News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by shrikant on Sunday May 19, 2019 @05:14AM (#19952329)
You say

> Such arguments are usually emotional [...]

But start off your comment with

> I find it disconcerting that someone's remains would be violated due to being a murder suspect.

I guess I'm struggling to see the non-emotional component of your feeling disconcerted. Would you mind clarifying?

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by wallace_f on Sunday May 19, 2019 @05:31AM (#19952382)
To a large extent, I guess isn't almost everything emotional? Even our entire monetary system, as scientific as we prefer to call it, is ultimately a kind of emotional accounting system for merits deserved, and debts owed.

But what I think the author meant was what I hear colloquially when people say others are "thinking emotionally:" that they're relying on a first-order emotional reaction.

So I guess living in an extreme surveillance state is also bad because we feel like we want humanity to continue to to live with prosperity, dignity, and liberty... And that's arguably a more-compelling thought than disagreeing because in the short-term, one life could be saved.

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by shrikant on Sunday May 19, 2019 @06:07AM (#19952478)
Yes, this was my read as well, but parent commenter was implying that an emotional argument by itself isn't good enough in face of (presumably) more logical/rational arguments (in this case, against a surveillance state).

But parent's original point about having ones remains "violated" was in itself a first-order emotional reaction. So I suppose my point is that I'm not quite seeing why their emotional response is more valid than other people's emotional responses -- presumably they've left the non-emotional part of their reaction as an "exercise for the reader"?

I don't really know, and would be interested to understand correctly (more for my edification than anything else -- I'm not great at grokking people's intentions most times).

Re:Seattle police use family DNA, latest science to identify... by wallace_f on Sunday May 19, 2019 @06:49AM (#19952635)
In other words, it's not a problem that it is emotionally-motivated, but that it relied solely on emotional intuition without considering second-...n-number consequences.