News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why falsificationism is false by dang on Saturday May 11, 2019 @04:11PM (#19888126)
The author addresses this:

"It’s the crude version that most people, especially scientists, have in mind when they talk about falsificationism. I will be satisfied if all I have achieved with this post is to convince you that, at least in this crude version, falsificationism is false."

It isn't a straw man if he's right that the crude version is what most people believe.

Re:Why falsificationism is false by leereeves on Saturday May 11, 2019 @07:18PM (#19888995)
Even the author calls it "naive falsificationism". That's the strawman. The author is right that it's a crude version of falsificationism, but I doubt that most people believe it.

I suspect most people believe the version that the author calls reasonable: first confirm the experiment and its conclusions before questioning a proven theory.

Re:Why falsificationism is false by dang on Saturday May 11, 2019 @08:16PM (#19889266)
In that case you and the author have an empirical disagreement about how many people believe which version. Given how often "naive falsificationism" shows up in internet comments, I wouldn't bet against the author. But isn't it moot anyhow? He states up front that not everyone believes this, but those who do are the ones he's writing for. That's not a straw man argument.
Re:Why falsificationism is false by leereeves on Saturday May 11, 2019 @08:28PM (#19889316)
"Naive falsificationism" shows up in Internet comments from the kind of people who think vaccines cause autism or global warming is a hoax, and cling to a single isolated result as "proof". Even on the Internet they aren't a majority.

If the author merely wants to argue against that kind of thinking, that's fine, but given the extensive discussion of Karl Popper and physicists, I don't think that's the author's intent.

Re:Why falsificationism is false by lisper on Saturday May 11, 2019 @07:14PM (#19888972)
> The author addresses this:

No, he doesn't. The word "explanation" doesn't even appear in the article.