In contrast, censorship is a kind of prior restraint that restricts speech in the absence of judicial review or due process contrary to the rule of law.
A lot of the stuff right wing extremists say on youtube today would have been censored on television in the past (depending on the country of course).
Not all forms of this look like China, some look like the USA circa 1990.
You have no right to mass media outlets. Just as I have no right to barge into your home and force you to listen to my speech... you have no right to force the owner of a tv or radio station to broadcast your message. Your right to free speech is not a right to violently force others to deliver your message against their will... those other people have the right to free speech and liberty too.
I agree. I'm just saying that suppression of violent extremist propaganda in mass commercial media isn't some kind of violation of some centuries-old tradition, or a slippery slope toward Chinese style information control, as some people frame it, because it was literally the state of affairs in the US prior to the Internet.
I don't even know if you and I have the same definition of extremist. If you mean promoting literal violence or any other illegal activities, you're absolutely right. No one has a right to that kind of speech.
But that may be too subtle a distinction for a thread like this.
Yes, they did.
The purpose of suggesting that "extremism" as a term is "so vague as to be meaningless" is to imply precisely that. It's a common enough rhetorical tactic that it can be taken for granted in any thread where speech or censorship (particularly of what is considered right or far-right politics) is the subject.
Extremism in context has a commonly understood definition, and claiming otherwise is not a convincing argument.
Obviously, the drafters of this agreement had certain types of content in mind. But those people are not the ones who will be implementing the policy.
The types of content targeted by this kind of policy depend very much on who is making the decisions.
https://theintercept.com/2017/08/29/in-europe-hate-speech-la...
We are already on, and have always been on, that slope. Yet not all Western countries are like China or North Korea, odd.
It's almost as if that slope isn't as slippery as some would have us believe.