It helps the people who migrate and their families, at the cost of the development of the nation they're leaving behind who lose skilled workers, and it also hurts those left behind in the country that aren't receiving remittances as the influx of foreign cash raises costs and prices.
> More people means more customers.
And more workers (putting downward pressure on wages). More customers offsets that slightly by increasing demand for products, but between the effects of increasing labour supply and cash leaving the country (those remittances you brought up), is it a net positive for both sides? There are losers, where's the equilibrium?
> The question is whether and how to take all this into account in your cost-benefit calculation. It doesn't seem at all obvious to me, without actually doing the math
Of course you take everything into account when doing the maths. The problem is that those who make decisions are swayed by corporations and lobbyists, so they optimise for what's best for corporations, not necessarily citizens.
> Conclusion: this stuff is complicated.
Very. I studied it in university, it doesn't get simpler the deeper you go. And the answer of 'migration is always positive' is a simple answer, and doesn't take into account the winners and losers.
It seems like you're still thinking zero-sum? Someone moving to a richer company could send back more money than they could have possibly earned if they stayed home, while also earning and spending even more in their new country. Total spending is higher in both places. There are extreme cases of immigrants who started companies (which creates jobs), became fabulously wealthy, and also helped the whole village back home. Or things could go badly, of course; I don't claim this is what usually happens.
Just figuring out the total effect of remittances seems rather difficult, considering effects on trade balance. Are imports good or bad? How about exports?
In general, it seems like more economic activity is good? But there exceptions.
More people means more customers. There are certainly places with the problems that come from over-crowding, but places that lose population tend not to be doing too well economically.
The question is whether and how to take all this into account in your cost-benefit calculation. It doesn't seem at all obvious to me, without actually doing the math. And certainly you can't trust the judgement of random people who don't know much about what's going on outside of their everyday lives (which is most of us).
Conclusion: this stuff is complicated. Simple answers aren't to be trusted.