News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by cs702 on Monday May 06, 2019 @09:30PM (#19845620)
> Microsoft’s integration of Linux in Windows 10 will interface with a userspace installed via the Windows Store...

Given Microsoft's history, I can't help but wonder if this wholehearted embrace of Linux is part of a classic Microsoft embrace-extend-extinguish strategy.[a]

Is the endgame a Windows-only userspace layered on top of the Linux kernel?

[a] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend,_and_extinguis...

Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by lake99 on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:53PM (#19846017)
They can embrace Linux, but they can't extend it in any meaningful way. By which I mean they can't ever create a Microsoft brand of packaged Linux. The Linux marketshare is already flooded with distros, and any software that earns revenue running on Linux runs on all the major distros more or less equally well. What could Microsoft create for which Microsoft Linux would be an option so compelling that companies would pay money to buy Microsoft Linux?

For example, MS could create a whole new graphical alternative to X and Wayland that works better than them both. Their challenge for capitalizing on that would be to create a software that works only somewhat well on X or Wayland, but works perfectly on MS Linux. I predict the Linux crowd will not use it. At best, they'll end up providing an alternative for the benefit of MS aficionados.

Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by dleslie on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:58PM (#19846046)
Why not? Google did it.

Android was an embracing of Linux, they extended it with Google Play Services, and now they're moving toward extinguishing it.

Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by pmilot on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:30PM (#19846245)
Except they are not extinguishing Linux as a whole, simply phasing it out of their own OS offerings. Linux itself is still alive and thriving, and will continue as such even after it has been replaced in Android and/or its successor.

The classic EEE strategy aims to eliminate a competitor entirely. If that was Google's plan (which I doubt), it was doomed to fail from the start.

Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by acct1771 on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @07:42AM (#19848493)
The classic EEE strategy is to "extinguish" the desirability of the open source offering compared to the perceived trick MS stuff, so the community shifts to the commercial offering.
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by comex on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @01:50AM (#19846947)
Other replies have contested your use of the EEE metaphor, but I think it’s important to look at why Google seems to want to get off Linux. There are a few, but the biggest one seems to be the intentional lack of a stable driver API/ABI. That’s historically been a large part of the reason Android devices haven’t received software updates, since SoC manufacturers make their own “vendor trees” of the entire Linux kernel, and all kernel updates have to go through them. Recently with Project Treble they’ve tried to make things more modular; AFAIK it’s made it easier to apply small changes like security updates, but if you want to update Linux to a new major version, you’re still at the mercy of the vendor. Now, if you ask upstream, that’s the vendors’ own fault for not upstreaming all their drivers so that upstream can maintain them for them – but upstreaming drivers is hard, and it doesn’t mesh well with the (crappy) hardware development culture of proprietary and one-off designs, so they don’t do it.

In contrast, Windows and macOS both have stable ABIs for third-party drivers, with the result that you can upgrade your OS to the latest version and install the same drivers and they’ll probably work. One notable exception was the Windows XP to Vista transition, which made a number of breaking changes that required new drivers… and just look how that turned out.

If Microsoft switched Windows to the Linux kernel, well… To start off, of course, there‘d be a one-time break of all existing drivers; popular devices already have equivalents in or for mainline Linux, but there’s a very long “long tail” of devices that don’t. But even more importantly, they’d be opting into the Android model of periodic breakage for perpetuity. In theory, they might be able to avoid that problem by forking the kernel and adding their own stable APIs on top. But that would require such deep changes that the resulting fork would either (a) have an “abstraction layer” big and complex enough to be a kernel of its own, (b) be unable to keep up with upstream refactorings and thus diverge permanently and rapidly from mainline, negating the benefit of adopting Linux in the first place… or, most likely, both of those. Never mind the amount of engineering effort required to build that, compared to maintaining the kernel they have. Or the licensing issues they’d encounter in an ecosystem that’s currently even more proprietary-oriented than Android. Or the control they’d be giving up over future development directions (although to be fair, you could have said the same about Edge).

So yes, Microsoft could embrace Linux as their new kernel. But they’d be crazy if they did.

Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by kelnos on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:25PM (#19846215)
But that doesn't negatively impact all the prior uses of Linux. The "extinguish" part means that they ruin Linux for everyone else. If Google stops using Linux as the kernel for Android... so what?
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by ufo on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:33PM (#19846267)
The embrace-extend-extinguish approach deprived us from non-Android (and non-Google) Linux on smartphones.
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by pjmlp on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @01:07AM (#19846767)
Try to get a pure GNU/Linux phone, that the market actually cares about.
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by cwyers on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:06PM (#19846103)
> What could Microsoft create for which Microsoft Linux would be an option so compelling that companies would pay money to buy Microsoft Linux?

