News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by bluGill on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @10:45AM (#19788364)
In the US fired means for cause. When you are fired they are legally saying you are a bad employee and they can/will tell others not to hire you. This implies they can not give your severance because the time you "worked" for them without doing your job is your severance. You don't get unemployment because you were not actually working. Contrast this with laid off which means you were a good employee, they just don't need you anymore: you can get severance (if there is any, it is not required).

If/when you employer is going to fire you ask if you can resign on the spot instead. Most will say yes: because you resigned of your own violation you cannot sue them, but in turn when someone checks references they will carefully say "yes s/he worked here, s/he left in good report, we have nothing more to say", which doesn't look bad.

Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by bryondowd on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @12:18PM (#19789288)
This just isn't true, at least in New Jersey. For NJ Unemployment, being fired only renders you ineligible if you are fired for misconduct, which is further defined as requiring intent or sufficient negligence to imply a disregard for the job. Meanwhile, employers aren't limited to firing you for misconduct or layoffs. You can be fired because you're just not a good fit for the team/position. In that case, you are eligible for unemployment because you didn't quit but didn't commit misconduct. If you asked to resign instead of being fired, you'd be giving up your right to collect NJUI.

I can't speak for other states, but I'd be surprised if NJ is entirely unique.

Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by gamblor956 on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @02:54PM (#19790793)
No, what he said is true in NJ and generally all over the US.

While being "fired" is commonly used by laymen as a shorthand for being laid off, the two have very different meanings in practice (and very different legal consequences).

Being "fired" in the US means a termination "for cause", where cause generally means commission of a felony, morally reprehensible acts, deception in the hiring process, or violation of rules set forth in the employee handbook.

Being "laid off" means a termination for any reason other than for cause. For example, if you are terminated because you are a "Bad fit", you have been laid off, not fired.

If you asked to resign instead of being fired, it would have not affect on your right to collect NJUI, because you wouldn't be eligible either way. No one in their right mind would choose to resign over being laid off unless the company was offering a termination bonus that exceeded the foregone UI.

Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by bryondowd on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @04:33PM (#19791648)
I've never heard of a termination based on individual performance being called a layoff. In fact, I'm fairly certain it's defined as a termination due to factors outside the employee's control. A layoff is when the position itself no longer exists due to downsizing, restructuring, etc.

Being terminated due to poor performance or a bad fit is not a layoff, by any standard I've heard of, and some brief googling seems to support that. Terminating an employee for being a bad fit and calling it a layoff would almost certainly invite legal action.

But I'm no lawyer, so if you've got a source backing up the claim, I'd love to see it and be enlightened.

Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by gamblor956 on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @05:39PM (#19792238)
I've never heard of a termination based on individual performance being called a layoff. In fact, I'm fairly certain it's defined as a termination due to factors outside the employee's control. A layoff is when the position itself no longer exists due to downsizing, restructuring, etc.

You admit that you're not a lawyer, and then continue to argue about the meaning of terms which have defined legal consequences?

Your colloquial understanding of what "layoff" means is just that--a colloquial but not correct understanding. A layoff is legally just a not-for-cause termination of an employee by the employer. Down-sizing is a type of termination (and a type of layoff) which usually has additional legal requirements and consequences (mostly for the company).

Being terminated due to poor performance or a bad fit is not a layoff, by any standard I've heard of, and some brief googling seems to support that.

Cites needed. HR and legal sites only. You might be confusing the Canadian and EU sites that pop up as the first results as authorities on US law, which is very different. (Note: Canada does define "layoff" and "termination" to mean different things. The US does not.)

Terminating an employee for being a bad fit and calling it a layoff would almost certainly invite legal action.

Literally anything can invite legal action in the US. But terminating an employee for being a bad fit is precisely within the meaning of "layoff" and would not result in a successful legal action by the terminated employee.

But I'm no lawyer, so if you've got a source backing up the claim, I'd love to see it and be enlightened.

