Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ...
by bobthepanda on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @01:09PM
(#19799263)
> they only need to last as far as the next charging point.
You had better hope that your bus doesn't get stuck in traffic on the way there, then.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ...
by chriswarbo on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @03:20PM
(#19800666)
Why? That's part and parcel of lasting as far as the next charging point.
I didn't say "assuming no traffic" or similar, because that would be silly.
You seem to be critiquing an incredibly flimsy straw man.
I would think busses are a very poor fit for batteries: their economics favours driving around for as long as possible (switching drivers in shifts). Any time spent charging is a waste.
This is less favourable than a consumer car, which sits around unused for most of the time (hence easily charged) and usually only makes a few short trips a day (e.g. commute).
I can understand the desire for supercapacitors on busses, since they are much quicker to charge than batteries. Putting chargers in the stops is a way to mitigate the low energy density of supercapacitors: they only need to last as far as the next charging point.
I think supercapacitors + fast charging stops makes busses very suited for electricity; but I don't think they're best suited for batteries (the fact that there are battery-powered busses shows that there's enough wiggle-room in the economics that they can work despite this unsuitability).