News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by ZhuanXia on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:02PM (#20053355)
Anyone paying attention to cognitive genomics knows wide-spread germ-line engineering is inevitable. The gains are just too great. Once we know the causal variants, raising IQ by 5+ standard deviations will be very feasible. In the short term (next 5-10 years) half a standard deviation is possible with single-trait embryo selection.

And iterated embryo selection (which does not require knowing the causal variants, just the predictive ones) will also be possible, and offers 5+ SDs.

Gwern has a great write about about it here: https://www.gwern.net/Embryo-selection

With this in mind, does anyone really think China and Singapore will not embrace this? And if they do it and we do not we would be as children compared to them.

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by danarlow on Thursday May 30, 2019 @02:47PM (#20054602)
This is not correct reasoning about genetics. I've seen a lot of comments with this same incorrect claim on HN recently. In a complex trait like IQ, there is no reason to believe that stacking all of the alleles that each are individually associated with small gains in IQ will result in a large cumulative effect on IQ, let alone an additive effect. It could easily result in decreased IQ-- there are plenty of examples of negative epistatic interactions between loci. Even if you had all the individuals in the world in your GWAS, you couldn't estimate all of the possible pairwise interactions between loci, let alone fit the higher-order terms. The only way to really measure the effect of a combination of alleles is to find a subpopulation with that combination. That hasn't stopped people from trying to fit polygenic models for IQ based on all of these tiny effects, and unsurprisingly the best model only explains 10% of the heritability of the trait. I don't think that model has been carefully validated in a new cohort either, so I wouldn't be surprised if the true predictive power was lower.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by dooglius on Thursday May 30, 2019 @03:13PM (#20054889)
Is there any reason to disbelieve it? It seems like a reasonable thing to try.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by est31 on Thursday May 30, 2019 @03:14PM (#20054895)
This is interesting. Do you have any links to research about the topic?
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by ladberg on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:09PM (#20053443)
Where are you getting 5+ standard deviations from? That's an insane number. Assuming a normal distribution, around ~2000 people in the world would fit that description today, and finding those 2000 and analyzing their genes to find what's different would be a nearly impossible task.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by ZhuanXia on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:44PM (#20053924)
It does not work like you would intuitively think, where smart people have special unique alleles that make them so smart, instead they have a higher proportion of common alleles that have a slight positive effect on IQ and a lower proportion of common alleles that have a slight negative effect on IQ.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by hodder on Thursday May 30, 2019 @03:15PM (#20054911)
Your claims are completely unverifiable speculation and are frankly absurd. I would bet every dollar I have against there being a simple method to increase IQ by 0.5 SDs within 5-10 yrs. I’m sorry but your prediction of 5SD increase is frankly science fiction novel territory. It is not science.

Gene editing will be pursued around the globe, and countries that fail to embrace it may be left behind in health and wellness. However, let’s not radically rush to science fiction level conclusions (stated as fact) of megahumans without any evidence that it may be possible.

[Edited for an incorrect use of hyperbole around the math of 5x standard devs. I removed it from the post as I am acknowledging that using excess hyperbole in a post specifically directed at criticism of wild predictions is beyond ironic and unfair to the OP above.]

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by ZhuanXia on Thursday May 30, 2019 @03:56PM (#20055301)
I did not say 1000 times smarter. I said 5+ standard deviations. John von Neumann had an IQ 5+ SD above the mean. We know this phenotype is possible. It is not science fictional to think we can raise the average to at least his point. In animal breeding we increase traits by much more than 5 standard deviations all the time.

Iterated embryo selection and/or direct genetic engineering will be able to do this. It breaks no physical laws, it is in concert with what we have already observed and our understanding of cognitive genomics is getting to the point that it is becoming increasingly obvious to anyone paying attention that we will be able to select/edit for intelligence comparable to John von Neumann.

Look at the "Known for" section of his Wikipedia page to see what such people will be capable of: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_von_Neumann

"That sounds vaguely like a science fiction story" is a very poor heuristic for determining if something is possible.

