News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by wang_li on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:29PM (#20045044)
Are you prepared to pay your employees a significant premium for the requirement that they engage in fisticuffs with random strangers who may try to tailgate into the building?

Tailgating is a problem for your physical security staff, not your run of the mill white collar employee.

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:51PM (#20045941)
> Are you prepared to pay your employees a significant premium for the requirement that they engage in fisticuffs with random strangers who may try to tailgate into the building?

I have zero experience with this, but I imagine the policy would be "Don't enter the building if someone is too close behind you."

If you don't feel comfortable asking for space (fine!), turn around, go back to your car, and call building security as necessary.

Is this shortsighted?

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by cge on Thursday May 30, 2019 @12:02AM (#20048263)
The policy at our building is that, if you don't feel comfortable, let the person follow you in, but let security know.

We have the advantage that all entrances end up going through a central area, and we have ample camera coverage, such that security can reliably find people who tailgated if they are informed.

Tailgating is actually a very frequent and problematic occurrence for us, sometimes by people who will be aggressive, and this has seemed like the safest solution for us.

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by lathiat on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @09:38PM (#20047572)
I would also expect that if you immediately reported that someone tailgated to security, that it is no longer a fire-able offence.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by gnicholas on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:45PM (#20046901)
Good point. My brother was radiated into his condo building in D.C. one night. They robbed the office after he went up to his condo. He didn't feel safe refusing then entry, and knew this was a risk of letting them in.

After the incident, he was contacted by the building management, who asked him what happened and warned him not to do it again.

This seems like a reasonable policy since many people would not have thought in advance what to do if a potentially threatening person tries to tailgate.

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by dylan604 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:53PM (#20046948)
For the guy that has to clock in at 8:30 and is trying to enter the door at 8:29 it is a huge deal.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:20PM (#20047141)
Well, there would be need to also be an understanding that tardiness is acceptible if (!) it’s because you were being tailed.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by xkcd-sucks on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @10:34PM (#20047859)
Oh that sounds like a liability nightmare if someone refuses entry to a crazy crackhead and gets stabbed for it
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by Scoundreller on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:18PM (#20045607)
Tailgating is a problem when you must keep a log of employee entries (and possibly exits).

If you’re just trying to ensure only employees are on-site, tailgating is less of an issue (unless somebody got fired but their colleagues were never told).

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by wil421 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:37PM (#20045159)
That’s not true. My workplace has employee only entrances where even visitor/temporary badges don’t work. No one is standing guard and they tell everyone to not allow tailgating.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by ygjb on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:11PM (#20045542)
That's the point. I was in the infantry, am 6'2, and a guy. I don't have a problem with challenging folks who are tailgating. That is not the case for everyone. Do you expect disabled folks to challenge tailgaters? What about physically small people? Setting aside the office dynamics around discrimination issues, how many people actually have the confidence to challenge an unknown person who is tailgating, knowing that there are practically no repercussions for allowing it, versus the fallout of alienating coworkers, potentially senior folks who might react negatively?

It's one thing to say "don't let people tailgate", it's quite another to actually enforce a policy that says that unless you provide proper physical security onsite. During security awareness training I always stress that people know who to notify onsite as well as telling them that they can choose to challenge them directly if they encounter someone tailgating.

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by mikeash on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:48PM (#20046474)
We expect tiny people making minimum wage to ask thieves to pay for the cheese they’re shoplifting. This seems pretty minor by comparison.

I wouldn’t expect any physical force to be used. If asking politely doesn’t work, call security. If they threaten you into letting them in, comply, then call security.

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by solveit on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:30PM (#20047203)
> We expect tiny people making minimum wage to ask thieves to pay for the cheese they’re shoplifting.

We don't actually. All sane employers have them record and report the incident and not engage, because petty shoplifting isn't worth somebody getting shot and it's built into the margins anyway. If the store is big enough, they may have "loss prevention", who are people who are very much not tiny and will verbally engage the shoplifter and pretend to be scary, but they are also not allowed to engage physically, because again, it's not worth somebody getting shot, and liability is going to be a nightmare even if they were stealing.

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by mikeash on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @09:26PM (#20047501)
I’ve heard of policies that cashiers are not to chase, let alone fight, but never that they’re not even supposed to ask someone to pay. Is that really true?
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by solveit on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @09:38PM (#20047571)
It might vary by chain, but everywhere I'm familiar with you're not supposed to accuse people of stealing, which has the same effect, perhaps for different reasons.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by whenchamenia on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:26PM (#20045680)
But you can report that it happened, taking silent note of their details, demeanor,direction, description. Nobody is challenging little Stacey from accounting to take on an intruder barehanded.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by dahfizz on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:24PM (#20045668)
You are getting really hung up on a very tiny edge case. No reasonable manager would punish you for being physically overpowered. That doesn't mean you should encourage people to ignore the security policy.

99.99% of the time, saying to the tailgater "you need to swipe" is enough. If you do work somewhere where people are physically trying to break in often, then you ought to have real security personnel.

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by komali2 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:44PM (#20045872)
It's not about being punished for being physically overpowered - it's about being a five foot 3 intern and having someone 6'1 250 lbs, in a suit and in a hurry, behind you, tailgating.

