News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mystery Frequency Disrupted Car Fobs in an Ohio City, and... by ajross on Sunday May 05, 2019 @09:33AM (#19832716)
And this, everyone, is why the FCC regulation of transmitter hardware is a good thing and a benefit to society.
Re:Mystery Frequency Disrupted Car Fobs in an Ohio City, and... by sokoloff on Sunday May 05, 2019 @09:51AM (#19832804)
And yet it's absurd when, to follow the law, you need to do testing on even unintentional radiators (with few exceptions) with a digital clock higher than 9 kHz (yes, kilo Hertz...)

I leave it up to you to guess what percentage of low-volume devices are actually tested, but I'm pretty sure "design it sensibly and we'll take the business risk that we're not going to get found and hosed by the FCC" is wildly more common than non-technical people would assume. For devices released in under quantity of 10K units, I bet the percentage of digital devices without intentional transmitters that are certified rounds to 0%. (Arduino was only FCC certified on the 5th version, IIRC.)

Re:Mystery Frequency Disrupted Car Fobs in an Ohio City, and... by davidgay on Sunday May 05, 2019 @12:33PM (#19833577)
> And yet it's absurd when, to follow the law, you need to do testing on even unintentional radiators (with few exceptions) with a digital clock higher than 9 kHz (yes, kilo Hertz...)

And the answer to "why 9 kHz?" is pretty obvious from: https://www.ntia.doc.gov/files/ntia/publications/2003-alloch...

Or do you think those "RadioNavigation" users magically don't care about interference?

Re:Mystery Frequency Disrupted Car Fobs in an Ohio City, and... by sokoloff on Sunday May 05, 2019 @01:27PM (#19833838)
This is a situation where the law and the actual practice is so diverged that we've basically just enshrined selective prosecution by the FCC.

Small volume manufacturers just try to design well and roll the dice because (almost?) no one is spending four figures on an accredited lab to do emissions testing on a device that sells a few dozen or couple hundred units per year.

Some try to find a way to indicate that it's used only in transportation, that it's industrial/commercial test equipment, that it's a peripheral device or sub-assembly and not a finished end-user device, others just realize that the FCC isn't going to bust down anyone's door because a device not emitting harmful RF doesn't have a testing certificate on file.

Re:Mystery Frequency Disrupted Car Fobs in an Ohio City, and... by mcbits on Sunday May 05, 2019 @11:01AM (#19833137)
His transmitter hardware was probably fine even if it was some $2 module direct from China (which it probably was), but he was transmitting constantly in a band designated for short intermittent or periodic signals and very low power.
Re:Mystery Frequency Disrupted Car Fobs in an Ohio City, and... by Aloha on Sunday May 05, 2019 @11:29AM (#19833271)
In this case, the transmitter was likely legal, and an FCC certified unit, it was just not complying with the rules as such for that band.

https://linxtechnologies.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/fcc_resou...

Re:Mystery Frequency Disrupted Car Fobs in an Ohio City, and... by sokoloff on Sunday May 05, 2019 @12:38PM (#19833598)
I would be fairly shocked if it turned out to be an FCC certified transmitter. (That's not to say I don't agree the primary issue was a duty cycle violation, but very few of the hobbyist modules on the market are FCC certified.)
Re:Mystery Frequency Disrupted Car Fobs in an Ohio City, and... by salawat on Sunday May 05, 2019 @09:51AM (#19832806)
How's that work anyway? I thought their certification on transmitters was meant to certify that the design didn't emit any extra RF noise other than that it was intended to, that the power of the generated signal was commensurate with its' intended use, and that it fell within a frequency band that wasn't reserved for something else.

The only thing that really chafes for me with the FCC is their absolute retardation with Internet regulation, and I'm still not sure I'm 100% okay with idea of "spectrum auctions". I get the idea behind it, but I seriously question the wisdom of anything that basically self-selects for corporate ownership over anyone else.

Still a bit of a noob on the RF scene though, so I've probably got nil real insight into the real reason the FCC is actually doing a good job.

Re:Mystery Frequency Disrupted Car Fobs in an Ohio City, and... by ldoughty on Sunday May 05, 2019 @11:06AM (#19833162)
I don't know much about RF, but essentially any device can act as a software defined radio.. loops, obviously, operate many times per second; if you use that loop to send power down a wire, you get software defined transmission.

If your power is going down a long wire, it tends to generally get better travel on the signal (for accidental transmitters, intentionally sending signals can can use math and design to better results)

So if your Arduino operates on a loop, and sends LOW voltage, and occassionally HIGH voltage, you get a radio. The frequency is not exactly always the loops executed per second, it tends to get mirrored onto many frequencies for some reason I'm not familiar with.. you can force it to a certain frequency by getting you loop to operate at a specific speed, but it will also appear in other frequencies.

Would love a radio guy to expand on my explanation here.

Re:Mystery Frequency Disrupted Car Fobs in an Ohio City, and... by myself248 on Sunday May 05, 2019 @11:49AM (#19833378)
> tends to get mirrored onto many frequencies for some reason I'm not familiar with.

Play with this for a few minutes: http://www.jezzamon.com/fourier/index.html

And watch any of these: https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=vibrating+reed+...

Okay, so think of a radio receiver as being sensitive to a particular frequency, because it has a filter in front of it. A vibrating reed of a specific length, if you will. (This is almost exactly true for certain types of crystal and SAW filters, actually.)

But when you flip a digital output from 0 to 1 or vice-versa, it changes state very quickly -- the output is essentially a square wave. (Physical limits mean it does have a finite slew rate...) Which means it contains components of every frequency. Think of coming up to one of those vibrating-reed meters and smacking it -- a single impulse excites ALL the reeds.

Smack it regularly (change the pin state at a specific frequency) and the reeds that're way off frequency will just sort of bounce around but not be particularly excited. You're creating noise, but it's just noise. But the reeds that're odd multiples of the smacking frequency will vibrate too -- these are the harmonics. They'll get really excited, almost as excited as the fundamental. (The evens essentially cancel out.)

Here's what it looks like on the radio spectrum: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eC36AqL5mw8

Incidentally, this is why so many chips now boast "slew-rate limited" outputs: to intentionally slow down those transitions, to reduce the amount of noise that has to be filtered and shielded in order for the device to pass RF emissions testing.

Re:Mystery Frequency Disrupted Car Fobs in an Ohio City, and... by couchand on Sunday May 05, 2019 @01:03PM (#19833720)
Perhaps you could spend a few moments thinking of a creative way to express your thought without the casually offensive language.