News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fortnite is free, but kids are getting bullied into spend... by jerf on Monday May 13, 2019 @10:26AM (#19899538)
In my brush with Fortnite and its culture, this was the thing that surprised me the most.

What I wonder is, did Epic deliberately do this? It wouldn't take much to seed the initial culture with this idea.

If they didn't, it is certain that whatever the next "Fortnite" is will deliberately have its corporate creators try to seed the community with the idea that not spending money is socially bad, and you should feel bad about not buying things, and make other people feel bad about not buying things. I can come up with three or four subtle ways of slanting things against the "defaults" even in a nominally free-to-play game that on paper is indeed totally fair just by casually thinking about it for five minutes [1], and goodness only knows what I could come up with if I were in a position to think about this as my day job and run experiments.

I've posted on HN a few times about how I'm keeping my kids away from a lot of the modern ad-based or free-to-play stuff like this, because since I was a kid the market has become wildly more potent at extracting money from children. I often have phrased it in terms of ads being more sophisticated, but this is honestly more what I have in mind. This is so far beyond anything I was subjected to as a child as to be a quantitative difference.

(Let me emphasize that yes, I'm aware that such things existed as a kid. I remember the console wars, Furby, and the general stream of advertising aimed at me. It was not unheard of to have even a bit of spontaneous social pressure show up. But I'd still say this is some next-level stuff. None of that stuff really followed me home unless I let it; this actively shuts people out of full social participation even from their home if they don't give in to the social pressure.)

What prepubescent brain can be expected to stand up to this?

I'm trying to explain this stuff to my kids, but the simple truth is they are cognitively capable of getting hooked by this stuff years before they are cognitively capable of understanding the analysis, and then it's another few years of brain development after that when mere intellectual comprehension of what is being fired at them can be transformed into concrete actions to defend themselves.

[1] For example, suppose you have the player's name above the character, as it often is. Suppose you make one of the things you can get with a skin is the ability to change the fonts on that name. Suppose the default font is much higher visibility, and that when you buy something, the UI automatically changes them away from the "default" font, making their visibility de facto lower, even though it's officially just an "optional" font. You only have to provide a slightly gradient like that, and then let the community iterate it on it for a few months. You can even trivially be sure that your gradient is noticed by seeding the player forum with a couple of accounts pointing this out in week 2 or 3, and a couple dozen other accounts agreeing with it, and then a couple more later swearing up and down that they tried it out and it totally improved their game.

But you could claim with a straight face that the game is still totally fair to people who don't pay... "look, they get all the same weapons, the damage is the same, the win conditions are the same".... it's not even necessarily a bad argument!

I miss when you could be on the Internet and read a message from someone and safely assume it was from an actual person.

Re:Fortnite is free, but kids are getting bullied into spend... by jessriedel on Monday May 13, 2019 @10:37AM (#19899649)
This effect existed way before modern advertising, right? Kids have always formed status hierarchies based on the wealth of their parents, which could be signaled with clothes, transportation, and basic stuff like that. I guess it might be important that this is more intrusive (because kids get less respite from it when they go home), but it's not clear to me that's crucially different. I remember spending a lot of time at home worrying about whether I'd have the right clothes to wear to school the next day.
Re:Fortnite is free, but kids are getting bullied into spend... by mental1896 on Monday May 13, 2019 @10:43AM (#19899723)
>I'm trying to explain this stuff to my kids, but the simple truth is they are cognitively capable of getting hooked by this stuff years before they are cognitively capable of understanding the analysis, and then it's another few years of brain development after that when mere intellectual comprehension of what is being fired at them can be transformed into concrete actions to defend themselves.

Don't be too hasty to sell the young-uns short. Just the other day my 9yo was remarking about how addictive his youtube feed is and voluntarily declared that he just has to cut it off at some point in order to do things that he needs to do. I was gobsmacked. Maybe when they grow up with this stuff constantly in their faces, they have a better chance at learning how to deal with it in a healthy way.

