beyond) in one go.
You aren't going to go from a 5k to a 50k in 12 weeks and remain injury-free, sorry.
5 weeks training, 43 marathons in 50 days.
This is more akin to hiking a flat version of the Appalachian Trail than running 50 km straight.
It's more complicated than that. Actual muscle mass has less to do with being strong than leverage and nervous system development.
Leverage is genetic and there's not much you can do about having long arms.
What you call "muscle memory" is the strength and frequency of nervous system signaling - most strength gains come from changes in the nervous system.
That's why there's tons of drug-free power and weightlifters who don't have a ton of muscles but are extremely strong. Conversely, there's tons of bodybuilders using steroids who can't actually lift all that much. This is because muscle mass is mostly dependent on hormones.
You don't gain muscle by lifting weights so much as you raise your testosterone level by lifting weights, which promotes muscle growth.
So athletes can come back quickly in terms of strength, but not so much size.
From what I read about Tim's "muscle gain" advice (he posted the story on his blog) it was mostly just water and fat. I bet he started out by dehydrating before the experiment, too. Assuming you start out slim it's very easy to gain 34 pounds in a month by drinking water, eating a ton of high-carb foods and taking creatine (I've done ~20 pounds in two weeks this way to go up a weight class). The only way you're going to gain any muscle that way is with weightlifting (a lot more than 4 hours) or steroids, and preferably both.
Then the book isn't telling how to "gain 35 pounds of muscle". It's telling how to restore 35 pounds of muscle you recently had.
Which is significantly different from "add 35 new pounds of muscle".
My favorite thing about Tim Ferriss are the video podcasts that he does with Kevin Rose. They're posted on his blog ("Random episode X"), and they're usually pretty interesting (the one they did when traveling around China comes to mind), though not mind blowing.
As for the rest, I try to be inspired by his energy at trying new things and being methodical about learning, but I don't really follow him on most of the specifics of what he does.
I find that the best way to deal with self-promoting people is to ignore them. I have a limited amount of attention and brain space, and I really don't have time for Tim Ferriss trying to cram himself into every nook and cranny of it.
Besides, Tim Ferriss is a cunt. If you try to learn from his example you'll become a cunt too.
(Interesting: my spellcheck flags "cunt" as misspelled. How else would you spell it?)
I find Tim way more inspiring than "yet another discussion on how $TECHNOLOGY_X is {dead,the hottest thing since sliced bread}."
YMMV.
So are the Chinese dudes who put melamine in the milk and formula they sold, poisoning untold numbers of children while increasing their profits by selling watered-down milk. (The melamine tested as protein, covering up the dilution.)
That was a hack. Same with 'hackers' who use shoddy building materials resulting in buildings that collapse.
Hackers like that are a dime a dozen. It's not anything I'd want to emulate. And I certainly wouldn't want to hire someone who thought along such lines.
* Have you read the book?
* Do you have thoughts of your own about why Tim Ferris's methods cannot be applied to exercise?
If so, I would be genuinely delighted to read them.
That's not really my style either but it is a bit amusing that he did it.
I guess I just have a filter for those things. I'm mostly inspired by his unconventional thinking and the idea of non-conformity. Even if I don't agree with everything he says, I love that he's always looking for different and better (at least to him) ways of doing things.
One line from the 4HWW "Ask for forgiveness, not permission," can change the way you address challenges for the rest of your life. I'm really looking forward to seeing what insights he's put into the new book.
But overdo it and people will think you're an asshole.
Agree! Note this from the bottom of the page:
cloudsponge – Your users have friends. cloudsponge gives you their address books. (Now get 3 free months by using this discount code: MIXERGY)
Don't get me wrong; I understand that you're a journalist and want to keep an open mind. No question about the popularity of this person and his subject.
I just don't think that he or his message are very inspiring. While most of us here work hard building stuff for the benefit of others, this guy just hacks the system for personal benefit. Whether it's gaming the rules to win a martial arts contest, front loading phony book reviews, or making outrageous claims that spawn counterproductive behavior, I really don't want to know about it; I've read enough.
The world already has enough hustlers, charletons, and posers. I'd rather see you spend your time continuing to bring us the real inspiration the has given mixergy such a great track record.
Just my .02.
[EDIT: Just a quick follow-up to those who have disagreed. I don't hate Tim Ferriss. I don't accuse him of lying or deceiving. And I don't question whether or not his methods are effective. (Spam is effective, something else I would never do.)
When I read his last book, I was totally turned off when he claimed winning a martial arts contest by finding a loophole in the rules and shoving his opponent out of bounds. I have never done anything like that and have no intention of learning anything similar.
There's so much inspiring stuff to read here and in books that I see no need to follow up on something I've already ruled out. I was just a little surprised to see Tim Ferriss and mixergy in the same post. That's all.]