I charge $600/hour, if you want cites, however, Google is free if you remember to limit yourself to US sites. This ADP article (https://www.adp.com/spark/articles/2018/09/firing-employees-...) confusingly notes the difference between the two from a non-legal/non-HR perspective intended for layman employers.

Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by pnutjam on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @12:36PM (#19789469)
I don't think that would help you in most circumstances. I know when I worked for HP, they had a policy of only confirming the dates of employment. Beyond that, I think some employers will indicate if an employee is rehirable, which I'd guess your not if you were getting fired.
Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @11:12AM (#19788638)
In my country (Netherlands) there's some strict laws around firing; the situation you described (being a bad employee and getting fired on the spot) only applies for a few cases; refusal to work (without good reason, probably the most up for debate reason), theft, fraud, or severe incompetence. The other cases though require a more formal release procedure and compensation.

However, to work around that some companies get up to some really scummy practices. Multinationals especially, they can just let a company go bankrupt so there's no way for employees to get anything.

Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by bluGill on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @11:28AM (#19788808)
You are typically not fired on the spot in the US. The law allows it, but generally it only happens for the good reasons you listed. Most cases you are doing useful work, just "not enough", and the company will try to help you produce enough. If those attempts fail to work out they will fire you, but you should have seen it coming for months.
Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by BrandoElFollito on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @12:16AM (#19794500)
In France (and I belive everywhere in Europe) your employer is not allowed to comment on your employment at all.

The only thing they can confirm is that you were employed, from when to when, and the position you had. Full stop.

Not your salary, not whether you were "good" or not, nothing. They can of course tell w great your were if you explicitly allow them.

Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by garmaine on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @11:39AM (#19788900)
> You don't get unemployment because you were not actually working

Nope. You have to get fired (with or without cause, doesn’t matter) to collect unemployment in most US jurisdictions.

Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by gamblor956 on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @02:56PM (#19790806)
Nope, you have to get terminated "without cause" (i.e., laid off) to collect unemployment in most of the US.

If you are terminated with case (i.e., fired), you are generally not eligible for unemployment, though there are a few exceptions.

Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by garmaine on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @03:37PM (#19791152)
In California it is misconduct which disqualifies you, which doesn’t include more common “with cause” cases. I don’t know about other jurisdictions.
Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by gamblor956 on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @05:48PM (#19792339)
Laymen, especially techies, often assume that termination for "poor performance" or "bad fit" is a "for cause" termination because there is a "cause" behind the termination, but that is an incorrect understanding of employment law.

Businesses always have a "cause" for letting someone go (usually financial or performative), so the inartfully term "for cause" actually means a cause for something other than business considerations. Generally, today "for cause" means misconduct. Each state enumerates a different set of activities constituting misconduct, but there is always some sort of misconduct involved.

(Unfortunately I no longer have the employment law book where they cover the history behind the origination of this term and I don't have the time to google an alternative history, but in a nutshell it's shorthand for a somewhat longer phrase.)

Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by garmaine on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @06:04PM (#19792473)
Not always. “With Cause” is defined in employment contracts quite a bit more broadly than just misconduct in all its forms. For example, my most recent contract had terms about the company hypothetically requiring relocation and I refusing as being “With Cause,” as well as things like not complying with internal rules, procedures, or org charts. Basically any reason for letting me go due to a choice I made. “Misconduct” on the other hand requires material detriment, aka me screwing over the company financially.

“With Cause” is about you being qualified for severance pay. “Misconduct” is about you causing trouble through intent or severe negligence.

Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by bluGill on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @09:05AM (#19796649)
That might be different for the legal term "With Cause" though. It is common for legal documents to define terms, many laws in fact start with a definition section that apply just to that law. Thus legally your state may have several different definitions for "with cause" that apply to different parts of the law.
Re:Can your employer fire you after you quit? by gamblor956 on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @10:24AM (#19797241)
That's cool but that's not legally for cause in the US whatever the company wants to claim. I'd go even further and say they may be violating labor law but including such a provision.