The argument is always, "well there is always trade school" and that's true....for some people. I have the utmost respect for people doing trades, and the thing that most people skip over in this argument is that it is hard and often brutal work. Pulling cable is hard, building cabinets is hard, cooking food for 400 customers is hard. It can be absolutely crushing on the body, and not everyone can do it.
People going into extreme debt for a shot at an OK life is a massive problem, and personally, I don't think its fair to just say "well you should have thought about that before." I agree, they do need to take some responsibility to think things through, but at the same point, we as a society need to leverage their intelligence and work ethic, and give them a path forward in life. We don't do that now for the majority of cases.
Not for those majors. And there are plenty of good jobs outside an office environment.
Part of the problem is we curtail students' search functions very early on. That inhibits edge case students from finding edge case jobs. That, in turn, reduces the dynamism of our entire economy.
I agree that society should provide more tools to help students discover something they (a) enjoy, (b) are competitive at and (c) is in demand. But the ultimate responsibility is, and should always remain, the student's.
that's what degrees like science/engineering is. It's a path forward. The trades are also one, but less "comfortable". What else could've society done?
This leads me to another problem, because everyone wants to get a degree in a STEM field for a better job, the pool is diluted. I've met several people with degrees in CS where I seriously question if they actually ever attended class. (Actually from what I've seen the profitable jobs are really just in TE, science and math in undergrad seems to be little better than an English degree as far as decent job prospects.)
The liberal arts fundamentally shape how we view, live and act in the world. If this perspective is purely driven by the rich and the privileged, we risk losing an understanding of how the other half lives.
Being productive in liberal arts, and more broadly, creative endeavors is absolutely attainable without a university degree. The internet has made self study, guidance and distribution open to anyone. It's also decimated many of these fields from a professional perspective.
Fulfilling careers that pay even a semi-decent wage for folks in those majors already kinda are limited to the (relatively, at least) rich. See Graeber's speculation in Bullshit Jobs re: the elevation of the military in certain circles as a reaction to all the doing-good-in-the-world or expressing-oneself while also making-ends-meet jobs being monopolized by those with family connections and/or existing money.
As it always has been except since the 20th century. Lots of writers of the past known as such today had to have patrons, be well-situated in society and commerce, or just be rich as hell. The period where a writer could be a published writer and make a living just by means of achievement was incredibly short.
There are many extremely successful people with 'useless degrees', like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jessica_Livingston, but she had a metric ton of social capital which the middle class simply does not have.
The middle class ever had only limited opportunities, and since the middle class is shrinking, that's indicative of the opportunities getting boarded up.
> The liberal arts fundamentally shape how we view, live and act in the world
Thinking many years hard about engineering topics does the same. Plus, engineers do not not philosophize.
> People going into extreme debt for a shot at an OK life is a massive problem, and personally, I don't think its fair to just say "well you should have thought about that before." I agree, they do need to take some responsibility to think things through, but at the same point, we as a society need to leverage their intelligence and work ethic, and give them a path forward in life. We don't do that now for the majority of cases.
But as you said, society _is_ giving them an opportunity to productively leverage their intelligence and work ethic, and your hypothetical person's answer is "but I don't wanna".
I'm of the opinion (and have been for far longer than it's been so en vogue) that society is rich enough that we should be providing a robust resource floor like a UBI: having the resources to live with dignity shouldn't be contingent on one's economic productivity. But I scratch my head over claims like this that we should be contorting the economy to provide not just a resource floor, not just make-work, but _stimulating_ make-work in whatever field they desire, ignoring any question of whether the work provides value to society.
Note that I'm not suggesting that the market is a perfect oracle for determining value to society. But govt action in these cases boils down to a principled expansion of the set of fields we consider to provide value to society, which has the effect of eg allowing people to apply their intelligence and work ethic to eg the arts. This is orthogonal to your general claim that we should be providing this path for whatever field people want.
What actually seems to happen is: "Spend at least 3 years making your way through CC, then somehow still take another 4 years to finish at the University."
Students who can actually manage to complete the 2+2 may be better off just doing the 4 at the University. (And might actually do it in less, due to AP credits and other things.)
Any source on this? Because going to CC and then moving on to University in 4 years total is exactly what my sister, and grad school advisor did. His path was particularly good, going CC -> State University -> Ivy League PhD.
I've personally known people to pull off the 2+2 as well, but I've also personally known people who basically had the University look at their two years at CC, pat them on the head, and told them they get basically no credits because they didn't accept the level of courses involved.
The crazy costs of university have made us look at university through the lens of job training, but there's a lot more to university than that. It just not worth it when you're going to be $100k in debt.
