News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by simonh on Friday May 03, 2019 @06:57AM (#19817222)
Note the sneaky non sequitur at the end, which of course this being the Discovery Institute was the whole point of the article:

>Maybe it’s worse than they fear. Perhaps the brain doesn’t and can’t operate like a piece of machinery at all. And vice-versa.

Just because the brain may not work like an 'ideal' neural network running in a computer simulation, that doesn't in any way say that it couldn't be duplicated using a non-'ideal' neural network simulation.

It may just mean we need to adjust the form of the simulation.

Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by Jesus_Jones on Friday May 03, 2019 @12:52PM (#19820054)
Yeah, the discovery institute is just another creation science cover front. No science, just 'truth'. They try hard to look legit. And a fascinating fact is they are in Seattle of all places. It's a 'the earth is 9000 years old somehow' place and "let's cast suspicion on all science that contradicts the bible".
Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by winter_blue on Friday May 03, 2019 @07:07AM (#19817270)
You’re implicitly suggesting that the brain “operates like a piece of machinery” and that we just need to adjust the form of “simulation”. The problem with this is that you’re also implying that the brain (and human mind) is a deterministic system.

The implication of determinism is that everything is predictable. Given a set of inputs, in a deterministic system whose rules we fully know, the output is entirely predictable. We could extend this determinism to the whole universe, and reduce the universe into a pure function 'f' with a some specific initial state 'x'. Starting with f(x), for every unit quantization of time, f is applied on its previous result --- f(f(f....f(x)....))). And that's reality. (If you believe in a Big Crunch / Big Bang cycle, the output of 'f' at some point cycles back to the original 'x'.) The initial state 'x', and the definition of the universe function 'f' _is_ existence -- the totality of all that is.

I don't have any proof that we are not living in a deterministic universe, but all I can say is that, philosophically, I find the idea of determinism to be extremely upsetting. It empties life of any meaning. Why even continue living if everything you do was pre-programmed at the beginning of the universe? Determinism implies that the values of 'f' and 'x' could be blamed for the Holocaust. Moral responsibility becomes meaningless, because everything is pre-programmed. I think a lot of people, if they deep-down believed in this sort of mechanical determinism, they would sink into a very deep deep depression. I struggled with this myself, as a teenager—and I’ve emphatically rejected human mind determinism.

Believing in free will on the other hand, is very empowering. Believing in the concept of free will can in and of itself imbue one's life with a certain degree of meaning, purpose and drive. It means what you choose to do, matters. Life is meaningful; we’re not just empty automatons executing our pre-programmed futures under illusion of choice / free will. We are sentient beings with free being.

From the point of view of physics, I think free will in biological organisms will eventually be proven to some degree. The fact that in the last century, practically every physicist has come to accept that there's a lot of unpredictable behavior in matter, that cannot be deterministically predicted, and can only be described with probability distributions, has been very reassuring. My theory is that free will emanates from somewhere in these probability distributions, and is amplified in living organisms.

Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by elcomet on Friday May 03, 2019 @08:36AM (#19817829)
This is interesting. You are basically saying that free will is the same as non-determinism. I don't think that's the case. For me, non-determinism is just randomness (quantum for example), and doesn't imply free will. Can you just say 'your actions are random, therefore you have free will '?

First, 'free will' in the physics sense doesn't really exist. Everything is particles, and particles don't have 'will'. Your body is constituted of particles that follow their own path and interact. This can be deterministic or not, it doesn't matter.

Then, you can believe that there is something that we cannot see that can be called 'free will', like a soul, but this is a religious belief.

But we can look at free will in the philosophical sense. People have a conscience, they are conscious of themselves, and of their own free will. Also, your actions are only a product of your own inputs (your senses) and your outputs. I believe those are better arguments for defining free will. As free will doesn't exist in physics, we have to give it a definition. And I think this is true whether the universe is deterministic or non deterministic.

Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by winter_blue on Friday May 03, 2019 @11:20AM (#19819185)
> You are basically saying that free will is the same as non-determinism.

No, I'm saying that determinism precludes free will.

Free will is more than mere non-determinism / randomness.

I believe that people have souls, and they have free will. I reject the notion that we are all a bunch of soulless machines.

I can't offer you a physics theorem that proves the existence of free will and souls, but to me, it is experientially self-evident.

Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by elcomet on Friday May 03, 2019 @12:35PM (#19819874)
> No, I'm saying that determinism precludes free will. > Free will is more than mere non-determinism / randomness.

Yes, I even think that free will is not really related to the determinism / non-determinism of the universe, as I said earlier. Free will doesn't make sense in physics.

That's why I don't agree that determinism precludes free will. You can define free will in an other way, that is compatible with determinism. That's my point of view, you can read more about it : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compatibilism. Your view is called 'Incompatibilism', ie determinism and free will are mutually incompatible.

At the end, I think that most of it is a question of definition, but we can all agree that free will in a deterministic world is not the same as free will in a world where people have souls.

Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by Retra on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:23AM (#19818148)
On top of that, you can easily emulate non-determinism in deterministic systems and vice versa. So why would it even matter?
Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by winter_blue on Friday May 03, 2019 @10:13AM (#19818596)
It’s impossible to have actual non-determinism in a deterministic system. Non-determinism is emulated in software using random number generators. If you know the seed (the ‘x’) and the definition of the random function (the ‘f’), you can predict all outputs, analogous to my f(..(x)..) universe above.

There’s no programmatic random number generator that is truly random. (I mean random in the sense that it’s entirely unpredictable; not in the sense that the distribution of the random number generator covers all possibilities uniformly over many calls.)

