News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by battletested on Monday May 27, 2019 @01:42PM (#20023896)
> Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data?

Uhhh, collecting, storing and trying to make profit with it at some point in time? I still wonder why people don't realise this when they buy such system, it's so obvious.

Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by ronsor on Monday May 27, 2019 @01:52PM (#20023980)
While it's easy to believe free services like Google are siphoning your data, it's harder to connect that a device you pay for is collecting and selling your data.
Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by obenn on Monday May 27, 2019 @02:10PM (#20024112)
I find the best way to convey to people the reason why these smart speakers and devices are so cheap, and seem to be on sale almost perpetually.

A growing number of smart devices are being sold at below-cost, using a combination of data harvesting, ads and a proprietary app/skills store to make a profit for the maker after the sale.

Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by deogeo on Monday May 27, 2019 @02:20PM (#20024178)
The price doesn't actually matter - if they can make more money with ads/data harvesting, they will. When has a corporation ever said no to free money?

(Yes it happens but it's damn rare)

Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by taxidump on Monday May 27, 2019 @02:17PM (#20024151)
I am not for regulation normally, but I feel we may need to protect our personal data with some type of oversight. The amount of information and personal data these companies hold is frightening.
Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by soulofmischief on Monday May 27, 2019 @02:28PM (#20024231)
Don't forget about the ginormous TCL Roku televisions with "opt-in" Active Content Recognition. Now everyone feels they can afford a 70" TV and don't think twice about it.
Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by scarejunba on Monday May 27, 2019 @02:42PM (#20024324)
I mean, they think that because they can. It's a great feature.
Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by soulofmischief on Monday May 27, 2019 @02:52PM (#20024396)
Except they don't understand the full scope of the purchase. All of their viewing data is now being recorded.

I can afford tons of things when they are subsidized. That's why coal, etc. still seem so sustainable and we think we can afford them as well.

Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by scarejunba on Monday May 27, 2019 @06:44PM (#20025778)
I think I am fully on-board with giving people the same option Kindle does:

* Offer price with view tracking

* Offer price without view tracking

I cannot argue that this shouldn't be clearly visible, and I think, for the benefit of the consumer this can't be a ridiculous matrix of all the different kinds of tracking. Opt-in or pay the higher price. That sounds fair. But "make it so no one can opt-in": no. That is oppressive nonsense from rich people who would go "How much does a TV cost, man? Ten thousand dollars? Just buy it."

Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by soulofmischief on Monday May 27, 2019 @08:11PM (#20026185)
Kindle offers advertisements at a discount. I purchased one such model.

AFAIK Amazon is not keeping a remote log of every file accessed on my Kindle. Can you point to something saying otherwise?

> I cannot argue that this shouldn't be clearly visible, and I think, for the benefit of the consumer this can't be a ridiculous matrix of all the different kinds of tracking.

Visibility isn't really an issue either way if it's achieved normality.

Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by scarejunba on Monday May 27, 2019 @09:59PM (#20026606)
I said "like the Kindle" in that it's clearly advertised what you're getting in the two different flavours. I didn't mean they track you. I was hoping to emphasise the clarity.
Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by soulofmischief on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @12:23PM (#20031626)
The issue is that anyone who willingly participates in Active Content Recognition systems has made themselves ineligible for revolution.

If they ever start watching anti-government propaganda, the government will know.

We've all read 1984. We know what happens.

Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by scarejunba on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @03:38PM (#20033553)
The problem will always be your fellow man who believes the revolution is evil. I am convinced of this. In the face of that, this stuff is nothing.

1984 was the mid 20th century take. I'm pretty sure any current take would be focused on people's desire for authoritarianism.

Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by soulofmischief on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @04:16PM (#20033920)
So we should just go ahead and put always-on vidscreens in everyone's house then? Because people don't know any better?

It's an education problem. Pointing at an ignorant man and then claiming he should get what he desires is ridiculous.

Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by kbenson on Monday May 27, 2019 @02:10PM (#20024108)
It shouldn't be. At this point you need a really good reason to assume a company isn't storing any information it can collect, whether they are monetizing it now or not.

It's been proven the information has value. Unless there's some regulation or contract preventing them from doing so, they're going to collect it in the vast majority of cases. Whether they already made money on a service getting the information is irrelevant.

Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by _verandaguy on Monday May 27, 2019 @02:11PM (#20024117)
It's necessary to educate people that while they're purchasing* the hardware, they're receiving the service "for free" (AKA, supported by ads in some way, shape, or form) via the hardware.

*purchasing may not even be fully accurate here since loads of companies are starting to treat it like a pay-once licensing fee allowing you to use hardware that they own in perpetuity or until that hardware is no longer supported by the manufacturer.

Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by arkades on Monday May 27, 2019 @03:06PM (#20024512)
That’s true. I’m still having trouble internalizing that my multi-hundred-dollar Bose headphones are spying on me. I’ve yet to delete the app, though I should.
Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by TeMPOraL on Monday May 27, 2019 @03:40PM (#20024759)
Honestly, this is past the shark-jumping point. When I saw that Bose thread yesterday, my initial reaction was "what in the actual fuck?!". I would have never expected a set of wireless headphones to spy on users. I thought this has optics way too close to actual wiretapping for companies to do that, but I guess I should never be surprised by how low adtech industry can get.
Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by arkades on Monday May 27, 2019 @04:00PM (#20024871)
Agreed. Considering the headphones have a mic and are used -for sending and receiving the contents of actual phone calls- it’s hard for me to imagine how prying into their data isn’t wiretapping.
Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by throwayEngineer on Monday May 27, 2019 @02:12PM (#20024123)
Kind of confuses me when people say Apple isn't collecting your data.

Are these people unaware or fanboys?

Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by duxup on Monday May 27, 2019 @03:15PM (#20024577)
"I bugged my own house, and now my house is bugged!"
Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by donretag on Monday May 27, 2019 @03:19PM (#20024611)
Exactly. Don't want it? Then don't buy it. It's really that simple.
Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by JumpCrisscross on Monday May 27, 2019 @03:26PM (#20024670)
> It's really that simple.

No, it isn’t. If people buy these products knowing the terms of the trade, that’s one thing. But a lot of people don’t. This is why we have disclosure regulations.

Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by rchaud on Monday May 27, 2019 @04:14PM (#20024965)
You know how FB can create shadow profiles of people that have never had an FB account but were tagged on photos or comments? Same principle applies.

You may not buy an Alexa speaker, but if you're in the room having a conversation with someone who does, your name and personal information could leak as well. Same goes if the conversation was on a phone loudspeaker.

The voice data would have limited usability in its present state, but as Alexa's network effects improve, the signal to noise ratio will only get better.

Re:Alexa, what are you doing with kids' data? by deogeo on Monday May 27, 2019 @03:35PM (#20024735)
Until the alternatives disappear.