News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by bilbo0s on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @10:57AM (#20030757)
In fairness, no one needs to be convinced that nuclear plants are better than coal plants. The problem is the renewables.

In Iowa, they are in the process of shuttering their nuclear plants. Now no one in Iowa was out protesting the plants or anything, but here's the issue. Windmills have reached a level of practicality and low cost that encouraged Iowans to slap them up almost everywhere. (Seriously, drive through Iowa sometime and you'll see what I mean.) Even relatively small investors can get together, slap up some windmills, and start making some money.

Now imagine you're in Iowa and deciding on which electric bill you want to pay. Do you want to pay the 2 to 3 cents per kWh for wind? Or do you want to pay the 5x cost for coal or nuclear? Not surprisingly, Iowans, who are more poor than most of you on the coasts, have switched to wind in a big way.

It's a money problem. If we want nuclear, we have to convince the government to subsidize it. You're not going to find a lot of people out there who will just agree to sign up and pay 5 to 10 times the electricity bill just for the pleasure of saying they're using carbon free nuclear.

It's like organic food. Sure, maybe it is better for them.

But a lot of the masses only see the price tag.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by acidburnNSA on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @11:05AM (#20030835)
People do need to be convinced that nuclear is better than natural gas. In calm winter nights, nuclear is competing with natural gas, not wind. And because of fracking and horizontal drilling, the electricity prices have fallen in deregulated markets like the midwest, and electricity revenues have dropped precipitously. When you have a plant that's all capital and O&M with very low fuel cost (like a nuke), this unexpected drop in electricity price is hard to swallow and you shut down.

Having natural gas prices go back up because it emits greenhouse gas would have a lot better optics than subsidizing nuclear plants. But you're right that Iowans don't care about that. Shoot, even in Seattle we couldn't get a carbon tax passed.

The nuclear industry needs to get serious about reducing its costs. It's not very efficient. They've got a few hundred people at each plant doing regulatory compliance paperwork with some really inefficient and expensive process.

At least the nuclear industry is trying, a little: https://www.nei.org/resources/delivering-the-nuclear-promise

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by beat on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @12:33PM (#20031729)
And considering the usual ways giant industries choose to "reduce costs", it's a bit unnerving for the rest of us.

Blaming the costs on regulatory compliance bureaucracy is one of those things that pro-nuclear people really need to stop saying, even to the extent that it's true (which is less than they think). Distrust of big corporations is as high as distrust of government, and for good reason. No one wants to live downwind from a nuclear plant constructed by the lowest bidder. Blaming the cost and construction issues on those stupid anti-science treehuggers and their liberal regulations is just alienating the very people you need to win over.

That said, nuclear will never, ever be able to achieve either the real or the apparent risk levels of a wind farm or a bunch of rooftop solar panels. And there's probably not a less attractive look for nuclear enthusiasts than some dude mansplaining about how solar is more dangerous than nuclear based on the number of people who smash their thumbs with a hammer while installing panels.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by acidburnNSA on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @02:41PM (#20033037)
> That said, nuclear will never, ever be able to achieve either the real or the apparent risk levels of a wind farm or a bunch of rooftop solar panels.

I'm going to go ahead and point out that more people die falling off their roofs installing solar per kWh than have died per kWh from decades of nuclear operation [1]. Denigrating that data as mansplaining seems pretty anti-scientific. Both death/kWh rates are nearly zero compared to fossil fuels.

Apparent risks, now that's a real problem. Can be solved with PR and education.

Check my link in the previous post. You'll see that the industry is writing down in good detail exactly how it plans to reduce costs by increasing procedural efficiency without reducing safety.

To just say that appropriate safety has to be expensive, and any attempt to fix it is unsafe, is pretty bold, especially in the face of what the climate scientists are predicting with continued carbon emissions.

[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-d...

[2] https://ourworldindata.org/what-is-the-safest-form-of-energy

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by pfdietz on Thursday May 30, 2019 @07:34AM (#20050127)
The "falling off the roofs" argument is bogus in at least two ways.

First, most PV installs in the US are now large scale, where the PV modules are installed on the ground, not on roofs.

Second, deaths of workers in an industry are different than deaths of the general public. Workers made a choice to work on roofs; the public has no choice if a reactor near them has a problem.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by acidburnNSA on Thursday May 30, 2019 @10:34AM (#20051550)
So if a technology kills workers but not the public, that's ok, because the workers made that choice? I don't think that stands to much scrutiny. Most workers choose careers of opportunity.

