News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by Stormbringer on Sunday December 12, 2010 @08:08AM (#1997015)
I was in 4 different airports in the US recently. Didn't have any problems in any of them.

I will note though that the big scanner off to the side that I saw in one airport had the product name:

"Rapiscan"

... which probably doesn't seem like such a good idea now to their marketing team.

Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by jcromartie on Sunday December 12, 2010 @08:40AM (#1997058)
The question is: is anybody surprised? (particularly curious about those at DHS/TSA, and scum like Chertoff... I'm guessing not)
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by jey on Sunday December 12, 2010 @11:32AM (#1997294)
I'm against security theater, but this sounds like an information visualization problem: if the image contains enough signal that a theoretically optimally trained eye can detect the contraband, they should be able to use machine learning algorithms to detect suspicious items and make them show up with higher contrast.

In other words, the software should magnify anything out of the ordinary, like contraband. It's not foolproof of course, but would help.

Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by cheald on Sunday December 12, 2010 @12:00PM (#1997337)
I think the issue is that if you can produce anything approximately the size and density of a gut, you can get it past a scan - no machine learning is going to be able to pick up something that for all intents and purposes looks like a normal beer belly.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by jey on Sunday December 12, 2010 @12:29PM (#1997404)
Fully agreed that that's a real problem.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by cscheid on Sunday December 12, 2010 @12:25PM (#1997390)
Sorry, but what you're suggesting is the equivalent of "every airplane should fly flapping its wings"

"if the image contains enough signal that a theoretically optimally trained eye can detect the contraband, they should be able to use machine learning algorithms to detect suspicious items and make them show up with higher contrast."

The type of processing which you'd run on an image to make it easy on the human eye is entirely different than what you'd do for ML applications.

Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by jey on Sunday December 12, 2010 @08:41PM (#1998854)
I'm not talking about making it "easy on the human eye". I'm suggesting that they use the output from a classifier to make parts of the image stand out more.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by kujhytrtyu on Sunday December 12, 2010 @12:21PM (#1997377)
They aren't meant to detect explosives. They are meant to detect weapons that the metal detector might not pickup

The explosive you would just put through the x-ray machine anyway where it wouldn't be detected.

Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by ceejayoz on Sunday December 12, 2010 @03:16PM (#1997888)
> They aren't meant to detect explosives.

Yes, they are.

http://www.tsa.gov/approach/tech/ait/faqs.shtm

> Advanced imaging technology safely screens passengers for both metallic and non-metallic threats, including weapons and explosives, which may be concealed under a passengers’ clothing without physical contact to keep the traveling public secure.

Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by kujhytrtyu on Sunday December 12, 2010 @04:29PM (#1998082)
That's a TSA website - it also claims that they are professionals working for our security.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by ceejayoz on Monday December 13, 2010 @02:15PM (#2001608)
The scanners may not do a good job of it, but it's pretty clear that one of the things they were sold as doing is detecting explosives.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by pierrefar on Sunday December 12, 2010 @05:29AM (#1996888)
Great headline based on a simulation. Says so in the second sentence of the abstract. Is it hard to do a test using real machines? What's stopping them?
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by tomjen3 on Sunday December 12, 2010 @05:51AM (#1996900)
Why should the company that makes these machines allow access to them?
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by pierrefar on Sunday December 12, 2010 @05:57AM (#1996906)
Shouldn't the airports or governments (or whoever is paying for these) test them properly?
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by angusgr on Sunday December 12, 2010 @06:03AM (#1996911)
That's true if their main concern is security, as opposed to security theatre.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by Mrich30 on Sunday December 12, 2010 @07:31AM (#1996968)
I'm not even sure security simulation is the main concern at this point. it rather seems to be giving as much tax dollars to the companies who helped politicians get into office in the first place.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by pmjordan on Sunday December 12, 2010 @08:31AM (#1997047)
To me it seems that at this stage it's purely a matter of refusing to back down on any "security" measure because that could be interpreted as "letting the terrorists win" by political opponents or voters.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by sitmack on Sunday December 12, 2010 @07:38AM (#1996979)
The money allotted to the TSA for the scanners was specifically part of a stimulus package (ba-da-bing!). It didn't directly have anything to do with security, more pass through grant to the scanner companies.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by SpikeGronim on Sunday December 12, 2010 @01:08PM (#1997495)
I'm really curious about this. People on HN are saying "oh it's just security theater" as if the TSA purchasing officials are knowingly disingenuous. I suspect the testing procedures are badly flawed and the TSA has no clue whether the devices that they buy work. Right now I don't haven enough data to say either way - lying or stupid. Both hypotheses fit the facts.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by jdp23 on Sunday December 12, 2010 @01:41PM (#1997597)
Suppose as you hypothesize the TSA really doesn't know whether or not they work and whether or not they pose radiation risks to travelers and TSA employees. But they've told the President and Congress that this is the only way to keep us safe and we absolutely must spend $2.4B.

