News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by Tepix on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @10:57AM (#20030750)
No, quite the contrary.

Just as an example, in Germany the search for the ultimate disposal place has just started over from scratch after decades of failed attempts.

In the US, a nuclear waste dome is leaking in to the Pacific: https://www.civilbeat.org/beat/a-dome-holding-nuclear-waste-...

Here's another story from 12 days ago: "Years of mismanagement, delays at nuclear waste sites could pose risk, report says" https://www.wsbtv.com/news/2-investigates/years-of-mismanage...

Excerpt: "According to the U.S. Government Accountability Office, cost estimates to clean up the legacy radioactive tank waste and contamination at the facilities increased $214 billion from 2011 through 2018. During that same period, DOE spent $45 billion on cleanup efforts. DOE spent $170 billion on cleanup since 1989, but the most challenging work remains. Estimates now stand at $377 billion to clean up the waste, but that amount does not include cost to clean sites where no feasible remedy exists."

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by mbell on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @11:07AM (#20030860)
> In the US, a nuclear waste dome is leaking in to the Pacific

That has absolutely nothing to do with nuclear power. This is the type of fear mongering that caused the current situation.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by Tepix on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:58AM (#20039024)
The post i was answering to was talking about nuclear waste in general. So was my response.
Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by perfunctory on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @12:29PM (#20031679)
> That has absolutely nothing to do with nuclear power.

Why not?

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by jimrandomh on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @12:38PM (#20031774)
Because the site in question is the crater left by a nuclear bomb test in the 50s. There was never a power plant nearby, and the type of site, and the type of waste, is very different from what a power plant would produce.
Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by Valgrim on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @12:06PM (#20031462)
Long term, large scale containment of radioactive waste is an unsolved problem. Nuclear advocates have two answers to this problem:

A) We'll solve it later (we should research fuel reprocessing, we have an urgency to act, etc.)

B) It's not really a problem (people don't actually die from radioactive waste, most nuclear plants have proven themselves safely managed, etc.)

Both answer sound like sweeping the dust under the rug. What happens when (not if) a catastrophe occurs? If a war breaks out, how can you guarantee the safety of all nuclear power plants around the world? If a country economy collapses, how will nuclear engineers get paid? If an epidemic of a deadly disease spreads worldwide, how many people can die before there is not enough people to safely operate a nuclear plant?

We cannot sweep this under the rug. Nuclear energy may be theorically cheap to implement, but the potential cost of an uncontrollable failure is too great.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by umvi on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @12:20PM (#20031583)
A modern thorium/uranium recycling pipeline should only produce small amounts of "final" waste (and only after waste has been iteratively recycled many times). That final waste takes a few hundred years to decay, but if contained, it is harmless to the environment. So, create a warehouse large enough to handle 200 years worth of waste, and create a pipeline. At the end of the pipeline, the containers are empty and can be used at the start again. Who knows, we may even be able to figure out a way to extract even more energy from the "final" waste eventually.

Consider that the final nuclear waste passively disappears after a few hundred years, whereas carbon dioxide in the atmosphere does not passively disappear in a few hundred years - it must be actively removed by plants, but the plants can't keep up with humans.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by benj111 on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @12:48PM (#20031892)
"create a warehouse large enough to handle 200 years worth of waste"

200 years ago the world was a very different place. I'm struggling to think of any building not including houses still used for their original purpose, from that long ago.

So while I don't doubt that we could build a structure that lasts 200 years, I doubt we could build some kind of continuously used industrial building without it becoming some kind of ship of Theseus. Now that in itself isn't necessarily a problem, except what about a war or something. Unlikely? Yes, but how many countries havent had any war on their soil in the past 200 years?

And I cant imagine a 2219 health and safety person green lighting the reuse of a 200 year old containment vessel for storing nuclear waste either.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by NeedMoreTea on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @01:16PM (#20032147)
Westminster Hall has been single purpose for a while. Since the late 11th century.

Perhaps that's the answer. If waste is stored in a warehouse next to the seat of government, I doubt there will be short-cuts, neglect and cost savings to the same degree as say putting it on the Cumbrian coast.

https://www.parliament.uk/about/living-heritage/building/pal...

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by benj111 on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @01:21PM (#20032191)
You know Westminster palace is in dire need of repair and debating in the house of commons had to stop due to water flooding in through the roof recently?

So yes there probably would be 'cost savings'

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by tialaramex on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @02:48PM (#20033103)
Although Westminster Hall is on the estate and is part of the palace in terms of tours and so on, it isn't the part they want to refurbish.