Single-source licensing for enterprise-grade Linux and Windows, with a sweetheart deal. And they wouldn't have to do much, just take RHEL and offer certified builds and support. (Which is what Oracle does with their Unbreakable Linux.)

Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by martamorena on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @01:33AM (#19846886)
You know how expensive it is to write a Kernel? I wouldn't be surprised if Microsoft will ditch their own Kernel just as they ditched their own browser engine... Why waste time and money on something that other people do equally well or better for you for free? It's just business....
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by mimixco on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:08PM (#19846115)
If it looked like Windows,shared files with Windows, and ran Windows apps (via emulation or virtualization) that would be a huge deal in keeping companies on MS platforms, even if they're Linux underneath.
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by lake99 on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @06:44AM (#19857593)
Good point. The market segment of keeping companies on MS platforms is one I had not considered. That will certainly contribute to Linux not gaining a marketshare, and possibly fragment the overall Linux developers' ecosystem.
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by mimixco on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @11:30AM (#19859752)
IMHO, this is the strategy. MS can't extinguish Linux; it's too late for that. But they can make it invisible and a "non-issue" for users. That would be a big deal and arguably better for everyone. Pretty smart, Microsoft.
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by mixmastamyk on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @12:46AM (#19846676)
It might be useful. Novell did that with Netware, and things didn’t go so well. But they didn’t have cloud revenue.
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by userbinator on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:07PM (#19846108)
I'm feeling more like they want to inject their invasive "telemetry" into Linux too, or at least "normalise the deviance". I see their whole "we're open-source now" (mainly, open-sourcing code they can't really profit from anymore) and "friendly" face as merely trying to divert attention away from their darker side.
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by Quiark on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:23PM (#19845855)
I don't think they care about Windows that much any more. They even dissolved the team and it's now a part of Azure team / Office team.
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by hestefisk on Monday May 06, 2019 @10:42PM (#19845959)
“Don’t care” is probably a stretch. There is still a ton of corporates who pay MS license feee for Windows. It’s still a huge part of core revenue, but future long term. revenue streams will come from services and new platforms.
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by mr_toad on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:02PM (#19846075)
I think those corporations care more about ADS and all the user management infrastructure than they do about Windows desktop.

If they could manage Linux desktops with group policy settings they wouldn’t need Windows at all.

Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by cwyers on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:12PM (#19846135)
All it takes is one application that's Windows-only and a lot of places are locked in. And maybe it's an app that isn't made anymore, or maybe it's an internal line-of-business app with no ready off-the-shelf replacement.
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by kelnos on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:31PM (#19846253)
That wouldn't necessarily be a problem, though. They wouldn't kill the Win32/Win64 APIs or anything else that people tend to write Windows applications to, they would just replace NT with Linux and adapt the Windows APIs to run on Linux (basically WINE, but presumably Microsoft could do a more complete/compatible job due to all the institutional knowledge they have).

Some apps still wouldn't work, like anything that calls NT APIs, but they could make that work with a compatibility layer until they're ported.

I agree that this seems a bit unlikely, though. But who knows where their priorities may lie in the future?

Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by cwyers on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:39PM (#19846307)
Okay, flip it around -- how many places are using a piece of hardware that doesn't have a proper Linux driver? How many people are still using laptops where Linux has problems with sleep/hibernate? And where do the benefits of using the Linux kernel come from?
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by kelnos on Monday May 20, 2019 @04:37AM (#19958474)
I'm not disagreeing with this at all. Merely addressing the point made about what most apps are written using.
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by wbl on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @12:11AM (#19846487)
NT was the best part!
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by hestefisk on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @07:42AM (#19848489)
A significant amount of businesses worldwide are still run on Excel sheets and Access databases on SMB fileshares. Combine that with an insane amount of VBA code and you have something it is very hard to justify why you should spend time and money porting or virtualising when you can just keep it running on Windows. I work with very large banks and insurers and see this everywhere. Justify effort / cost / risk / benefits of that vs investing in new customer / ‘digital’ stuff that will actually sell more.
Re:Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10 by cwyers on Monday May 06, 2019 @11:03PM (#19846080)
...why? In the consumer/desktop hardware space, Windows has much, much better driver support. What benefit would they get from this?