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by hodder on Thursday May 30, 2019 @04:08PM (#20055396)
I am very familiar with von Neuman. I understand the potential of what intelligent individuals can figure out and accomplish. Von Neuman was a truly incredible individual.

My criticism is specifically directed at your timelines and foregone conclusions that intelligence is as easy to increase via artificial embryo selection as more observable traits such as size by observing alleles.

I stand by my statement that I would bet every penny I have against your proposed 5-10 yr timeline of simple half st.dev increases in IQ.

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by Max_aaa on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:05PM (#20053385)
All it takes is for one group to start. Then the rest would either have to follow or be overtaken.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by ZhuanXia on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:11PM (#20053478)
Exactly, it is overdetermined. In the west we have Lysenkoists on the left (who refuse to acknowledge that intelligence is even heritable) and on the right we have people who believe embryos have souls.

Asia has none of these problems, and will thus force us to get over our scruples.

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by zapita on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:08PM (#20053437)
Actually all it takes is for one group to make the assumption you just made.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by reallydude on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:11PM (#20053477)
Takes less than that. My baby can be better (healthier, safer, smarter, whatever) is sufficient.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by Dirlewanger on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:27PM (#20053688)
It's already started. The China of the last 20 years has repeatedly demonstrated they don't give a shit about the morality/future ramifications of any of their actions regarding science's unexplored territories.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by quotemstr on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:34PM (#20053769)
> morality/future ramifications of any of their actions regarding science's unexplored territories

Have you considered the possibility that it's a good thing that China's isn't letting subjective feeling about morality stand in the way of progress?

It's easy to get stuck in a rut where we fear new technology, pre-emptively declare it unethical, and never experience the benefits. IMHO, the west has gone way too far over the past few decades in the direction of risk aversion and the "precautionary principle", and China's boldness is a much-needed corrective.

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by vore on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:44PM (#20053919)
Progress for progress's sake is meaningless. If you're going to forsake any notions of morality in the name of progress, then you're losing sight of what the goal of the progress is: using technology to better people's lives.

Even if you're going to argue that the long-term benefits outweigh the short-term detriments: surprise, you're still applying morality.

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by ZhuanXia on Thursday May 30, 2019 @03:40PM (#20055145)
Forcing stupidly and mediocrity on our children is the opposite of morality. They could be so much more than us.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by vore on Thursday May 30, 2019 @08:21PM (#20057217)
What are the risks of getting it wrong? You can't wave your hands, close your eyes, and say "look how great it will be" without considering the catastrophic consequences.

We don't come close to having an understanding of genetics, and without that understanding, we risk unleashing horrible new genetic defects and illnesses for literally generations.

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by devoply on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:38PM (#20053828)
Have you considered that such a rut could at one point even now be progress. Where we are happy with the level of tech we have and for 1,000 or 10,000 years things stabilize on this planet?
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by quotemstr on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:42PM (#20053885)
blink Are you really trying to define stagnation as progress? Is war peace too?
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by devoply on Thursday May 30, 2019 @04:57PM (#20055837)
If technology is war, then "stagnation" is peace. And technology, at least the way that Capitalist society does technology, is war more or less on the status quo. You could do technology other ways where this would not be the case, but then that would force you to think differently then the way you are thinking now where war is good.

I am not arguing here that Capitalism does not work, it works very well... I am not arguing banning technology either. All that I am arguing is that there are other paradigms outside of those where technology is progress and progress is good. This paradigm is a very convincing paradigm because of how well it works in Capitalist society and how it generates wealth and helps accumulate power.

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by quotemstr on Thursday May 30, 2019 @05:43PM (#20056191)
You appear to be arguing from within an esoteric anti-capitalism framework that's redefined a number of common words as terms of art within that framework. You're not going to have a lot of luck convincing people to ban technology by using this framework and those terms.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by Dirlewanger on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:54PM (#20054050)
Ok you let me know how the world is in 50 years when near-perfect Chinese citizens by the millions will be demolishing the rest of the developed world in nearly every academic/intellectual measure.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by Macross8299 on Thursday May 30, 2019 @02:24PM (#20054371)
So we should delay life-saving and world-changing technology as long as possible until we can get some sort unrealistic international consensus (good luck with that, look at climate change) on the technology to make sure that the hand-wringing leftist collectivists and moralizing rightist collectivists are happy and nobody gets left behind?

