News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by gasull on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @05:45PM (#1985009)
At what point is it OK to use a DDOS attack as a form of protest?

I mean, do we have to wait until they grope us at checkpoints? Checked.

Until they take websites down without trial? Checked.

Until they start accusing journalist of espionage? Checked.

Until they illegally tape the Internet? Checked.

Is there a limit or DDOS is wrong no matter what?

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by CWuestefeld on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @05:56PM (#1985059)
do we have to wait until they...

Who is the "they" that you refer to? I don't think that it's MasterCard nor Visa that did those things.

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by gasull on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @06:02PM (#1985087)
They is obviously the Government, but with the help of unethical companies: AT&T for taping the Internet, Amazon/Paypal/Visa/Mastercard for suppressing free press, etc.
Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by xenophanes on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @06:26PM (#1985165)
Not doing commerce with someone is not suppression. It's a peaceful activity. They were never responsible for helping wikileaks or anyone else do anything, so they are not violating an obligation by failing to help. (OK they do have obligations to their customers, but those are governed by contracts which let them cancel service and which they no doubt followed).

Whether you agree with Amazon/Visa/etc or not, it's important to keep clear the difference between their actions (no force involved) and the Government's actions (force involved). It's not all the same thing even if they help accomplish some similar ends.

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by gasull on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @06:44PM (#1985239)
Good point. The problem with this is that this is exactly the reason why the Government is using companies as proxies for suppressing freedom, because it leaves nobody to blame: (1) the Government didn't really forbid donations to WikiLeaks and (2) the companies can always blame the Government or the law for what they were forced to do.

I don't have the right answer for this and it just makes me sad that our freedom is being eroded incrementally.

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by xenophanes on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @07:53PM (#1985477)
It's tricky b/c Amazon (for example) denies that they acted b/c the Govt wanted them to. Are they lying? I don't know. It's really hard to tell. They said Wikileaks violated their terms of service which is no doubt technically true; but I don't know if they would have been happy to overlook it without any Govt pressure.

So even if I wanted to get mad at companies that do the Govt's bidding without being compelled, I don't really know if Amazon is such a company or not.

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by gasull on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @08:44PM (#1985622)
[Amazon] said Wikileaks violated their terms of service which is no doubt technically true

It's technically wrong since leaked documents, like the Pentagon Papers, are in the public domain, so WikiLeaks does have the right to publish them, contrary to what Amazon said.

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by nerfhammer on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @10:57PM (#1985954)
The Pentagon Papers were manually put into the public domain when Sen. Mike Gravel (yes, that one) entered them into the Congressional Record.
Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by A1kmm on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @09:41PM (#1985760)
The trouble is that there is a duopoly in the financial services industry, especially in credit card processing. Cardholders want to pay Wikileaks, Wikileaks wants to receive the money, but they are being restrained by the actions of the duopoly members, and Wikileaks is left with no alternative.

The US has anti-trust laws (15USC1 - see http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/html/uscode15/usc_sec_15_0...) which cover similar conduct: "Every contract, combination in the form of trust or otherwise, or conspiracy, in restraint of trade or commerce among the several States, or with foreign nations, is declared to be illegal".

It sounds like the companies have not admitted a conspiracy with Joe Lieberman to stop Wikileaks from receiving donations - the companies seem to claim to have all come to the conclusion independently - but if such a conspiracy did exist, and was considered unreasonable by the courts, it could be illegal.

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by makmanalp on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @07:39PM (#1985422)
Not doing commerce would be, for example, rejecting a new sale or a renewal or such. Cutting existing service is a pretty direct motion.
Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by danenania on Thursday December 09, 2010 @12:51AM (#1986265)
They clearly did this in response to government pressure, which means they are acting as proxies for intimidation and force. They have a unique power to protect the freedom of humanity, but the people running these corporations have abdicated their responsibility toward their fellow man. They have revealed themselves to be cowardly and complicit, and deserve a lot worse than a few ddos attacks for their actions.
Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by zcid on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @10:44PM (#1985925)
Choosing to not do business with an organization for political reasons is a pretty good example of suppression.

It's hardly peaceful. At best, it is passive-aggressive. At worst, an outright attack on that organization. It can especially be considered such when the company in question is part of one of the world's biggest anti-competitive conglomerations.

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by borism on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @06:48PM (#1985258)
this is far from peaceful and force is very much involved:

"Not being able to receive money from the public for a week can cost Wikileaks 7 digit figures in losses, and DataCell as well, as it is unable to process any cards," Fink said.

The suit will be filed in the UK against Visa Europe. The company will file a court case with a request for an immediate injunction "to limit further damage," Fink said.

Wikileaks donations can still be made via wire transfer, but that MasterCard and Visa handle small donations, which make up the majority, according to Fink.

"Wire transfers are good if you want to transfer €10,000, but if you want to pay €10, the costs of the transfer eat up the donation," said Fink. "Visa and MasterCard are vital for the small amount donations, and that's around 99.9 percent of the donations."

http://www.zdnet.co.uk/blogs/security-bullet-in-10000166/leg...

