The Sorcerer's Apprentice was written about 200 years ago and is as current as ever.
The “counterpoint”, that women were not as well suited toward engineering roles due to their biology, was “offered” on a company mailing list.
While this is, notably, what a Microsoft employee in a non-engineering role reportedly said (in an unclear and unexplained reference to purported "thought patterns") referencing their own diversity efforts, Damore's memo did not allege that women at Google or any other company might be less suited; only that the pool of those who would be interested enough to pursue the field in the first place might be smaller.
It did though. Damore hedges a bunch, but
>I’m simply stating that the distribution of preferences and abilities of men and women differ in part due to biological causes and that these differences may explain why we don’t see equal representation of women in tech and leadership.
Can be reduced to
> I’m simply stating that the distribution of [...] abilities of men and women differ in part due to biological causes and that these differences may explain why we don’t see equal representation of women in tech and leadership.
It is really saying there are fewer suitable women. Which is true, and there is a huge movement to remedy that by making it more inclusive. Not that I'm on-board with lowering the bar hiring unqualified applicants or anything, but I think changing project structures to use better use underutilized talent is great for employers and employees.
Though, IMHO, the most honest way to do any of this is by evaluating candidates sight unseen, with no name presented, to remove bias. I like that other approaches are attempted, but this one is my favorite. It doesn't make my resume less favorable. :)
About abilities, it's well known that men have a higher standard deviation of IQ, which, as Damore explained, means there are more men of high IQ than there are women. Google preferentially hires high IQ people so it will be skewed towards men, all else being equal.
Not really. Science certainly agrees that there are differences between males and females. But if you can find me a peer reviewed article showing a causal relationship between sex and performance in a software engineering career, controlling for environmental and social factors, you'd be the first.
> Google preferentially hires high IQ people so it will be skewed towards men, all else being equal.
Note here you aren't arguing about performance, but about culture. But to throw a wrench in your argument, Google hires mostly college graduates, which as we all know, skew female. Sprinklinga wrong "ceteris paribus" into your line of thinking isn't conducive to interesting discussion.
Yes, I think they probably do get more females by preferring graduates than they would if they didn't have that bias towards graduates.
What do you mean by a wrong ceteris paribus? Of course it's wrong in the sense that all else isn't equal in reality, but you can still consider what would happen if it was. Or do you mean it's not even possible for all the other factors to be constant because they're correlated with the one we're changing so we still have to make a choice about which ones to really hold constant?
And that said, obviously retaliation is going to vary on the scenario. You're essentially saying that they deserve retaliation for reporting sexual harassment etc because of an entirely separate incident.
No, that's a complete non-sequitur from what they said.
It's bizarre how such an obvious point is being described as grasping at straws, a non-sequitur etc.
Of course, there are individuals like yourself who have a different perspective on that -- and for the purposes of keeping this discussion on topic I'll avoid sharing my views on that. Regardless, it is different from being fired or punished for reporting sexual harassment or racial discrimination. There is substantially no political group who, at least publicly, would espouse the view that such reports are wrong, or should be punishable in any way. Except I suppose if they are found to be baseless. So if someone suffers adverse consequences due to making such reports, assuming they are made in good faith, almost everyone would agree that that is retaliation.
Not quite: retaliation is when someone experiences adverse consequences for using the proper channels and methods to try to do the right thing.
They are allowed to be wrong about whether their complaint or concern is actionable; as long as the employee was proceeding properly they are protected against retaliation.
It is not true that he stated women are less suited to the job. It is possible that he was implying it. Firing him for something he did not say, but may have implied, is weak. Destroying a person's livelihood for an imagined offense WHILE the company releases a statement that they encourage widespread opinions is even weaker.
I don't understand how that's relevant. I mean I grant you that wrongdoers often believe they are doing right. That is true in almost any context. The issue is about whether wrong is being done -- by which I mean, the consensus viewpoint on that question -- not how the wrongdoers feel about their wrongdoing.