I think it's hilarious that all the anti-CRISPR/anti-gene-editing people bring up dystopias when it's pretty obvious they want to live in a very Harrison Bergeron world.

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by Max_aaa on Thursday May 30, 2019 @08:56PM (#20057402)
Who defines "morality"?

What about the future ramification of stagnation? Or ignoring progress? Most of the world seems to be ignoring climate change, and somehow hoping for it to go away.

Some claim to care, but those are just hollow words for the most part, as the world is hooked on cheap (dirty) energy.

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by dekhn on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:21PM (#20053606)
complex phenotypes like intelligence are dominated by small effects caused by large numbers of variants. it's not simple "causal variant" like you see in mendelian disease.

We also don't know what the long term effects of making changes like this are.

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by ZhuanXia on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:26PM (#20053669)
I know that; I said "causal variants" not "causal variant."

It will take hundreds of edits to raise IQ several SDs. I think this will be very feasible in 10 to 20 years.

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by dekhn on Thursday May 30, 2019 @04:17PM (#20055486)
I don't think that mental model really works for these sorts of traits. The functions are highly nonlinear and the cross-terms are very dense. And, you still haven't addressed the unintended side effects problem, which would only be well understood after a stastical cohort of people received the treatment, and were compared to a carefully matched control group, studied over decades.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by scohesc on Thursday May 30, 2019 @02:01PM (#20054134)
I'd say they've already embraced genetically modifying animals and now most likely humans. There's a lot we don't know about in China considering their secrecy and control of information.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by brighter2morrow on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:14PM (#20053515)
If we can edit cognitive things like IQ then will we be able to modify other cognitive things like sexuality and gender identity?
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by devoply on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:17PM (#20053558)
Here we go again... You would think we learned the first time with the Nazis... but nope... The seduction of the ubermensch is too strong.

I would like to point out that there is no higher, just fit for purpose. If you give these technologies to businesses and to governments they will use it instrumentally to create stronger soldiers that can take more abuse or build better workers that don't feel any negative emotions and can work longer hours. In the current environment this is stupid.

Just look at what we have done to dogs, you want to see human equivalent to pugs or chiwawas.... or rottweilers?... or hell chickens.

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by DuskStar on Thursday May 30, 2019 @04:16PM (#20055475)
If I had the option... Yes of course all of my kids would be brilliant, hard working, resistant to depression, physically fit, physically attractive, cancer resistant and anything else that might give them an edge. I don't consider that to be "creating ubermensch" any more than picking the person I have kids with is.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by devoply on Thursday May 30, 2019 @05:13PM (#20055969)
Then find yourself a partner and go on your merry way.

Humans are not capable of creating such a thing, they will create something like it but it will not be what you desire.

Bad examples could be any of the following:

> brilliant and hard working

Introverted thinker. Works long hours, does not challenge authority. Chinese work pretty hard for next to no pay, why can't you be more like them?

> resistant to depression

Lobotomized individuals are pretty resistant to depression as well.

> physically fit

Sure looks like a body builder, and has all sorts of rage issues from the excessive testosterone in her system.

> physically attractive

We all look pretty good compared to chimps.

> cancer resistant

Sure let's engineer humans to better tolerate the pollution in our cities so we can pollute more.

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by DuskStar on Thursday May 30, 2019 @07:36PM (#20057010)
You seem to be suggesting that there's no way to make genetic alterations to humans that would be a net gain. I would strongly disagree with this statement, because I do not believe that the current state of humanity is the global optimum a balance of traits I care about - or even close.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by RobertoG on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:11PM (#20053470)
>"And if they do it and we do not we would be as children compared to them. "

It seems to me that if that happen the big division (us and them) will not be along national lines, but generational. So, we would be like children, compared to our children, anyway.

Maybe I'm growing old, but sometimes I already feel like that.