Hardware random number generators are truly random (like the RDRAND instruction in x86 CPUs which is seeded by an on-chip entropy source). But if you’re relying on physical entropy, it’s not a deterministic system anymore. You simply can’t emulate non-determinism in a deterministic system.

Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by Retra on Friday May 03, 2019 @12:34PM (#19819857)
Why do you say 'actual'? I can emulate a chemical reaction in a computer, but that does not mean I have produced an 'actual' chemical reaction.
Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by dtech on Friday May 03, 2019 @11:47AM (#19819437)
How can you create non-determinism in a deterministic system without a source of randomness/non-determinism?
Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by Retra on Friday May 03, 2019 @12:27PM (#19819785)
You compute every possibility in parallel, and defer the selection of the 'true' result to some time-at-infinity. Once you've done this, realize that there's no difference within this system between selecting the 'true' result at random or using an algorithm, because the system would consider this result selection to be equally arbitrary in either case. (I.e., there's no way to prove that you've selected a specific result non-deterministically.)

A deterministic system emulates a non-deterministic one using (computational or data-) parallelism, and a non-deterministic system emulates a deterministic one using (temporal or spacial) aggregation.

We typically use random numbers to model non-determinism because it is computationally infeasable to track every possibility, but that is not the only way to do it, and nature doesn't appear to have this problem.

Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by winter_blue on Sunday May 05, 2019 @09:50AM (#19832799)
> there's no difference within this system between selecting the 'true' result at random or using an algorithm, because the system would consider this result selection to be equally arbitrary

This makes zero sense. Choices matter. Selecting one path could potentially result in the suffering of billions of people, and another path could result in the joy of the same billions.

> We typically use random numbers to model non-determinism because it is computationally infeasable to track every possibility

First, tracking every possibility has absolutely nothing to do with random selection. I don't know how you're mixing these two. We use pseudorandom number generators precisely because it is impossible to have true randomness within a deterministic system.

> You compute every possibility in parallel

I think you're alluding to some sort of multiverse theory -- and implying that since every possibility exists in parallel, choices are meaningless and nothing matters.

Except, we don't live in a multiverse -- a gobbledygook theory if ever there was one. Choices matter.

Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by Retra on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @05:40PM (#19863240)
>This makes zero sense. Choices matter.

Not in models that don't contain them.

>We use pseudorandom number generators precisely because it is impossible to have true randomness within a deterministic system.

"Nondeterminism" and "true randomness" can be modeled in deterministic systems. Your ability to deterministically construct those notions in your own brain is a weak proof of that. If I say "elephant", and you imagine an elephant, then you've modeled an elephant. You have not created an elephant, I'm not claiming you will, and I'm not claiming that you will get true randomness from a deterministic machine. I'm saying you can model it, and thus reason about it.

>I think you're alluding to some sort of multiverse theory.

I am not. I am alluding to parallelism being a computational feature which usefully serves as a model of nondeterministic processes.

I'm not talking about choices, meaningless or otherwise, I'm talking about modeling the concept that is invoked by your use of the word "nondeterminism." (Though you can also model nondeterministic choices as parallel thunks.)

My point is that for every nondeterministic function, there exists a deterministic function which will produce exactly the same outputs. Thus one cannot argue that nondeterminism offers any additional capabilities (beyond computational efficiency.) This is effectively the same as saying that every parallel computation can be executed sequentially, or that every strict computation can be computed lazily.

Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by eli_gottlieb on Friday May 03, 2019 @10:53AM (#19818955)
Stochastic determinism is still determinism, in the philosophical sense. On the other hand, certainly, the probabilistic (and metabolically/computationally bounded) nature of the mind is an important part of why it doesn't seem to fall into certain "paradox traps" the way a nonstochastic axiom schema might.

You should probably go right up on compatibilism about free will, because at this point, you're re-litigating a debate that hasn't been considered philosophically interesting or nontrivial for ages.

Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by kalado on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:46AM (#19818384)
Just build a non deterministic AI. Free will and true AI are not (necessarily) mutually exclusive.

"Free will" is a vague concept anyway. What does it really mean to make a decision? It already is heavily weighted by your knowledge and experience, everything else would be "random".

A smart (smarter than us) machine shouldn't have "free will" anyway, as all choices should be exhaustively evaluated for their pros and cons.

Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by xorfish on Friday May 03, 2019 @07:23AM (#19817363)
So your argument against determinism or non existing free will is that you don't like it if one of them were true? I find that very weak.

How does chance add anything to free will? If something is random, how does that add free will?

Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by dtech on Friday May 03, 2019 @07:55AM (#19817548)
> he problem with this is that you’re also implying that the brain (and human mind) is a deterministic system.

This is not a problem. This is a conclusion from the assumptions. Just because you don't like the conclusion does not mean it's incorrect.

Does a transistor have free will? does a protein? a bacteria? A sponge? A mouse? A dolphin? A human?

Another point of view of "free will" is that it's what we call a system that is so complex, has such good feedback loops and is so nuanced that it is capable of influencing itself. That is not exclusive with determinism.

Re:The Human Brain: Even Basic Facts Are Hotly Contested by frankbreetz on Friday May 03, 2019 @09:02AM (#19817998)
This argument has been going on for a while Einstine said:

"der alte herr doesn't throw dice" or "The old man (God) doesn't throw dice" His comment was in reference to Quantum Mechanics which is based on stochastic functions and make this deterministic approach invalid. This was one of the instances where Einstein was wrong.

https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1301/1301.1656.pdf