(I see your other paragraph, but I'm not responding to it because, as I said earlier, I don't wish to discuss my views on it. I'm not afraid to talk about it, but I don't think it would move this particular discussion forward.)
Also, politics is human decency. It's a way of imposing our morals onto everyone else. Some people (protesting Googlers) think killing people in wars is against human decency. It is, and it's also political.
Be specific, what wrongs of the past? Which straight white male employee of Google today is benefiting from what tipped scales of the past? How about the straight asian males [like the CEO], are they also benefiting from tipped scales? What about white females, are they also carrying the unspecified guilt burden of their forefathers?
Don't try to make a workplace more attractive to women because it's better to criticize people from the past instead?
> Awful convenient for the straight white males to be demanding equality now
Do you want equality or do you want oppression of the popularly marginalized group (straight white males) as punishment for what different people from the same group did in the past?
Consider two people who are equally qualified; one is a straight white male, the other is a minority gay woman. The fact that they're equally qualified demonstrates the minority gay woman is a better hire, because she did the same as the straight white male, but with fewer resources. It stands to reason then that providing her with additional resources will result in a higher output than what the straight white male would be capable of.
The reality is, straight white males are given plenty of extra resources and opportunities, and despite that they're very frequently on the same level as people who have been given less. Those are the situations that are relevant; no one is hiring unqualified people to do jobs.
If Harvard accepted every qualified applicant, they'd have to triple their enrollment. The reality is there are very often too many well qualified people and not enough slots, be it a job or any admissions/application process. Pretending like less qualified people are being let in, and the straight white males are being denied despite being just as good is a complete lie.
By providing opportunity to minorities in hiring, Google is simply leveling the playing field. It's beginning the process of giving those minorities opportunities that have been granted to straight white males for literally millennia.
"I look to a day when people will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character."
You gave an example of how you want to oppress straight white males, and that actually happens, which is why I believe they're oppressed.
Millennia? Since nobody lives that long, it's clear that you want revenge on a whole class of people for something that different people did.
And no, I don't want revenge on anyone, stop focusing on yourself. This is about giving people who don't have resources more of them, and in so doing finding the true bright spots on this planet.
If you think this has anything to do with individual punishment, you're a lost cause...
I can think of two ways you might justify your view:
A) By assuming that every member of a class has the same characteristics as the class average. This overlooks the existence of privileged wealthy gay black female from Portland who grew up being glorified as a precious minority and of disadvantaged poor straight white males from Appalachia who were abused as children and taught by their whole society that they weren't meant to be successful. You want to give extra advantage to the already-advantaged person because different individuals in her class are disadvantaged.
B) Class-based revenge. You accept that individuals are different from their class averages, but it's OK to push some disadvantaged people down and lift advantaged people up as long as it's consistent with your view of which class should be punished for their collective situation. This option seems more realistic because it's not factually wrong like A), and it's consistent with your reference to the millennia of opportunities. There's nothing anybody can do to change the thousands of years of now-dead people so their advantages should have no bearing on what happens today. But you still mentioned them. Maybe you want to correct the balance between classes by putting the advantage in the other direction for another few millennia, under the assumption that two wrongs make a right.
You chose race, sex, and sexuality as your classes because that's what your culture told you it's OK to discriminate on. You didn't chose history of psychological abuse, mental illness, wealth, intelligence, having powerful friends, quality of parenting, chronic pain, height, physical attractiveness, or any of the other ways that people have different advantages to each other. You don't care about real people with real differences, and only care about the classes that your culture has told you are important. Have you asked yourself why race is more important to you than intelligence or age, which have much more consistent and severe histories of discrimination?
> Pretending like less qualified people are being let in, and the straight white males are being denied despite being just as good is a complete lie.
Harvard is being sued for racial discrimination. Though the lawsuit is about Asians, whites suffer similar though less severe discrimination: https://www.npr.org/2018/11/02/660734399/harvard-discriminat...