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by quotemstr on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:28PM (#20053700)
It really doesn't help that much of the public conversation is based on the false premise that intelligence is primarily an environmental phenomenon and that heredity has only a minor influence or none at all. The blank slate model is severely incompatible with how biology actually works, and a civilization holding onto it when competitor civilizations are embracing gene editing technology and intelligence augmentation will guarantee failure.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by buckminster on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:30PM (#20053727)
If very high intelligence was an unmitigated good then wouldn't evolution have done this already?
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by SkyBelow on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:36PM (#20053789)
No. Evolution works on a 'good enough to not die out' basis, except quite a lot of species do die out.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by devoply on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:37PM (#20053805)
Just look at high intelligence and its correlation with all sorts of other issues including rare diseases, social issues, mental health issues, etc. It's empty idealism to think that the human condition can be solved through genetic engineering, if anything it can be made quite a bit worse.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by tendersej on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:44PM (#20053905)
What if a ream of social and mental issues could stem from people of high intelligence feeling alienated due to their being so different from their « standard intelligence level » fellow humans?
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by rocqua on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:53PM (#20054049)
That strikes me as wishful thinking by intelligent people who consider the problems they and their surrounds suffer to be unique and blamed on 'the others'.
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by antepodius on Thursday May 30, 2019 @04:12PM (#20055438)
And it's empty pessimism to think it couldn't be.

High IQs might have deleterious side effects, but even ignoring the possibility of those ever being fixed- given the association of IQ with negative side effects, if I offered you a pill that would give you an IQ of 80, would you take it?

If we raised the intelligence of everyone future child that would have had an IQ of 80 or below to 100, would that not be an improvement to the human condition? If we eliminated genetic diseases, would that not be an improvement?

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by devoply on Thursday May 30, 2019 @04:47PM (#20055754)
IQ allows you to solve problems, in the case of humans mostly for society. If you increase someone's IQ their ability to solve problems is increased, but what is also increased is their ability to see all the problems and their desires increase with their abilities -- hedonistic treadmill. Therefore increasing IQ will have no effect on their perception of the human condition. If you start decreasing IQs and decrease everyone's then similarly it will have no effect on any individual's perception of their condition.

Intelligence is the red queen and an arms race, if you start raising anyone's IQ then you will have to raise everyone's IQ. If you do so genetically, then you will be genetically modifying pretty much everyone.

Since the technology and its long term implications are not understood at all, it's basically a giant experiment on the whole of human race. Not to mention other unexpected side-effects like the genomics wars from Star Trek where your enhanced people start wanting to rule the world and are cunning enough to do it. Another example if Ozymandias from the Watchmen, imagine someone with that level of intelligence wanting to fix the problems of the world... by any means necessary.

You don't know what you are getting yourself into, and optimism won't fix that. And if you go wrong you will probably have a genocide on your hands, either them the genetically enhanced killing you or you killing them.

I mean you could create a theory like the Nazis had if you were genetically enhanced people that would be scientifically true. Where does that leave the rest of humanity? No more than Jews to the Nazis. If the Nazis had given Jews a choice to join them and become Nazis by genetically engineering themselves to being the Blue Eyed Aryan race, would that have made Nazism okay?

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by quotemstr on Thursday May 30, 2019 @05:57PM (#20056322)
You're forgetting the effect of technology. High IQ invent the means of supporting a lot more people than the Earth otherwise could support and allows them to live longer and in greater comfort than ever before. We might even go to the stars and make trillions of new lives. Think about all of those lives, those experiences, that sum of happy moments: does it all mean nothing to you? Is it not something we should want to make real?
Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by quotemstr on Thursday May 30, 2019 @05:55PM (#20056294)
Why would it? Evolution cares about only "fitness", which is the ability to survive and reproduce. It doesn't care about intelligence or happiness or health or anything else except to the extent that these things promote survival and reproduction.

Current human populations are actually being somewhat negatively selected for intelligence, since at least in the developed world fertility is inversely correlated with education (except at the insignificant extreme high end).

Re:House spending panel drops U.S. ban on gene-edited babies by djohnston on Thursday May 30, 2019 @02:25PM (#20054381)
I agree with you on most points, but I do hope the timeline isn't so fast. I was hoping to be dead before this happened.