It seems like as the situation has become more universal and more central to the national conversation, the pendulum has again flipped, and I rarely see people mention the benefits of university beyond job training.
Someone who isn't interested in any field that clearly pays high salaries is going to be stuck doing work that does not pay a high salary. If this isn't basic logic, I don't know what is. The fundamental mistake that such people make is going to college to begin with: their chances of securing gainful employment aren't great, but the chance of landing in significant debt is almost 100%. I don't see how anyone can consider this a good deal.
Is this "right", in a purely ethical sense? Probably not. I'm happy to spend all day talking about alternative societal forms where all skills and occupations afford practitioners a good standard of living, but such conversations are moot for as long as we as a society are clinging to capitalism.
P.S.: It's ironic how many of the most vociferous critics of our current economic model are also the prime beneficiaries of its spoils.
And indeed, how some of the people being systematically screwed over by it are so supportive of it. Relatedly, I recall reading in Michael Lewis' "Fifth Risk" that some rural beneficiaries of USDA loans and grants downplay (or outright hide) the source of the funding that's making significant differences in people's lives (sometimes such basic things as access to water or electricity), because the very people being helped disagree with being helped by the federal government.
No other farmers? What are you talking about? I'm not talking about farmers. Who's talking about farmers?
The USDA does an awful lot more than giving grants to farmers. An awful lot more. In some cases, rural communities would be without water and electricity without USDA grants. They subsidise school meals for poor children. They help people pay their rent. They are the source of food stamps under SNAP. They help people in rural areas get a mortgage to buy a house. They are so much more than grants to farmers, and they keep it quiet. They are effectively a rolling system of government assistance to some of the poorest and most cut-off communities in the US.
It's exactly because I'm on the spot of being a prime beneficiary of such system that I believe I can criticise it, I don't deserve the amount of money I earn while other people go hungry, I don't deserve the luxuries I have because I know how to type some stuff on a keyboard and make a machine virtually do some other stuff. And that is the point, the more you have benefitted from this system while trying to understand your own ethics that you realise how fucked up it is... I could definitely shut my eyes and blindly follow that capitalism is the rule and it's amoral and because of that any criticism should be deflected to "but capitalism is like that".
Yeah, I would prefer to live in a society where capitalism has passed this ugly phase and has been tamed to be as beneficial as possible to most people, not enable a system that left unattended or unbounded will eat everything in its way.
But that's largely irrelevant because I have a varied background. When we got our first computer in 97 (when I was in 8th grade), I learned basic HTML and started doing Battlebots (was on the last season on Comedy Central) because of the internet. I was able to learn about the relevant aspects of mechanical engineering that applied to what I was trying to do, which then led me to doing that as a hobby for a few years, eventually landing an apprenticeship as a machinist at a shop that wanted to help pay for my college to become a mechanical engineer.
Spent my first two years getting an AA at a community college, getting burnt out on the trade. I had no financial help with my degree, and was the first in my family to go to college, so I was in new territory with understanding what I was doing. That's when I pivoted to becoming an English major, because I really enjoyed the elements of communication, critical thinking and art that the field offered.
I got my degree, then worked in non-profit for a few years. I started a website that grew into a successful SaaS, then eventually left non-profit to apply my skillset in software engineering to a career. I've been doing that for 7 years now.
The degree itself got me past all the HR checkboxes, but my personal interest in these fields (and the skills I learned along the way to earning my BA) are what led to me to where I am today.
That's all anecdotal, but the truth is that I needed a Bachelors degree--in anything--to be where I am today. Without it, I would've been shut outside of those closed doors.
But that isn't actually true. Lots of people (including many with engineering degrees) follow rather non-standard career paths that are still quite successful by any reasonable measure.
[1] http://www.hamiltonproject.org/papers/major_decisions_what_g...
My fiancee majored in Creative Writing and she ended up using it to write proposals for major companies and moved up and is now a marketing and proposal manager and making pretty decent money.
When writing proposals she has to think a lot about how to sell the company and their business and that's been leading to a greater focus on business strategy lately too, so she could potentially make the leap into an executive position before too much longer.
Many of these institutions are selling shoddy products to gullible buyers.
If getting a student loan did not involve a government guarantee, you can bet that there would be much more scrutiny of the product being purchased and of the students progress.
The government is grossly distorted this market by pouring in money for products that will not pay out, and by not providing appropriate feedback as to the quality of the wares.
It's all very fine for someone to spend their own money and time on a degree where employment prospects are low and pay is low. This is called a hobby. It is not alright for precious taxpayer money to be spent on frivolities or hobbies.
Your point is about universities or higher learning institutions and is spot on.
