Re:London girl could be first to have “air pollution” listed...
by Someone on Saturday May 04, 2019 @11:37AM
(#19827099)
By that logic, nobody ever died of HIV. It only makes you immuno-deficient, opening the door for any of a zillion diseases (pneumonia, TBC, Kaposi’s sarcoma, cervical cancer, etc)
Also by the same logic, heart attacks do not kill, the resulting oxygen shortage does. Correction, it isn’t the oxygen shortage, it’s some chemical reaction in your brain cells that causes irreversible changes (experts in the field likely can split this in a sequence of multiple events)
If you take this chain to the limit, you end up with “you die because your cells die”, which is almost circular reasoning.
I think what matters is what’s the root or at least primary cause. If a child has asthma, would easily have survived in a normal (already polluted) city environment, but died because of living in an extremely polluted neighborhood, I would agree taking that as the cause of her death.
Back to the cheeseburger example: “died of overeating” (if eating a lot in a short time frame caused the heart attack) or “died of obesity” (if eating too much over a long period stressed the heart too much) could, IMO, be better descriptions than “died of a heart attack”
Also by the same logic, heart attacks do not kill, the resulting oxygen shortage does. Correction, it isn’t the oxygen shortage, it’s some chemical reaction in your brain cells that causes irreversible changes (experts in the field likely can split this in a sequence of multiple events)
If you take this chain to the limit, you end up with “you die because your cells die”, which is almost circular reasoning.
I think what matters is what’s the root or at least primary cause. If a child has asthma, would easily have survived in a normal (already polluted) city environment, but died because of living in an extremely polluted neighborhood, I would agree taking that as the cause of her death.
Back to the cheeseburger example: “died of overeating” (if eating a lot in a short time frame caused the heart attack) or “died of obesity” (if eating too much over a long period stressed the heart too much) could, IMO, be better descriptions than “died of a heart attack”