Re:Fortnite is free, but kids are getting bullied into spend... by jerf on Monday May 13, 2019 @10:48AM (#19899776)
Oh, I'm not, which is why I am indeed trying to explain why I'm telling them they can't do this or that.

I should also say that I'm not pursuing an "absolutely not, never ever" policy. I'm trying to walk them into the pool slowly; they've actually purchased a couple of Minecraft skin packs & mods, for instance. And then we've discussed whether it was worth it (sometimes yes, sometimes no), and whether they got their money's worth. (And this is happening in a way that's less klunky and parental than this sounds; one of the things I emphasize is how I have to do this myself for real in my own purchases, with examples, for instance, it's not all a talk-down and sound sanctimonious speech.)

After all, it's obviously also no solution to leave them entirely unexposed to this stuff and then they hit 18 (or whatever) and it's the first time they've seen any of these techniques deployed. That's got way too high a probability of going really poorly.

I'm also trying to use the very system against itself. I think the very abundance of all their options can help desensitize them from some of this stuff, via much the same (I have no word for this) cognitive effect that leads to the phenomenon where one just browses Netflix endlessly but never quite watches anything. They've got Netflix, a fairly decent video game collection that is already paid for, and more options than you can swing a cat at for $5, which is definitely not the position I was in as a kid. A $20 Fortnite skin is several great $5 games on sale, or several movie rentals, or all kinds of other things that if they sit and think about it for a moment are more appealing than 1/3rd a brand-new AAA game on a single skin... or at the very least, it really helps contextualize how big the ask is for them. Skins on Fortnite are absurdly expensive for what they are. (Which is also evidence just how much "social networking effects" are in those prices, IMHO.)

Re:Fortnite is free, but kids are getting bullied into spend... by wyldfire on Monday May 13, 2019 @10:37AM (#19899639)
> It wouldn't take much to seed the initial culture with this idea.

I don't want to bend over backwards to defend a company that certainly could have done this. But, sadly, this strikes me as plain old "humanity at work." I think many of us have subconscious/instincts to evaluate people on status cues and kids don't yet know enough social conventions not to make that kind of thing explicit. Sadly, some adults may model this bad behavior too.

Re:Fortnite is free, but kids are getting bullied into spend... by jerf on Monday May 13, 2019 @10:44AM (#19899735)
As you can sort of infer from my post, the only thing preventing me from assuming that Epic did it on purpose is my assessment that the difficulty of manufacturing that from scratch, on purpose, is actually significantly higher than the difficulty of backing into it by accident. A lot of major "marketing discoveries" were clearly backed into by accident, as a result of marketers just throwing everything at the wall over time.

But even if it was an accident this time, it won't be next time.

Re:Fortnite is free, but kids are getting bullied into spend... by EGreg on Monday May 13, 2019 @10:34AM (#19899617)
How is this much different from the culture I grew up where people made fun of you when you didn't have some nice fashion, but wore, say, the same sneakers as your parents?
Re:Fortnite is free, but kids are getting bullied into spend... by jerf on Monday May 13, 2019 @10:40AM (#19899685)
It's possible you missed it in my edits as I was editing things in, but the answer is, it didn't follow you home. When I got home, I could be broadcasted at by the TV, but I had no peer-interactive media other than voice phone calls, which are structurally unsuitable for this style of peer pressure. The TV could set the parameters of the peer pressure, and then I could be pressured at school, but there was no dynamic, real-time blending of the corporate agenda-setting and my actual peers reinforcing it in a live loop.

And if memory serves, honestly, even that loop was non-linearly weaker than you'd think (or, if you prefer, the aforementioned dynamic loop is non-linearly stronger than you'd think from the parts, since it's iterative). Yeah, some kids were really into that peer game, but it was pretty easy to check out, and the peer pressure was easily lost in the ambient level of general bullying and child unpleasantness. Yeah, I wore the wrong shoes, but it was something I heard about infrequently, and even if I had been wearing the right shoes it was pretty clear it would just have been something else. It wasn't the dominant playground topic, every day.

