News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kinect finally fulfills its Minority Report destiny by shawndumas on Thursday December 09, 2010 @10:06AM (#1987672)
the phrase, "for 8hrs a day" is implied...
Re:Kinect finally fulfills its Minority Report destiny by Cushman on Thursday December 09, 2010 @10:15AM (#1987704)
Of course, that's a valid point. But again, lots of (perhaps most?) people engage in conversation for several hours per day, and a lot of that time is spent gesturing, mostly unconsciously.

I'm not envisioning it as a primary input device, naturally (although the deaf seem to get by fine). But I don't think I've ever been in a situation where a heated conversation made my arms tired; as a replacement for a few basic mouse tasks, I bet it could even improve ergonomics.

Just try it: raising your arms as if gesturing conversationally is way, way less stressful than reaching out to touch your monitor.

Re:Kinect finally fulfills its Minority Report destiny by hugh3 on Thursday December 09, 2010 @10:26AM (#1987751)
Right now I'm sitting back in my chair, with my elbows on my chair's armrests. With comfortable armests I reckon I could gesture all day. If I had a hundred odd inches of monitor surrounding me like in Minority Report it might be a reasonable way to control things -- easier than moving a mouse pointer all the way from one side of a vast piece of screen real estate to the other.
Re:Kinect finally fulfills its Minority Report destiny by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 09, 2010 @11:27AM (#1987982)
I'd love such an interface precisely for the ergonomics. The mouse is very bad for my wrists. I imagine waving my hand through the air wouldn't be.

Also, the gorilla arm would go away fairly quickly. This used to make me tired:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPKbCsWLe4k

Now it doesn't. I expect people would get used to minority report interfaces, particularly if they didn't immediately try to transition from 8 hours of keyboard to 8 hours of minority report.

My real question: is source code for this demo available?

Re:Kinect finally fulfills its Minority Report destiny by electromagnetic on Thursday December 09, 2010 @07:20PM (#1989928)
I don't think it's absurd to use this for hours a day, given that for many deaf people signing is their only way to communicate face to face, and people will find ways to talk all day.

I work in construction, I spend my days holding 5lb drills in front of me. Using the standard gesture position (forearm down) your arm won't get tired during a day. I basically live my day in the 'gesture position' often for well over 8 hours a day, always with weights in them.

When the upper arm is lifted is when your arms get not so much tired but literally drained, which is what I think the Kinect will likely have to adapt to.

Re:Kinect finally fulfills its Minority Report destiny by contextfree on Thursday December 09, 2010 @04:26PM (#1989222)
So you're taking it as assumed that there is one, singular interface that people will be using for the whole day. Even now, while designing and thinking things through I usually alternate between typing in a text editor, drawing on a whiteboard, taking notes on paper, discussing verbally with other people in the office, and just pacing up and down thinking to myself. The whiteboard for example is essentially a specimen of the much-maligned vertical touchscreen interface, and I don't see why it couldn't be made into a computationally-driven dynamic display.