The implications are enough to make it a shitty situation for such a person have to turn around and say "sorry person that looks c-suite, you can't come in with me."

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by el_dev_hell on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:45PM (#20046444)
This triggered a memory from my second "real" job.

We had a secure building with glass entry turnstyles. In my second week, a suited important-looking person was standing behind the gates at 8:20AM (we started at 8:30AM). It was busy and everyone was ignoring him (that seemed odd).

The suited guy picked me from the line of drones going through the turnstyles and asked if he could jump in behind me (he didn't even mention if he worked for the company).

I was still doing the HR training program stuff (the general wear deodorant, don't plug in flash drives from outside, don't ask for teamviewer, etc stuff) and the last thing we did the day before was end on the tailgating policy.

I told the suited guy that I couldn't let him in due to company policy. He smiled and said "all good" and went back to the corner.

He ended up being the head of logistics. Apparently, he liked to scope out the new hires and "test" their compliance. He tried this with 5 or 6 of the new hires and only managed to get let in once. The lady that let him in wasn't fired, but she did get a warning.

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by Spooky23 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:29PM (#20047189)
If the company handles this correctly, the intern should feel empowered to tell the CEO to get a visitor badge.

It’s also a safety issue. In a building evacuation, you should be able to account for every employee or visitor.

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by GFischer on Friday May 31, 2019 @04:32PM (#20064722)
Reminds me of Roger Federer being denied entry:

https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/tennis/not-so-fast-roger-fe...

Rules are rules in Australia, even if you are a 20-times Grand Slam champion and one of the most recognizable people on the planet.

Roger Federer found that out this week when he was blocked access to a locker room at the Australian Open by a security guard who took his job very seriously.

A video circulating Twitter on Saturday showed the Swiss double defending champion stalled at the entrance for lacking his tournament accreditation.

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by closeparen on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @09:19PM (#20047466)
Most sites control entry, not exit, so wouldn't be able to tell whether you had already left.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by wil421 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:38PM (#20046381)
I’ve had it done to me when I was hired and they explained we don’t allow tailgating here. Even though they know explicitly who I am, they are my bosses boss, I still need to swipe my badge on every locked door.

I’ve done it to VP level and I’d do it to my CIO too. I’d be that guy who badged the CIO but I try to take basic security and company policy seriously. I’d like an intern who is professional enough to “challenge” someone. Not sure I would’ve at that time.

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by goerz on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:58PM (#20046982)
There’s no need to confront anybody. Just notify security immediately if you see someone go through a security gate without swiping their access card, or if they tailgate you.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by tbyehl on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:39PM (#20045820)
It's also a very tiny edge case that someone is trying to gain improper or unlawful entry to a workplace. It's not my job to put myself at risk in order to stop an intruder. It's not my job to play policy police with my co-workers, either.

My employer recognizes this and uses mantraps to physically prevent tailgating at unguarded entries.

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by goerz on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:04PM (#20047029)
You don’t have to put yourself at any risk, but if you work in a secure facility, you are usually explicitly required by contract to “play policy police”. That is, report any security violation like someone jumping the turnstile, or not having a badge.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by chrismcb on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @10:59PM (#20047983)
Then why bother? If most of the time, asking is enough, then why bother at all? Because occasionally a bad actor wants in, I don't want to have to confront a bad actor.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by wil421 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:58PM (#20046005)
You politely say swipe your badge. If they refuse you walk over and get physical security. No need to physically challenge anyone.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by closeparen on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @09:20PM (#20047476)
Swiping on an already-unlocked door is meaningless.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by kazinator on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @09:51PM (#20047637)
If there is a response at the terminal which makes it obvious that the pass is valid, and the action is also logged, I would say it has meaning.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by closeparen on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @10:42PM (#20047888)
The only response that’s reliable across doors, sites, and institutions is the door actually unlocking, which you may or may not be able to discern when already opened. Do you know the beep and light pattern by heart for valid credential vs. recognized but unauthorized credential vs. bus pass at every door you use? Each one in my office is a bit different, my apartment is something else entirely, in college they were uniform within buildings but different across buildings.

Electric mortise locks and strikes will click, though sometimes they are held in unlocked state for a few seconds so you won’t hear a second click, or the second click might be reverting to locked state. Depends on hardware and configuration, and maybe a what the person in front is doing with the handle, and when/whether the exit sensor trips. Different things on the door can make clicking sounds, they’re a bit different from each other, but pretty close. Magnetic locks, forget it. Sliding doors, forget it.

I’m an engineer interested in security, I pay close attention to these systems, I’ve run their cabling and installed their admin panels, and I doubt I could tell even if I were actively paying attention.

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by newnewpdro on Thursday May 30, 2019 @12:14AM (#20048323)
You're absolutely right and I find this thread completely absurd.

If building security matters you implement mechanisms to enforce it, not burden all your employees with taking up the shortcomings.

Tail-gating should be impossible if you care about security.

Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by wstuartcl on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:03PM (#20045456)
I would think such a building is not (or should not be) considered high security.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by briandear on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:58PM (#20046014)
If someone follows you in, simply call security and report it. No confrontation needed.
Re:Should Failing Phish Tests Be a Fireable Offense? by Spooky23 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:26PM (#20047176)
You have a duty to at least report what is happening if you are threatened.