Re:Fortnite is free, but kids are getting bullied into spend... by mcv on Monday May 13, 2019 @10:59AM (#19899907)
> "How is this much different from the culture I grew up where people made fun of you when you didn't have some nice fashion"

It's not much different. It's the same thing in a different, more pervasive jacket, but both attitudes are wrong and harmful. It's a shame those cultures haven't grown out of it.

Re:Fortnite is free, but kids are getting bullied into spend... by linuxftw on Monday May 13, 2019 @10:42AM (#19899706)
Interesting point, but I'm not quite sure it's the same. You could call out that other kid and beat them in a footrace and embarrass them in their fancy shoes. Or you could make fun of their whatever. I think online, you can't beat them in the footrace because they paid to win.
Re:Fortnite is free, but kids are getting bullied into spend... by linuxftw on Monday May 13, 2019 @10:37AM (#19899644)
IMO, video games have become an addiction-based industry. It's all about the dopamine response. For many kids (and adults), video games are their primary social outlet.

Social media, modern television, are also addiction-based IMO. The magic of the internet and a/b testing to drive increased engagement has made anything that can be exploitative completely exploitative.

Re:Fortnite is free, but kids are getting bullied into spend... by brootstrap on Monday May 13, 2019 @11:01AM (#19899938)
i'm 100% addicted , in some capacity, to gaming. I enjoy it too much as a hobby to stop. I dont even get into online games though. Honestly i've been playing soulsborne shit and offline action games for the past few years. My satisfaction in gaming comes from overcoming challenges.

In dark souls that means precise melee combat against boss for a good few minutes. One tiny slip up with a dodge/block/attack, and you typically get shreked. You can spend hours learning and practicing against a boss and then you finally kill that mutha fucka and DAMN it feels good. That is the dopamine rush I am chasing

Re:Fortnite is free, but kids are getting bullied into spend... by jklm on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @01:02AM (#19906901)
As a counterpoint to this, I don't get much enjoyment out of games anymore.

You mentioned Dark Souls. A friend suggested I try out Sekiro, a new game by the same studio. There's a mandatory element of stealth, which is a genre I've never found terribly attractive. You die, you learn/memorize a little more, repeat. At then end of it you successfully accomplish something, like defeating a boss. But what did it mean? Were you skilled enough to run through it on your first try? (Probably not.) Is there replay value? Again, probably not - once you've learned the movement and attack patterns there's only so much variation that can happen. So you might've spent quite awhile memorizing something which doesn't improve your experience in the same game, much less other games.

Other factors that have turned me off: heavy randomness, in-app purchases, generic fetch missions.

I find myself more drawn to the rare unicorn that has a good story, or really is revolutionary in terms of gameplay. I can also appreciate online games to some extent - you gain extreme mastery in something, but it's a skill that you need to use in fresh, changing conditions. If you improve far enough, you might start playing against the best players, requiring you to predict multiple moves ahead like chess. In most games, this is impossible for AIs to reach.

Re:Fortnite is free, but kids are getting bullied into spend... by linuxftw on Monday May 13, 2019 @11:44AM (#19900421)
You would love Megaman series on the NES, lol. Unforgiving difficulty that requires complete mastery and and a good deal of memorizing to complete the stages.

Yeah, with video games you're always searching for that next high. While most things are fine in moderation, it's the addictive potential that makes people keep coming back, to the detriment of other areas of their lives.

Re:Fortnite is free, but kids are getting bullied into spend... by jacobush on Monday May 13, 2019 @10:42AM (#19899716)
Fortnite is exactly like that, not with the fonts but with the skins. The default skin is larger than many for-pay skins, so your view when fighting is obstructed by your own player taking up more space in your field of vision. (Because it's not a 1st person shooter, but a 3rd person shooter.)