News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by MuffinFlavored on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @06:43PM (#19792736)
How much do today's "carbon recapture" methods need to grow? What's the timeline on them looking like?

P.S. The first Google result for carbon recapture is titled "“Direct air capture” of carbon dioxide won't solve climate change"

P.P.S From Wikipedia with a cited source:

capturing and compressing CO2 and other system costs are estimated to increase the cost per watt-hour energy produced by 21–91% for fossil fuel power plants;

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by rmcginnis on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @10:34PM (#19794029)
Hi, Rob from Prometheus here! Most of the skepticism about CO2 removal from the air is focused on "carbon sequestration and storage" or CSS, which is mitigation of emissions from fossil fuel by putting CO2 into the ground, for example. Turning CO2 from the air into useful products like fuels and building materials is much more capable of scaling because these products have value independently from regulations or carbon taxes/credits. If you can be the low cost producer of a commodity like gasoline or polyethylene, it's possible to grow zero or negative carbon capture very quickly to very large scale. If all transportation fuels, heating fuels, and plastics were from atmospheric CO2 capture, this would be more than 10 GT of CO2 a year, which is hugely significant.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by D_Alex on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @12:20AM (#19794511)
>Most of the skepticism about CO2 removal from the air is focused on "carbon sequestration and storage" or CSS, which is mitigation of emissions from fossil fuel by putting CO2 into the ground

That is false! Most of the skepticism about CO2 removal from the air is focused on the difficulty of said removal, compared with the relative ease of removing CO2 from eg power plant exhaust.

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by petre on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @03:31AM (#19795193)
> Turning CO2 from the air into useful products like fuels and building materials

You mean something like DME synthesis from CO2 and H2? Isn't atmospheric CO2 capture sort of expensive at 400 ppm? Obe would obtain one kilogram of CO2 from 2500 kgs of air.

Turning atmospheric carbon to building materials is already being done with plant based fiber mixtures such as hempcrete or fiber cement.

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by wehriam on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @01:21AM (#19794734)
Hi Rob! Is it possible to produce gasoline through atmospheric CO2 capture for less than traditional methods? Will CO2 capture be competitive in real costs?
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by IgorPartola on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @01:45AM (#19794841)
I cannot see how you could take CO2 and make gasoline out of it using less energy than what the gasoline contains. At best, you will need to supply that energy via something like solar panels. Then it becomes a question of efficiency: how many Watts of gasoline can you produce per Watt of electricity you have? My guess is, not many.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by whiskers08xmt on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @03:53AM (#19795276)
It can still be competitive with things like tar-sand extraction, which takes more energy than you get out of the oil. It's only economically viable because energy in gasoline/oil form is more valuable than the energy content itself, due to it's ease of transfer. Air sequestration might be a viable fuel source in regions where import costs of fuel are high, but energy is cheap.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by IgorPartola on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @08:44AM (#19796533)
I did not know that! Thanks.

I am less concerned about economic efficiency and more about environmental efficiency. The process to set up carbon sequestration facilities will itself produce CO2. If you produce a paltry amount of gasoline because all your energy is going towards that conversion, it might take you years or decades to actually reduce atmospheric CO2.

Even more important is the fact that the gas you produce and sell will go right back into the air as CO2, further reducing your net impact. You would basically need to produce gasoline faster than people can use it. Do you think a private company can do this process and outpace the consumption of Asia and Africa? It’s a catch 22: either your process is so inefficient that you pollute more than you clean up, or it’s efficient enough that you just drop the prices of gasoline, putting CO2 right back into the air. Their option is that you produce so much gasoline that you cannot sell it fast enough. Ironically that will tank your profits.

I think doing something other than gasoline is the answer. Make fertilizer: it will help grow the ecosystem while not immediately winding up as CO2.

