Re:Germany is opening its first electric highway for trucks
by dredmorbius on Thursday May 09, 2019 @05:45AM
(#19866719)
Railroads do endpoint delivery -- last mile -- poorly.
The height of the railroad era in the US actually saw the peak of the horse population -- moving goods the final or first mile, or block, to and from the railroad depot was a huge need. The automobile and lorry rapidly picked up this niche, but horses were used well into the 1920s.
A train is an exceedingly good way to get goods or passengers from near point A to near point B. But if you want specific pickup and deivery, you either need to put everthing at ponts A and B (densification, tower construction), build an immense set of spur line (low raffic, high loal impact, low rate of return), develop an exceptonally efficient intermodal system (goods can coninue across multiple transport modes without major break-bulk costs -- shipping containers are an example). Or you have a means of accomplishing the final and initial delivery legs.
Keep in mind that there are transport needs that concentrate poorly, with agriculture being a prime example. You might even call ag an industrial productive mode dominated by spatial (or areal) inputs. Keep in mind that the fundamental unit of area under old units, the acre, is literally defined as a daily work unit. In German, that is literally true: Tagwerk, a day's work.
Which means that both the inputs and outputs of agriculture must be delivered over a sparse network not amenable to infrastructure-based optimisations. And running rail to every last field is a losing proposition. Asphalt or gravel roads are far less expensive infrastructure, and even electrifying those would be a high challenge.
(Other materials sourcing operations face similar dynamics.)
The height of the railroad era in the US actually saw the peak of the horse population -- moving goods the final or first mile, or block, to and from the railroad depot was a huge need. The automobile and lorry rapidly picked up this niche, but horses were used well into the 1920s.
A train is an exceedingly good way to get goods or passengers from near point A to near point B. But if you want specific pickup and deivery, you either need to put everthing at ponts A and B (densification, tower construction), build an immense set of spur line (low raffic, high loal impact, low rate of return), develop an exceptonally efficient intermodal system (goods can coninue across multiple transport modes without major break-bulk costs -- shipping containers are an example). Or you have a means of accomplishing the final and initial delivery legs.
Keep in mind that there are transport needs that concentrate poorly, with agriculture being a prime example. You might even call ag an industrial productive mode dominated by spatial (or areal) inputs. Keep in mind that the fundamental unit of area under old units, the acre, is literally defined as a daily work unit. In German, that is literally true: Tagwerk, a day's work.
Which means that both the inputs and outputs of agriculture must be delivered over a sparse network not amenable to infrastructure-based optimisations. And running rail to every last field is a losing proposition. Asphalt or gravel roads are far less expensive infrastructure, and even electrifying those would be a high challenge.
(Other materials sourcing operations face similar dynamics.)