Edit: I also see the EV cert on Firefox 66.0.5 and 67.
I can't really tell if safari has an EV indicator or not? I really don't use it much but it looks like this https://i.imgur.com/9asQkbN.png Safari version 12.0 (14606.1.36.1.9)
Normal TLS sites are black.
Sites with no SSL/TLS say “Not Secured —“ before the site name.
"Well this is weird".
Not sure if it's possible, but my money is on incorrect certificate deployment somewhere in the Paypal infrastructure, maybe an incomplete bundle somewhere that is affecting the "EV" evaluation.
I can't even imagine what you are referring to here. PayPal phishes people? Citation needed, please.
A lot of the bigger companies are guilty of this, Google is probably one of the few exceptions, since emails from Google tend to actually originate from [email protected], and their logins are all handled through accounts.google.com, unlike e.g. Microsoft which still has a handful of different login portals for the same account on non-microsoft.com domains (such as "msauth.net").
E.g. Dropbox sends emails from half a dozen or so origins, Microsoft uses a bunch, too, including shit like "microsoftmail.com" which rivals some of Paypal's choices for phishiness.
But I would also like to point out that PayPal is a known bad player when it comes to phishing, so no one really should give a damn what they do, and if you do the opposite of what PayPal does in security you are probably doing better than them.