If they don't review the video, they can use the safe harbor provisions. If they look at the content and decide to promote or reward those creators, Google themselves could become liable for that IP infringement on aassive scale that so far is mostly going unprosecuted.
This doesn't sound like an example of YouTube badness, but rather an example of the hazards of working with unreliable business partners. And pay attention to your contracts!
For each 1800 videos? The youtuber claims that you have to do it for each video and it takes 1 to 2 minutes each.
Though this case looks more reasonable then the idiotic case where white-noise gets a copyright strike.
This isn't MumboJumbo's fault in any way. But if there are samples and they're not cleared, there's a legal issue.
That does not - of course - give WC the right to steal 25% of the value of MJ's work just because YT says they can.
This is completely wrong. Youtube can do whatever it wants unless MumboJumbo specifically signed a contract with Youtube to receive guaranteed compensation. The only law Youtube has to follow is the copyright law and it's doing it to the fullest extent possible in this instance.
What's happening here is basically Warner Chappell is claiming a revenue sharing of his video with no recourse.
Edit: he posted a new video elaborating more about this issue.[1]
[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LZplh8rd-I4