But I'd say that even applies earlier on, starting in middle school. I distinctly remember being "sold" various career paths that were deemed noble but without the caveat of dim economical outcomes. Fortunately for me, I already knew I wanted to be a software developer and I stuck to my choice despite there not being much support from an academic side, at least not until much later. I knew back then that this is what I liked AND that this led to comfortable wages.
Money is not everything in life. BUT economy realities need to be disclosed to young students.
Since when is a degree about “chasing a dream”? We aren’t talking about starving artists or people pursing acting or becoming a professional athlete.
These are 18 year old kids who are pursuing an education and wind up in a mountain of debt they will service for the rest of their lives (at least 30-40 years).
In a world where the system is set up so these 18 year olds have to take on debt to obtain an education. These kids shouldn’t be blamed for the shit economy that doesn’t have jobs and the jobs that are available won’t be sufficient to repay their loans.
1million student loans are defaulted on every year, these are not dreamchasers its an entire generation that is finding there is no more middle class in this country rather a new unemployed/underemployed/indebted class.
If they were living in a good economy then there wouldn’t be 1,000,000 student loans going into default every year.
Sure corporations are making record profits, but wages have been stagnant for 30-40 years, workers have never seen a higher wage gap, and the economy has the lowest social mobility of any 1st world country.
I'm not disagreeing with your general point here, but an interesting dimensions to this fact:
There's some recent evidence that social mobility net of transfers in countries at the top of these rankings are no better than the US's. Now obviously the redistribution itself makes a big difference to QoL, but it's an interesting wrinkle in the claim that inequality is driven by skewed access to good schooling, childcare, parental benefits, etc. It seems theoretically obvious, but the data apparently doesnt support it: either a counterfactual Denmark with US policies would have much lower mobility or these investments are ineffective.
I'm still in support of all of these policies, but it is pretty troubling that they don't have the effects you'd expect.
Why? Going to university doesn't guarantee success. They clearly made a bad decision when they took those student loans. In a country where education is subsidized many of them might not have been able to go to university at all.
Since when is a degree
about “chasing a dream”?
When a high school student asks a high school english teacher whether studying english is a stupid idea, what do you suppose the teacher says?As it turns out, many people are not willing or know how to do the research, even if it's just a little google-fu. I wonder if, because of programming it is second nature to me to search the internet for answers about anything.
I've found anecdotally that many people don't bother trying to figure this information out.
I don't doubt it, but don't understand it, either. Not much google-fu is required to type in [starting salaries for college majors]. When I was in college (before the internet) my fellow students were quite interested in what the salaries were for various majors.
I always tell people we have things we are good at doing, and things we love to do, and while they sometimes coalesce, you have to think about the future yourself and plan ahead so you can generate some income doing what you’re good at.
I don’t understand why other kids don’t think about their future the way my brothers and I did. Parents teaching maybe? We didn’t really have the problems of other people, not knowing what’s being phased out of markets, not knowing what we were good at. I always like to tinker to a certain degree with computers and videogames. My parents supported my decisions, but I was no slouch, I knew I had to work in whatever I could and was good at to generate money somehow while I found what I excelled at (and hopefully liked doing it too). Eventually I became a (Computer) Support Assistant, changing keyboards and setting up backup plans, and that started a career which now has me as a DevOps Specialist.
I’ve always thought that even if you like doing art with scraps, why not try to market some of it for money? It’s absurd not to look around and figure there are people who would buy such things. You like doing it (probably on spare time), might as well share some of it for some extra money, while you do what you’re really good at on your daytime (and again, hopefully you liked doing it too).
I’m sorry I didn’t explain more, but I always feel constrained by written forums/tweets.
In general, yes, I think people need to be more conscious about their future. I was a teenager drinking alcohol and doing crazy things too, but it was clear to me the concessions I would have to make sometimes in order to move forward: Stop drinking and go study, or hey, maybe I can drink this time, or hey, maybe I need to go outside, walk for a bit, refresh my mind and come back to work.
Try to educate your children more to be conscious. Just because I skate and with practice became good at it doesn’t mean I don’t really think every time I get on the board that I might not fall; I know I will at some point (and I have). Just accept the responsibility and live with the consequences.
My 17 year old wants to go to trade school to be a beautician. We live in San Antonio, there is a nail place like every 2 blocks. After she goes to school, how is she going to do in that saturated field (hopefully well). My oldest sister got a 4 year degree in english, she graduated in 1994 and is still paying student loans. She never planned on writing or teaching, so now she does neither, was that a good choice for a degree.
Point is, are the degrees people are getting in "in demand" fields? Are people activily talking to students about their career paths and getting statistics if they are even in demand. I understand chasing dreams, but be prepared for the outcome.