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by foobarian on Thursday May 02, 2019 @08:53PM (#19814514)
This is false, the net energy is positive for tar sands it is just less than for conventional oil extraction.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by EamonnMR on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @06:31AM (#19795881)
The ideal method would be CRISPRing up some algae to synthesize gasoline, but we're pretty far from that.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by trickstra on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @03:32AM (#19795198)
you cannot. That would be a perpetuum mobile
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by solotronics on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @11:26PM (#19794292)
very exciting! Do we know yet if gasoline is the most efficient hydrocarbon to make from CO2 for a given amount of electricity? I would think there are a whole range of oil like things that could be produced. I always dreamed about using nuclear power to do all kinds of terraforming type things that would otherwise be energy inefficient.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by fallingfrog on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @11:30PM (#19794315)
It’s not thermodynamically possible to recapture carbon from the air without using more energy than was obtained by burning it the first place.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by onlyrealcuzzo on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @12:06AM (#19794462)
Thermodynamically, no. But is that the question?

We're a long way away from consuming so much energy we thermodynamically scorch the Earth, right?

It seems like they want to know if you can be mostly carbon neutral and generate existing fuels.

If that's the case, then if you have access to a cheap form of renewable energy -- huge amounts of geothermal, tidal, or solar -- you could generate a ton of something-like-gasoline, reduce carbon, and come out nearly neutral when re-burning it.

Theoretically, you can profit if the renewable source of energy is cheaper than the cost of generating and distributing the fuels.

I'm skeptical this is possible. But if it is, I'm optimistic it will actually happen.

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by IgorPartola on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @01:49AM (#19794856)
It is the question. You need to break up the CO2 molecule and reconstitute it as gasoline. That will take more energy than the gasoline had initially. So you have a process where you take say solar energy and convert it into gasoline chemical bonds. Great, what is your efficiency of this process? Because if it is close to 100%, great. But chances are it is much closer to 0, at which point you’d be better off just using that electricity for something else.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by trickstra on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @03:36AM (#19795218)
True, many people don't realize this. But carbon capture solutions don't necessarily need to be efficient - we are not doing it to make more energy, we are doing it to clean up the many decades of mess we already made in the atmosphere. So yes, we will have to spend energy, to clean that up, naturally. The most important part is that none of these solutions is exclusive and shouldn't be pictured as exclusive. We need to offset fossil fuels, lower our energy use, and suck CO2 from the atmosphere. All three of them.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by neotek on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @07:27AM (#19796129)
>But chances are it is much closer to 0, at which point you’d be better off just using that electricity for something else.

Unless your ultimate goal is not just to use energy efficiently, but to recapture carbon dioxide.

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by IgorPartola on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @08:34AM (#19796462)
Solar panels take energy to produce, transport, and install. Mining the lithium needed to produce them is pretty harmful to the environment. Other parts of the process are pretty bad too. If your efficiency is too low, if you install a gigawatt power plant and produce a half gallon of gasoline a month, you will take way too long to get an emissions ROI. Just recapturing CO2 requires less energy than recapturing and reconstituting it as gasoline. Sure you can sell the gasoline and maybe make some $$ but will that actually in the end be a net negative for the atmospheric CO2? The answer will 100% depend on efficiency.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by rebuilder on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @05:50AM (#19795736)
As an aside, we're not that far from boiling the oceans at the current rate of growth in energy usage. Maybe 400 years, IIRC.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by aaronblohowiak on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @11:58PM (#19794426)
Hydrocarbons are better energy stores than batteries. If we can “charge your car” by pumping hydrocarbons into it, that is better than lugging around heavy batteries (maybe.) so, in a way, co2 -> gasoline via solar power (or nuke) is an overall win.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by bjelkeman-again on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @01:08AM (#19794679)
I personally doubt the energy cost for the conversion is so low that it makes sense, but would like to see that demonstrated. Then you are still burning hydrocarbons, which is a big health problem.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by aey on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @11:58PM (#19794425)
I imagine the goal is to use renewables for the energy required for capture.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by ZhuanXia on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @12:13AM (#19794480)
The esoteric read on this, then, is it is a bet on fusion.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by trickstra on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @03:41AM (#19795235)
And before that?
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by rayiner on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @07:03PM (#19792883)
The author of the article (who does not appear to be an expert in anything) overlooks that renewables only address part of the emissions picture. Even if the U.S. switched tomorrow to 100% renewables and 100% electric vehicles (including trains, cars, planes, and ships), and you ignore the CO2 emissions of making all those new power plants and vehicles, U.S. usage would only go down by 3.5 gigaton: https://www.epa.gov/climate-indicators/climate-change-indica.... It won't change the CO2 emissions created by home and commercial heating, agriculture, and industrial uses, which add up to another 3.5 or so gigatons.