Besides, the direct short-term deaths from commercial nuclear nearly all came from Chernobyl first responders, where staff and firefighters were the ones who got ARS (they chose hazardous careers too).

For the "up to 4000" latent deaths from Chernobyl, I think you have a good point. 1960s nuclear is worse than wind and solar in latent deaths. I'm hoping advanced nuclear with passive decay heat removal and low pressure coolants will even that out.

I also didn't mention the reasons behind deaths from wind, which include hazardous maintenance and ice throw. Deaths from these things are exceedingly low per kWh, just like they are for nuclear. That's the point I'm trying to convey: nuclear is roughly on par with wind/solar in terms of deaths/kWh.

Anyway, where is the best data on what kind of solar is currently being built?

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by pfdietz on Thursday May 30, 2019 @10:58AM (#20051856)
I'm not saying it's ok, I'm saying its different. And it IS clearly different, in regulation. Risks to the uninvolved public are subject to stricter control than to workers, in the energy industry and elsewhere.

One could make the case that the public is also subject to risk from solar, for example from traffic accidents transporting the materials to and from large scale installation sites. But the "falls from roof tops" argument isn't doing that.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by acidburnNSA on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:12PM (#20053480)
It's definitely different. I agree. I should adjust the falls from rooftops talk. I don't want to malign the variable renewables. I need to figure out how to explain to people that nuclear deaths/kWh are extremely low compared to our current mix, and yes they're even roughly as low or lower than the excellent characteristics of the wind/solar lifecycle.

People often meet this idea wish shock: "But how can wind or solar hurt anyone? There are no Captain Planet episodes about that." So I have to explain some mechanisms of why huge distributed energy harvesting can harm people. If you have other suggestions on how to communicate this effectively I'd love the help.

[dead]
Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by acidburnNSA on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @04:38PM (#20034144)
OK well I can agree with that! I have never converted an antinuke with that fact. I have converted dozens (at least from absolute rejection to cautious optimism) with 10-15 minute in-person discussions. I have not found out how to scale that.

Indeed, this is a sales problem.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by beat on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @05:03PM (#20034379)
The pro-nuclear advocates are usually their own worst enemies. That smug dudebro points-scoring is a huge problem. Then again, I think most people would be a lot more effective at life if they'd sit down and read How to Win Friends and Influence People and other basic sales texts.

I'm generally anti-nuclear, but not for safety reasons. I'm sure we can build safe plants. Rather, I distrust institutions, whether governments or giant corporations. I'm also concerned about the impact of nuclear power on inequality, as it's simply not available to the poorer nations, for reasons both good (proliferation, terrorism) and bad (lack of infrastructure).

Renewable power is so good in terms of fundamentals, particularly accessibility to poor nations and difficulty in using it for state-level violence, that I no longer see good reason to even attempt scaling up nuclear power. A meaningful scaling would take decades of effort and trillions of dollars worldwide. In that time, we'll grow a renewable infrastructure of the same scale profitably and organically.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by dTal on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @06:58PM (#20035243)
This is a very good point. The shape of society will mirror the shape of its vital infrastructure. Energy is the fungible commodity - you can make virtually anything else with it. Centralize the [electrical] power, and the [political] power will centralize also.

I'm generally pro-nuclear - I think it's astonishing and tragic that we discovered an infinite source of clean energy, and doomed the Earth by failing to switch to it immediately - but the self-organization of the internet holds valuable lessons on the importance of distributed, fault-tolerant structures.

Especially as we enter a time already made uncertain by climate change, perhaps now is not the time to aggressively centralize. Windmills and Tesla walls look distinctly more "apocalypse-proof" than nuclear power stations.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by beat on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @09:18PM (#20036025)
Eh, nuclear isn't that great. It's taken decades to start even getting close to truly safe, low-waste reactors, and that only due to the considerable public pressure involved after various high-profile accidents. It's pretty cheap in the long run, but the initial costs are extremely high. We can't trust every nation to stick to high standards in terms of safety, so we're running globally at the safety level of the least competent crew of the worst reactor.

At this point, we're rapidly approaching (or already past) the point where renewables are cheaper per kwh in the long term than nuclear, and much cheaper in the short term - without the dependence on the neoliberal hegemony of giant governments and giant corporations and giant finance.

