News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Questions About Food and Climate Change, Answered by rayiner on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @02:01PM (#19799860)
This is an awful article because it doesn't put numbers on the various alternatives. Without hard numbers, the discussion of alternatives is meaningless. Even going from an average diet to fully vegan will only reduce your food-related emissions by 40%, which only accounts for about 12.5% of your carbon emissions to begin with (in the US): http://www.greeneatz.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/foods-ca.... Cutting your CO2 footprint 5% is not going to do anything. Cutting it even less than that is utterly pointless.

"Doing your part" and "doing small things" will not have any impact on climate change. It ignores the enormous gap between where our emissions need to be and where they are now. If you could convince everyone in America to become a vegan tomorrow, that would cut global CO2 emissions by about a gigaton. That is how much CO2 emissions went up last year alone, mostly due to China and India. Think about that: the effect of every American undertaking an unprecedented lifestyle change all at the same time would be totally wiped out by a single year's growth globally.

Re:Questions About Food and Climate Change, Answered by firethief on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @03:44PM (#19800872)
Those numbers are under "How much would changing my diet actually help?" (one of the first questions), and "Climate-Friendlier diets" (with a graph)
Re:Questions About Food and Climate Change, Answered by specialist on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @03:04PM (#19800526)
I agree with both you and agentultra. I'm struggling to understand why. You're correct on the comparative impact. But I've long believed psychology is important too.

We lefties are frequently criticized, for better or worse, for hypocrisy. Maybe personal pro forma efforts will remove that rhetorical angle of attack.

Also, there's got to be some priming benefits, an opportunity to educate about the larger issues. However, my faith in this strategy has been rocked by failures (betrayal) of the whole recycling charade, which has served to alienate people and likely reduced future engagement.

I wish I knew what is best. Right now, I don't even have an opinion, just more questions.

Re:Questions About Food and Climate Change, Answered by agentultra on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @03:44PM (#19800876)
The psychological factor of feeling empowered to take control of your part of the world, however insignificant, is important I think.

"No silver bullet," is something I've said elsewhere. I don't think this article nor I have implied that if everyone went vegan then the climate crisis could be averted. I think it's a good article because it doesn't try to frame our dietary choices as a solution. It informs us of the impact of our choices and makes sure people realize that eating some meat is okay. But if you want to do more, you can, and it will have an impact -- however small -- and that's a good thing in my books.

Re:Questions About Food and Climate Change, Answered by acqq on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @04:31PM (#19801314)
> the effect of every American undertaking an unprecedented lifestyle change all at the same time would be totally wiped out

It really wouldn't. You totally underestimate the "role model" influence the US has on the rest of the world. If the dynamics of the US market would change, all other markets would race to follow in the same direction. This would also be both supported and driven by the individuals across the globe, doing what is "fashionable." Humans are slaves of fashions, even when when is appears improbable.