And even the U.S. and EU going to 0 carbon emissions wouldn't offset the growth in India, China, and Africa. And those places are a long ways away from electric cars and solar power plants. (Also, where would you put them in say India or Bangladesh?) Carbon recapture can do a very important thing renweables cannot--allow the developed world to suck out the developing world's CO2.

The current cost of carbon capture is about $120 per ton. If it follows the same trend as improvements on solar panel cost, that could be $40 per ton in a decade. At that price it would cost $300 billion annually to remove the extra carbon India will be adding to the atmosphere by then. That will be just 5% of India’s GDP by then.

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by belltaco on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @11:56PM (#19794410)
>And those places are a long ways away from electric cars and solar power plants. (Also, where would you put them in say India or Bangladesh?)

Huh? What does that mean? You mean there is so space in India or Bangladesh to put solar power plants?

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by natch on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @07:56PM (#19793224)
>It won't change the CO2 emissions created by home and commercial heating, agriculture, and industrial uses, which add up to another 3.5 or so gigatons.

So address each one in turn, or in parallel. You give no reason not to.

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by Gibbon1 on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @08:29PM (#19793403)
Lot of people use the 'golden hammer or nothing argument'

Meaning if a proposed solution is partial then we shouldn't do anything. It flies in the face of the reality that most solutions to complex problems involve chipping away at them.

Currently there is a host of technologies which emit to much CO2. Personal transportation is just one of them.

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by MuffinFlavored on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @08:02PM (#19793260)
> The current cost of carbon capture is about $120 per ton. If it follows the same trend as improvements on solar panel cost, that could be $40 per ton in a decade.

This sounds reasonable to me. Do you believe this will be the way forward most likely?

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by ip26 on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @10:21PM (#19793975)
We can only hope. It's super early in the development of carbon capture, so hopefully there's still a couple 50% cost reductions ahead
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by D_Alex on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @12:26AM (#19794530)
>The current cost of carbon capture is about $120 per ton

I don't know where you got this from (citation?), but I am sure this is not the cost of capturing CO2 from the atmosphere via "technology" (trees - arguably yes).

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by bjelkeman-again on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @01:11AM (#19794693)
Carbon Engineering claims it will be between US$94 and $232.

https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2018/06/calgary-company-can-ca...

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by D_Alex on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @02:35AM (#19795029)
I have reviewed the original paper which from which the "$94-$232" estimate is obtained. You can find it here: https://www.cell.com/joule/fulltext/S2542-4351(18)30225-3

My comments are as follows:

1. Obviously, this is not the current cost, but an estimate for a hypothetical future plant.

2. You can get wildly differing estimates through a series of small discrepancies in the assumptions. Comparing the provided estimate (Table 2 in above link) to the estimates for other CO2 capture projects the following things stand out immediately: a) 7.5% CRF calculation should be ignored as unrealistic, 12.5% CRF is okay; b) O&M costs are low, for complex plant with caustic chemicals and high temperatures a fair assumption may be 6% of CAPEX per year rather than approx 3% c) 20% contingencies at the conceptual stage are too low, 40% would be perhaps defensible. Also, I don't see a basis for including Row D in the table, the commercial assumption is not justified.

Considering the above, if all goes well, plant number 100 might be able to capture CO2 for $200-300/tonne, better than the current claimed $600/tonne for a plant actually in operation, but nowhere near as good as other options.

