News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by DevX101 on Thursday December 09, 2010 @02:24AM (#1986506)
I don't like estate taxes. Governments are typically terrible financial stewards and bad examples of financial responsibility. Give the government one billion and it will find a way to spend two.

But I also don't like the idea of a permanent aristocratic class where generation after generation are born into opulence because your great grandfather created a great company.

The movement towards philanthropy is a great alternative as long there are clearly defined and applied metrics of success. Gates Foundation does a good job at this. If you claim you're going to change the world, but you can't prove it, you won't get funding again.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by sshumaker on Thursday December 09, 2010 @02:56AM (#1986571)
I'd argue one of the points of estate taxes (which are heavily favored by Buffet, Gates, et. al) is to encourage you to will your fortunes to philanthropy - so it doesn't end up in the hands of the government.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by ramanujan on Thursday December 09, 2010 @07:27AM (#1987133)
The biggest lobbies for increased estate taxes are life insurance companies:

http://blogs.forbes.com/hanisarji/2010/12/01/life-insurance-...

“The estate tax is a cash cow for the life insurance industry – and the industry’s lobbyists guard it zealously...[o]nly three industries – pharmaceuticals, electric utilities, and oil and gas – spent more over the same period.”

Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by DevX101 on Thursday December 09, 2010 @10:23AM (#1987733)
For more details on WHY the life insurance lobbies aggressively to support the estate tax, see this link from ramanujan's article:

http://www.nodeathtax.org/uploads/view/2313/life_insurance_b...

Excerpt:

"Life insurance is the most basic tool for estate planning. Put simply, inheritance is subject to the estate tax, while life insurance benefits are untaxed. This drives up the demand for life insurance, thus driving up the price. The disparate tax treatment distorts the market so much that a wealthy person could buy a policy knowing he will pay more in premiums than the value of the benefit – and it would still make sense financially.

For example, if someone bought a $20 million whole life policy at age 60, and paid $25 million over the years in premiums, he would still be giving more to heirs (an untaxed $20 million) than if he just bequeathed that $25 million to his children – because after the estate tax, that could be worth less than $20 million."

--This discussion has been really informative. Thanks to all.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by russell_h on Thursday December 09, 2010 @11:11AM (#1987922)
Is there anything to stop a person from investing their estate in a company whose sole purpose is to insure their life?
Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by jacques_chester on Thursday December 09, 2010 @09:50PM (#1990378)
If it hasn't already been tried, the IRS would tie it up in litigation for so long that the principal would be consumed by legal fees.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by waterlesscloud on Thursday December 09, 2010 @08:24AM (#1987281)
Of which Buffet owns several. Which may or may not play a role in his support.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by jakarta on Thursday December 09, 2010 @10:00AM (#1987648)
I don't think it does. The life insurance contribution to Berkshire Hathaway results is quite small. The bulk of the income is from reinsurance and P/C activities.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by jbooth on Thursday December 09, 2010 @10:43AM (#1987822)
How many billions has this guy given away again? I'd wager that he doesn't really care about an extra few million in insurance company profits.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by DevX101 on Thursday December 09, 2010 @03:13AM (#1986600)
Great point! High estate taxes gives an incentive to the wealthy not to pay estate taxes.

The original intent of my argument was that I don't like the idea of handing over half your estate to the government. I suppose the proponents of the high estate tax wanted avoidance of the tax via philanthropy as an intended side effect.

Thanks, I never looked at it that way.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by ovi256 on Thursday December 09, 2010 @08:06AM (#1987233)
Another one is to avoid the creation of a plutocracy. Of course, somebody more cynical could argue that it is too late for that.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by jacoblyles on Thursday December 09, 2010 @04:50AM (#1986820)
Or buy expensive life insurance policies.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by bertil on Thursday December 09, 2010 @07:35AM (#1987151)
> Governments are typically terrible financial stewards

Well, no: many governments are far more responsible than most individuals. That's not true in counties were everyone criticize the government as strongly as you do in the United States, but in countries where government positions are prestigious, the most talented people work there. As recently demonstrated, financial incentives are no where as efficient as job safety and support for creative tasks, this is why a system that promote civic dedication has tremendous impact.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by quadhome on Thursday December 09, 2010 @08:49AM (#1987373)
What's a country where government positions are prestigious for reasons other than they're an opportunity to participate in bribery and corruption? (Switzerland?)
Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by Benjo on Thursday December 09, 2010 @09:28AM (#1987511)
From what I understand, the government of Singapore keeps corruption low just by paying their officials a lot. The president makes about $3 million.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/President_of_Singapore

It may just be an anecdote but it seems like a reasonable system to me.

EDIT: had the wrong dollar amount.

Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by dualogy on Thursday December 09, 2010 @11:22AM (#1987961)
Germany had the same "strategy". I'm not sure pre-emptively bribing every official up-front really solves the "cost" issue to Joe Sixpack. Corruption might be more affordable in the end...
Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by cellshade on Thursday December 09, 2010 @11:12AM (#1987924)
That wikipedia page says about 3 million, not 300 million.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by Benjo on Thursday December 09, 2010 @11:26AM (#1987979)
My mistake: fixed.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by bertil on Thursday December 09, 2010 @07:36PM (#1989986)
Some countries value what you can't buy. Peerage works well in the UK, and is rather cheap. In France, the possibility to spend a career working in central historical buildings makes the best minds cram for decades.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by sp332 on Thursday December 09, 2010 @01:21PM (#1988443)
> But I also don't like the idea of a permanent aristocratic class where generation after generation are born into opulence because your great grandfather created a great company.

If you make a ridiculous amount of money, what's wrong with making sure that your family is financially secure for generations?

Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by mattmiller on Thursday December 09, 2010 @01:46PM (#1988556)
It cripples upward mobility for the rest of society. You could make an argument that upward mobility is one of Americas greatest strengths. It keeps people motivated and it allows the entire population the chance to contribute to advancement.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg Agrees to Give Away Fortune by jacques_chester on Thursday December 09, 2010 @09:51PM (#1990380)
> It cripples upward mobility for the rest of society

How?