It's too vast to be useful for much, but it does illustrate that the columns and so on in most buildings you do use are not actually obligatory (it doesn't have any). It's a bit like those huge buildings for building space rockets and jet liners, except built hundreds of years before the people who invented those were even born.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by NeedMoreTea on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @01:23PM (#20032213)
Fair point. :)

Though I thought it was just the palace, ie the Victorian bit put up after the fire (I'm not helping my case here, am I?), that was falling apart.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by joycian on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @01:09PM (#20032078)
Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by benj111 on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @01:50PM (#20032563)
Yes, and I suppose many churches in general.

In the UK theres still some covered market square buildings that still hold markets also.

http://www.endeavourcottage.co.uk/whitby-blog/whitby-marketp...

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by ageofwant on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @12:18PM (#20031574)
What if technicolor monkeys start flying out of my arse ? Whataboutism aside, today, right now, thousands of coal fired power plants are polluting the air I breathe with more radioactive waste, particulates and CO2, to a degree not seen in the last 800k years. Your catastrophe is real and happening right now, in real time, today, this minute.
Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by Ygg2 on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @01:48PM (#20032535)
Did you read your link? Honest question.

Here is a quote:

    A concrete dome containing radioactive waste on the
    Marshall Islands is cracking open, The Washington 
    Post reported Monday.

    The U.S. conducted 67 nuclear tests in the Marshall
    Islands in the 1940s and 1950. The dome was built decades     later to cover remaining fallout debris
To put it in perspective, that's like closing solar power plant, because a star went supernova in another galaxy.
Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by nickik on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @11:18AM (#20030986)
Typical lie.

In fact nuclear waste management from civilian power has fantastic.

In fact all nuclear power stations include cleanup and waste management as part of the cost.

Germany problem is not technical but political and anybody that has ever looked into nuclear power in Germany knows this. Not to mention that finding a 'ultimate disposal' a pretty unnecessary and wrongheaded that is only being perused because limited understanding of nuclear power in the first place.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by detritus on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @11:35AM (#20031167)
Really? I'm envious about your government's competency in the matter, in that case!

I'm fairly pro-nuclear, at least as part of a broadly renewable energy portfolio, as I think industry and transportation will need at least something more than solar and wind to reach none-emission energy production saturation any time soon.

However, if my own Government's record is anything to go by here in the UK, waste management is a perenially-deferred problem and clean up was not part of the original billing of any existing Nuclear facilities. It's all stored on site pending long-term secure solutions or - if optimisim is t obe believed - until we can develop technologies to eke every last joule of energy from the ever-growing mountain of waste.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by nickik on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @12:08PM (#20031477)
We need to differentiate between a number of different problems.

One is cleanup of nuclear sites, in that are there is a separation between civilian nuclear reactors and the much, much more problematic site management for nuclear waste from nuclear weapons production. Most problems from civilian sites date back to the early days of nuclear and most states have put in place some live cycle protocols for these sites.

Old nuclear weapons production sites are a whole lot of a bigger issues and its a desperate topic. Its not fair to accuse nuclear power of being problematic based on issues from those sites.

In general, I would argue most of these problems date back to the early days of nuclear technology and should not be used as a argument against new nuclear power.

In terms of waste management from civilian waste there is a very good argument to be made that putting all that waste into a long term storage (1000s of years) is not a smart thing to do. The nuclear waste is so small in overall size and relatively easy to story that it is not really a pressing issue for the next couple decades or even small number of centuries.

The technologies to use the energy from nuclear waste will not happen unless nuclear energy get used and finds larger commercial adoption. If you believe in 200 years nuclear will not exist and solar and wind will be used, then these technology will never exists. However if you assume that humanity has any kind of nuclear future, these technologies will very likely exists and that nuclear waste will be considered a resource.

Technically its pretty clear that we can build such long term facilities for the eventual small amount nuclear waste without much technical difficulty. What bother me is the push to demand that this problem is handled, before any other nuclear innovation can take place. It is used as an argument against nuclear even if the problem is not pressing in the least and compared to the continued exists of coal and utterly disingenuous way to attempted prevent usage of nuclear technology.

Finnland has build a repository called, Onkalo spent nuclear fuel repository, and has shown that this is not really that crazy of a thing. Again, for me this is a problem that should be pretty far down on the list of priorites to solve for the world. The reason it doesn't exists in most countries is political, not technical. See the Yucca Maintain political shitshow while at the same time much better sites exists in the US but those can't be considered because of political deadlock.

Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by jjoonathan on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @11:03AM (#20030814)
Would this waste have been moved to Sequoia Mountain had Obama not torpedoed it to get support from Harry Reid?
Re:Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy secu... by pfdietz on Thursday May 30, 2019 @07:31AM (#20050112)
Yucca Mountain.

Realize this thing is a sideshow. Having it open would not have helped the market acceptance of nuclear power. Even if waste disposal costs are totally ignored (as the Lazard levelized cost numbers do) new reactors are totally out of the running economically.