I haven't spent enough time in the US to have an opinion about it, but in many places this is not true. For example, taxi services in many countries seem to pretty commonly be ripe for dodgy behaviours with little accountability.
It's really about that accountability - what are you going to do against an internet entity which scammed you? How effective is that action going to be?
Accountability was supposed to be the extra value of OV and EV certificates.
If you look at the cert for https://www.walmart.com/, you see the following Subject fields:
Common Name = www.walmart.com
Organization = "Wal-Mart Stores, Inc."
Locality = Bentonville
State = Arkansas
Country = US
The certificate authority (GlobalSign in this case) is attesting that this is accurate identification information for this company--that you can use this information to locate legal records for the company and contact it, sue it, investigate it, prosecute it, etc. DV certs do not have the bottom 4 fields.That's what the famous "green banner" in the address bar was supposed to convey--that this website has a paper trail that can be used to impose accountability.
That's NOT a guarantee that the website will treat you well. It is a guarantee that you can try to do something if it doesn't. Even if a corporation is only established temporarily for the purposes of getting an EV cert to run a scam, that still leaves a legal paper trail. DV certs do not.
And this is a standards-based distributed system. It doesn't rely on one company like Google or Microsoft, or one particular browser, or even one particular CA. If Wal-Mart doesn't like GlobalSign anymore, they can go to another CA like Digicert. If you don't like Chrome, you can use Firefox--they can both read this cert information equally well.
IMO it is really a shame that the Internet industry was not able to lean into this concept of accountability. For example, why don't browsers surface this company contact info directly to consumers? The way that a consumer can easily find the street address for a store they visit? Instead it's buried 4 clicks deep in a complicated cert menu. Why don't they supplement it with a link to the corporate record of the company? Or to the Dun and Bradstreet listin? Or to the police department website in the registered locality? (Bentonville, AR in the case of Walmart) Or to the Better Business Bureau in that state?
It just seems like there was been the opposite of innovation into this concept of using certs to provide IRL accountability for websites.
For reputation: I have no idea if that's the company name of Wal-Mart. It's barely better than verifying the domain name.
EV and OV certs are intended to provide similar information. If you report a scam by a website with an EV or OV cert, the police can use the information in the cert to start their investigations. There's more to accountability than small claims court.
Setting aside the cert issue, it's just striking how many people take it for granted that there are no consequences and no recourse for online crimes. How did we come to accept this as normal, as a society?
> How did we come to accept this as normal, as a society?
Probably because it's so much harder to pin down specific actors. That cert only does so much.
I think the far more interesting question is why EV certs do nothing for end users, and why browser makers have not introduced any new features to replace what EV certs were intended to do: help end users understand which websites they can trust on first visit.
The entire Internet industry has absolutely punted on this problem. It's a hard problem, but no one is trying to solve it!
And it is absolutely striking to compare against how well this problem has been solved in real life, at least in the U.S. You can walk into any retail establishment in the nation and reasonably expect to have a safe, productive interaction with a proprietor you don't know--even on the first visit.
It's the exact opposite on the Internet, and it's insane that everyone just accepts that.