Would you consider that 'lying' or 'stupid'?

Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by SpikeGronim on Sunday December 12, 2010 @03:35PM (#1997940)
I was proposing two hypotheses. First, TSA knows exactly what is going on and they are lying about it. Second, TSA's testing procedure is flawed so they don't know what is going on, but they may think that they do. So if they are using a flawed test without being aware of the flaws, 'stupid'. If they are using a flawed test and they know it, 'lying'.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by foobarbazoo on Sunday December 12, 2010 @01:38PM (#1997587)
Security experts are saying it's security theater. And they're right.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by SpikeGronim on Sunday December 12, 2010 @03:33PM (#1997934)
I completely agree. I'm questioning whether TSA knows that or not.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by kujhytrtyu on Sunday December 12, 2010 @04:33PM (#1998095)
Well they could add up how many terrorists they have caught
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by jdp23 on Sunday December 12, 2010 @01:43PM (#1997598)
The government and the manufacturer refuse to give people access to the machines.

And the government has refused to release testing data; EPIC's currently got a FOIA suit.

Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by ShabbyDoo on Sunday December 12, 2010 @04:19PM (#1998055)
Let's say a terrorist had a plastic container with a wirelessly detonatable bomb inside surgically implanted in his abdomen. After a few weeks to allow the incision to heal, the guy went through airport security. Given the number of implantable devices on the market, I bet the TSA folks are quite used to feeling the odd lumps of pacemakers, etc. on people's torsos. While the backscatter xrays might show a bunch of wires and such, would the image look much different than someone who had a pacemaker implanted with various leads into the heart? What if that guy was rubbed down with the bomb detection cloth pad (name?) which is then placed in the explosives detector? After a few weeks of being sewn up, would he trigger an alarm?

What's interesting about this scheme is that the bomb would be ready-to-go, and the terrorist could throw himself right before hitting his remote control button toward the area of the plane deemed to maximize the likelihood of death.

Is this scenario at all possible? How could the TSA possibly deal with it without harassing a bunch of people with pacemakers installed? If a single terrorist tries such a scheme, I predict that everyone with any sort of implanted object will have be added to some sort of pre-screening registry so the TSA can sort-of verify the legitimacy of the thing which shows-up on xray/pat-downs/etc.

As is obvious to most HN readers, the TSA's security measures can only make it more difficult for terrorists to operate. However, the scenarios thought to still be possible do not seem terribly sophisticated compared to the incentive to commit these acts.

Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by lutorm on Sunday December 12, 2010 @11:28AM (#1997285)
Wow. There is a "Journal of Transportation Security"...
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by EGreg on Sunday December 12, 2010 @12:05PM (#1997349)
Cut the foreplay, TSA, we all know eventually we will have to get on the plane naked!

After a good cavity search.

Because, let's face it, all it takes is one bra-bomber and panty-bomber for this to become a reality.

Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by rorrr on Sunday December 12, 2010 @12:20PM (#1997374)
Cavity searches aren't profitable.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by IgorPartola on Sunday December 12, 2010 @01:01PM (#1997486)
Not sure why you got downvoted. You are correct in that the government can't exactly hand out a giant contrract for a cavity search scanner to some shadowy corporation with expensive lobbyists.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by EGreg on Sunday December 12, 2010 @01:31PM (#1997565)
I liked my joke.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by stcredzero on Sunday December 12, 2010 @09:50AM (#1997151)
It would be very hard to conceal such conformally-packed explosives from sniffers and dogs.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by pyre on Sunday December 12, 2010 @01:04PM (#1997490)
I've been through a few airports since 9/11 and I've yet to see dogs patrolling security checkpoints.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by SpikeGronim on Sunday December 12, 2010 @01:10PM (#1997497)
You can't use dogs for static defense because they can only stay on task for so long. After 10-15 minutes of bomb sniffing the dog needs to take a break. You would need several dogs (and handlers) per checkpoint, which is cost ineffective.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by InclinedPlane on Sunday December 12, 2010 @03:58PM (#1997991)
If we had systems that sniffed for chemical residue of explosive compounds we wouldn't be having an argument about ineffective and silly porno-scanners, because they wouldn't be used.
Re:Pornoscanners trivially defeated by pancake-shaped explos... by jfb on Sunday December 12, 2010 @10:57AM (#1997250)
Admittedly early for me, but I read the headline very differently.