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by aoner on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @05:34PM (#19801857)
Don't forget that there are also low temperature DAC routes that can use waste heat (climeworks, global thermostat, antecy, skytree). If you get the heat for free you only need energy for your fans. This drastically reduces the price. There are some good papers that do proper cost analysis on DAC. 100$ or lower is within range in a decade. I'm not in front of my computer now but if your interested I'll send the papers
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by D_Alex on Thursday May 02, 2019 @05:23AM (#19806084)
That would be great, my "anon" email is in my profile.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by hairytrog on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @07:39PM (#19793112)
You should read about process heat from nuclear. There's several companies aiming to do this: https://usnc.com/MMR.html
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by maxerickson on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @09:57PM (#19793871)
How do you switch to 100% renewables and then still have CO2 emissions from heating?

Is the first statement just about transport?

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by rayiner on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @10:09PM (#19793921)
A plurality of home and commercial heating in the US involves direct burning of fossil fuels. So even if the grid is 100% renewables, you’re talking about spending thousands of dollars per house to replace oil and gas furnaces with heat pumps.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by maxerickson on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @10:32PM (#19794024)
Okay, so 100% renewable grid.

A rapid transition would be hellishly expensive, but new installations can certainly be looking at heat pumps.

I wonder if there is a way to structure penalties/incentives so that home builders and landlords end up installing systems with lower lifetime costs (and lower environmental impact), rather than whatever is cheapest upfront.

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by natch on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @07:59PM (#19793243)
>wouldn't offset the growth in India, China, and Africa. And those places are a long ways away from electric cars

On the contrary, China is going crazy for electric cars. And the U.S. and EU are starting to turn as well. I wonder where you are getting your ideas.

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by rayiner on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @09:41PM (#19793802)
China put 28 million cars on the road in 2018. 95% were ICE. China put over 1 million heavy trucks on the road in 2018. Almost all were ICE. By 2025, the government aims to get it down to 80% ICE. That’s at least another 100 million new ICE vehicles on the road in the next half decade, plus the 300 million existing vehicles (which in developing nations are retired very slowly). Compared to maybe 20 million EVs if the government meets its target. China is currently building new coal fired capacity equal to the total amount of US coal generation capacity—and many times the renewables capacity it has added in the last year. Power plants are long term investments. These plants will be in service for decades to come.

Again, we need to cut 19 gigatons in the next decade. If “going crazy for electric cars” means that 80% of new cars—forget existing cars, and new trucks, etc.—will still be ICE half a decade from now, emissions reduction is not going to work.

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by MuffinFlavored on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @08:02PM (#19793255)
> Carbon recapture can do a very important thing renweables cannot--allow the developed world to suck out the developing world's CO2.

What would that look like? Pipes on top of smoke stacks in China? Big mesh blanket clouds in the sky?

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by erik_landerholm on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @06:58PM (#19792853)
https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/02/190212160020.h...

There is a lot of work. I'm not an expert, but it seems like our early attempts are orders of magnitude off in terms of efficiency, but there have been some breakthroughs using nano-tech to create custom structures that are much more efficient, but i'm sure it needs a lot more research and money to become commercially viable.

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by ForHackernews on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @09:19PM (#19793702)
Realistically, "carbon recapture" barely exists today. It's a science experiment / excuse to avoid reducing emissions.
Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by eganist on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @06:56PM (#19792832)
I have to wonder how much of the innovation here will couple advancements in catalytic conversion with accepted inefficiencies in "storing" renewable energy by sourcing from the atmosphere.

Because that's essentially what these initiatives are doing. They're seeking to artificially tighten the carbon cycle so that we can maintain the status quo indefinitely.

Re:A Quest to Make Gasoline Out of Thin Air: Prometheus (YC ... by MuffinFlavored on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @08:05PM (#19793275)
> so that we can maintain the status quo indefinitely.

Is that good enough? I've read that in China, they have some days where there are warnings to stay inside because there are random green substances in the air?