In practice, I think the problem that creates advertising is that humans have limited bandwidth for ingesting information in general, so we have tons of tools to compile more information into less information, such as news, books, statistics, reviews, etc. (For example, how many people really entirely understand their health insurance plans? It's not for lack of trying.) Advertising is sort of an arbitrage of that communication bandwidth based on the fact that some actors (companies) really want you to see their information more badly than others.
That problem doesn't go away just because you ban advertising, it just moves the arbitrage opportunity elsewhere.
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complaint_tablet_to_Ea-nasir
https://mises.org/library/what-do-austrians-mean-rational
> The rational being practicing rational-expectations theory only makes behavioral economists laugh. And the neoclassical construct of equilibrium prices requires assumptions that only tenured professors who don't get out much could believe, like perfect competition, perfect information, and perfect rationality.
Would consumers be allowed to recommend products to each other?
What about design and product packaging? Isn't that essentially a form of advertising?
At paying platforms to advertise your product.
>How would producers expect for consumers to find their product?
How about typing "insert product here" into a search engine?
>Would consumers be allowed to recommend products to each other?
Yes, as long as there is nothing of value changing hands.
>What about design and product packaging?
Fine, as long it ends at the store shelf/online product-listing.
Take my suggestions with a grain of salt, because they come from a person who ranks advertising as one of the top three problems facing humanity.
The theory behind free markets requires that voters are more or less rational and well informed. That they will never spend more on an inferior product. Advertisement distorts that.
I suspect that banning advertisement altogether would make the economy gain a lot in terms of market efficiency. Can you imagine a world where pricing and quality would be highly correlated? A world where information on a product would be, if not correct, at least made in good faith?
I'd love to see that happen.