News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An implementation of djb's 'redo' make replacement by wccrawford on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @08:39AM (#2004076)
Seems to me this is proof that you can lose an idea by telling someone about it. I hear a lot here that you shouldn't worry about telling people your ideas because ideas are worthless. I've never agreed with that.

Here we have someone who had a really great idea, did part of the work, and then told people about it. Then he sat on it and didn't release. Someone else came along, loved the idea, and wrote it from scratch in a month.

Does the original author care? Probably not. He's probably happy to see it be used. But if it had been a money-making idea, he'd be a lot less happy.

Software development is a very fast-moving field, and if you sit on your ideas at all, someone will do them instead. That's worth remembering.

Re:An implementation of djb's 'redo' make replacement by tptacek on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @09:22AM (#2004211)
The original author is Daniel J. Bernstein, a mathematics professor at UIC, who wrote an entire Sendmail replacement and an entire BIND replacement and released them both to the public domain. Monetizing ideas is not what he does.
Re:An implementation of djb's 'redo' make replacement by asb on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @09:43AM (#2004277)
Does anyone actually know of a commercial build system that's had any success? I know commercial support is available for CMake and I expect some of the Java build systems, but they're still all under a free software license.
Re:An implementation of djb's 'redo' make replacement by theb83 on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @12:48PM (#2004973)
Even this description doesn't really do him justice; the man is surely approaching genius status. If he wanted to get rich, he'd hardly be writing cutting-edge cryptography papers. :-)
Re:An implementation of djb's 'redo' make replacement by ZeroMinx on Tuesday December 14, 2010 @08:57AM (#2004123)
Isn't the core problem here "he sat on it and didn't release"? Money-making idea or not, if you don't release it doesn't matter whether you've told people about your idea or not.

I completely agree with your last statement, "if you sit on your ideas at all, someone will do them instead." - But, I think that's true even if you haven't told people about your idea. Someone else will have the same idea, sooner or later.