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by xenophanes on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @07:49PM (#1985460)
If Visa cut off service with Apple, no one would say Visa was using force against Apple unless they violated a contract. If Apple didn't have a contract with Visa with some guarantees in it (for transition time or whatever) that was their own fault.

Everyone making 7 digits or more has lawyers, or should, to deal with such contracts.

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by zabuni on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @07:35PM (#1985406)
Ugh. The person conflates not gaining money with losing money, the same rhetorical trick that the record companies make when talking about piracy.
Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by pyre on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @08:49PM (#1985639)
Not necessarily. If they are consistently pulling in $X per month, then it is reasonable to state that depriving them of service for a month is depriving them of $X (i.e. a good estimate of what they would have made that month).
Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by CWuestefeld on Thursday December 09, 2010 @10:43AM (#1987820)
No. You assume that those that would be donating today will never come back. But it's reasonable to believe that many/most of those people will try again next week.
Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by borism on Thursday December 09, 2010 @03:38AM (#1986652)
absolutely. donations = 100% income.
Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by potatolicious on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @06:22PM (#1985152)
I have a hard time linking "getting out of the crossfire" with "unethical". Spineless? Perhaps. Failing to stand up for some principle? Probably.

But unethical?

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by wtallis on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @07:12PM (#1985331)
The government shouldn't interfere with private transactions without proper cause and due process. When a big business complies with a "polite request" from the government, and that request is the sort that would be illegal and justification for armed rebellion if it were phrased as an order, that business is unethical and colluding with corrupt government.
Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by gasull on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @06:54PM (#1985284)
Failing to stand up for some principle? Probably.

But unethical?

Do you doublethink so?

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by potatolicious on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @07:18PM (#1985350)
This is the internal inconsistency that troubles me about this whole WikiLeaks thing. We've railed on companies constantly in the past for being political, and now we're railing on them for not being sufficiently political in our favor.

So which will it be?

This is Amazon, PayPal, VISA, MC, etc, saying "woah hey a dangerously hot potato, not touching that", which strikes me as a more or less neutral stance.

To expect more than that would be expecting a company to make a political stand on one side or another - something we've consistently fought against in the past.

So which is it? Do we want companies to remain politically neutral and leave the democratic process up to real people (as opposed to corporate persons)?

Or do we want them to fight for our cause, and make open political stands? If so, we also have to accept that often they will not be fighting on our side, and each punch they throw will be worth a lot of real people's punches.

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by gasull on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @07:31PM (#1985385)
When confronted with the situation, neutrality isn't possible: you either stand up for your users or you help the Government to censor.

There's only so much you can avoid taking sides on.

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by nhangen on Thursday December 09, 2010 @12:37AM (#1986214)
Not all users are created equal. We know this, just as we know that the customer is not always right. None of this is black and white, there is gray across the board.

These are complex decisions being made by complex businesses...why does no single company deserve the benefit of the doubt?

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by intended on Thursday December 09, 2010 @04:49AM (#1986814)
They all do. Everyone deserves it, and it has been given many times. But many companies have broken that trust, repeatedly and gotten away with murder.

I don't think its about the benefit of doubt anymore. I think we have to recognize that the groups on the other side of the power equation are implacable and do not have constraints stopping them from harming you. They have the power to take over your life and do not have any oversight.

Heck I would say that they have evolved to game the system and learnt how to be the best at it.

The original system was not about "the constitution" or freedom, liberty, fraternity or whatever ideal we can point to. It was about distributing power evenly and having checks and balances in the most enlightened way possible.

That power equation IS out of whack, and it needs to be brought back into balance.

At what point do you stop staring at the minute details and say - Crap things are messed up.

When was the last time you heard a company take the long view about society? If corporations don't care because they have a need to make money, if the rule makers have been corrupted and the average user is irrelevant, if the impartiality of the referees/judges is being removed, then who is there to ensure the system works?

As someone pointed out - "I mean, do we have to wait until they grope us at checkpoints? Checked. Until they take websites down without trial? Checked. Until they start accusing journalist of espionage? Checked. Until they illegally tape the Internet? Checked."

Heck you have to get pissed off at some point before you do something about it. Its likely that the point has been passed.

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by elomar on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @08:13PM (#1985530)
IMHO, "not touching that" is not being neutral - is taking a position against WikiLeaks.

Being neutral would be more like "I'll let they keep doing their thing, like any other business."

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by Alex3917 on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @07:50PM (#1985463)
"We've railed on companies constantly in the past for being political"

I have no problem with companies being political, my only problem is when they use their disproportionate power to rewrite the laws in a way that screws all other stakeholders. Would Amazon hosting WikiLeaks be a case of a big company using their political influence to rewrite the laws to favor themselves while screwing everyone else? I don't think so, and I don't see any inconsistency.

Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by wtallis on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @10:12PM (#1985843)
It's a lot easier to classify what wikileaks does as "exercising first amendment rights" than to classify campaign donations as free speech.
Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by donaq on Wednesday December 08, 2010 @09:22PM (#1985721)
"All that is necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing."
Re:Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS by rbanffy on Thursday December 09, 2010 @09:23AM (#1987499)
> At what point is it OK to use a DDOS attack as a form of protest?

The DDoS may be the net analog to a street protest that provokes a traffic-jam.