News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Long Before Boeing 737 Max Crash, Ethiopian Air Pilot War... by WalterBright on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:47PM (#20045277)
I specifically wrote "There's plenty of failure that needs to be dealt with all around with those accidents." That means Boeing, the airline, the FAA, and the pilots. To say that any one action is 100% of the cause is incorrect. Every point of failure needs to be corrected in the chain of events leading to the crash.

> tasteless

When you're trying to make airplanes safe, matters of taste, politics, emotions and legal culpability have nothing to do with it. The NTSB has a very good track record of dispassionately sticking to the facts, and I am looking forward to reading their report.

Re:Long Before Boeing 737 Max Crash, Ethiopian Air Pilot War... by 3JPLW on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:08PM (#20045519)
I completely agree.

Here's the deal, though: this wasn't just one crash. It was two. The failure mode of the second was indeed different than the first: it was a failure of Boeing and the aviation authorities to appropriately respond to the first disaster.

To propose that pilots should have willy-nilly flipped MCAS on and off based on your reading of the news is just staggering. What if there was another bug where turning on MCAS when there was an AoA disagree led to an instant plunge, regardless of etrim inputs? I'd bet you'd be critiquing those dead pilots for not following the checklist — and keeping MCAS off — in such a case.

Re:Long Before Boeing 737 Max Crash, Ethiopian Air Pilot War... by WalterBright on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:28PM (#20045711)
Turning it back on is indeed what the EA pilots did after being unable to use the manual trim, if I read the account correctly, the MCAS re-engaged and caused the final plunge. That wasn't on the checklist. But if they'd also engaged the manual trim switches, it would have corrected the nose down.

It's not willy-nilly nor staggering. The EAD (referenced in another post here) indeed talks about using the electric trim to fix the nose down problem, and then cutting off power to the system.

Re:Long Before Boeing 737 Max Crash, Ethiopian Air Pilot War... by zaroth on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:39PM (#20046385)
I think one piece of information you’re missing is that they also had cockpit warnings that the sensors were malfunctioning, and the pilot side controls were stuck on stick-shake the whole ride.

So add in the part where you can’t actually trust what your instruments are telling you, and the plane is flying like a demon has possessed it.

In the moment you are wondering, is the plane stalling? Is my airspeed actually what is being displayed? Why is trim not responding? My heart is beating 200bpm. Is that whooshing the blood in my ears or the wind?

The answers to these questions is obvious in hindsight. In that moment the flight had entered mortal peril. The question is not why didn’t the pilots recover from mortal peril with perfect hindsight. The question is how did this flight get into mortal peril in the first place?

Re:Long Before Boeing 737 Max Crash, Ethiopian Air Pilot War... by 3JPLW on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:48PM (#20045911)
Yes, indeed. It doesn't talk about turning STAB TRIM back on, though, nor does it talk about turning STAB TRIM on with etrim inputs already applied — that's what I was calling your homegrown protocol.

My point is that it's easy to armchair quarterback the pilots whether they followed the checklist or went off checklist to do something better or worse. The problem started long before they got in the cockpit, though, and had been made evident once before at the cost of 189 lives. To continue to focus on pilots' actions at this point is missing the elephant for the flea.

Re:Long Before Boeing 737 Max Crash, Ethiopian Air Pilot War... by WalterBright on Thursday May 30, 2019 @03:08PM (#20054836)
> It doesn't talk about turning STAB TRIM back on, though, nor does it talk about turning STAB TRIM on with etrim inputs already applied — that's what I was calling your homegrown protocol.

The EA pilots already had gone off the checklist when they turned the stab trim back on.