At this point, I'm not too concerned about climate change, largely because there's not much we can do about it. Environmentalism and liberalism are unfortunately full of a bunch of hairshirted Puritan shaming over anyone doing anything that feels happy or successful - denial is a moral good, and allowing ourselves the benefits of abundant energy is a sin. I feel that's driving concerns about global warming more than the actual environmental damage - they finally have an excuse to deny people a good time.

More importantly, denialism won't work. If we cut our consumption by 50% right now (fat chance), it'd just take us 100 years rather than 50 to burn through the same amount of dinosaur. Same long-term damage. The only thing that will work is creating an energy framework (both production and consumption) that doesn't use fossil fuels, but has roughly the same cost (or less) and the same output.

Renewables are on their way to giving us more energy than dinosaurs ever did, at lower cost, without complex technical dependencies, high up-front costs, etc. It's the greatest weapon against the Corporate State since the internet. Why anyone would want nuclear and its dependency on the neoliberal hegemony (especially if they fear concentrated power at all) is beyond me.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by thinkcontext on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @11:46AM (#20031288)
> no one needs to be convinced that nuclear plants are better than coal plants

Germany decided to shut their nukes before their coal plants

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by C1sc0cat on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @12:11PM (#20031507)
In a panic over a Tsunami - note that Germany doesn't have a coast to speak off and is not prone to tsunamis.

It was also used to keep the Greens on side though you do have to ask who benefits and is keeping coal plant open longer really a green solution.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by danielbln on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @12:27PM (#20031664)
The nuclear exit was planned long before Fukushima, all Fukishima did was create public pressure to not go through with the prolonging of the nuclear exit that was originally planned. There are 7 reactors operational still, although most are in the process of deconstruction.
Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by _ph_ on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @01:32PM (#20032349)
German here - it is not because of panic over a tsunami, but about the complete incompetence shown in the Fukushima disaster. The plant had construction faults, the operations after the disaster failed to prevent a preventeable disaster. Yes, we won't have a tsunami at any our nuclear power plants. But whatever else has been overlooked during their construction, where are the operating companies maybe cutting too many corners to save costs?
Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by asdff on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @04:51PM (#20034265)
I assume you've stopped flying on airplanes decades ago.
Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by _ph_ on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @03:05PM (#20044084)
No, and I have no reason to assume, that large regions become contaminated if the airplane crashed.
Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by chrisco255 on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @11:13AM (#20030927)
I've seen the same thing in north Texas and Kansas but wind isn't everywhere in such large quantities (with tons of farm land to easily build on to boot).
Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by magduf on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @12:56PM (#20031967)
Exactly; in places where wind works really, really well, you might as well take advantage of it. If you really can get your power from wind, why bother with nuclear? (But what about when the wind dies down?)

But there's many places where wind power just isn't feasible.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by boomboomsubban on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @01:42PM (#20032446)
>Windmills have reached a level of practicality and low cost that encouraged Iowans to slap them up almost everywhere.

Why are you sure this is the reason? If the price tag is the main concern, the North Dakota oil boom and ongoing pipeline projects are probably the primary cause.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by jessaustin on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @10:23PM (#20036363)
What are you saying here? Why would additional supplies of energy cause the price to rise?
Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by boomboomsubban on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @10:12AM (#20040392)
They seem to be saying that Iowa is closing their one nuclear plant because wind farms are cheaper. People primarily care about price, and don't want their government providing massive subsidies.

If price is what's causing them to turn away from nuclear, then they probably turned to cheaper oil. And they seem fine providing massive subsidies to further things like the Dakota Access pipeline.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by jessaustin on Thursday May 30, 2019 @12:48PM (#20053178)
I agree there is an implicit subsidy for pipelines, in the sense that if the pipeline operators screw up and poison everyone who lives nearby, society will probably do something to clean that up. That's similar to any useful but dangerous facility that we allow to be built and operated. (Like, for instance, a nuclear power plant...) Pipelines are still superior to other petroleum transport modes such as trains, in terms of both cost and safety. Most taxpayers can think of other projects that deserve the epithet "massive subsidy" more than a pipeline funded entirely by its owners.

I don't see the connection to wind generation, however. Did some Iowa landowner finance a wind farm with a DAPL eminent-domain payment? That seems tenuous.