News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by mochomocha on Sunday April 28, 2019 @01:49PM (#19772506)
"My parents got here before" shouldn't entitle you to a lower tax rate than anyone else. This is feudalism.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by avar on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:40PM (#19772833)
Property taxes can be viewed as a form of feudalism. You never outright own your property, and if you're not productive enough (can't pay your property tax) your feudal lord (the government) will throw you out and find someone else who is more productive.

You can sensibly critique Proposition 13, but calling it "feudalism" is nonsense. It's the opposite, it's basically carving out a limited exemption in a partially feudal system for some citizens over others. Is it dumb? Sure, unequal? Definitely. But it's not "feudal", it's making the system less so.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by thaumasiotes on Sunday April 28, 2019 @05:44PM (#19773903)
My understanding of European feudalism (which is sparse, and comes from https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00XTAXZAU/ ) is that it is characterized by the following features:

- The owner of land owns it outright. If you own land, you don't pay taxes on it to anyone. It's yours.

- Ownership of land is inalienable. Your land is yours, and you can't sell it or otherwise transfer ownership (except through inheritance).

- Land generates revenue through the collection of dues from peasants who would like to work it.

- The feudal dues associated with a stretch of land are fixed by tradition and, like the ownership of the land, can't be changed. This is why European peasant reform movements emphasized stable measurement units so heavily -- since lords couldn't change the nominal amount of feudal dues, changes were actually implemented by messing with the size of the units those dues were measured in.

- The king has no tax authority. He gets his revenue from the land he owns, just like every other noble does.

It is a radically decentralized system, even for the rest of the world at the time, and it reflects the very low level of societal development in feudal Europe.

The US property tax system is nothing like this. The government owns ALL the land, and no one else can ever own any. The government has tax authority over the land and many other things.

The proposition 13 system does look like it's trying to move things in the direction of feudalism, as far as I can see. It's even trying to make sure land can't be sold, in that when you sell your land, all the tax benefits are lost.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by solidsnack9000 on Monday April 29, 2019 @12:13AM (#19775771)
The owner of land owns it outright. If you own land, you don't pay taxes on it to anyone. It's yours.

Generally, nobles held land under "feudal tenure" and not "allodial tenure" (the latter is "outright" ownership). Under feudal tenure, the noble did not owe taxes but they did owe "service" which they could try to make up with goods and money instead.

The service was onerous. Generally, showing up with a sword and shield and an army fitting your station.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feudalism_in_England#Varieties...

Along with the main service there could be many more specific services. One example of many: in the present day, there is a noble family in England that is required to set out three glasses of Brandy or Cognac or another strong spirit on a certain holiday, so that the reigning monarch may come by and drink them if she so chooses.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by User23 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @07:32PM (#19774538)
> The US property tax system is nothing like this. The government owns ALL the land, and no one else can ever own any. The government has tax authority over the land and many other things.

Just a quibble, but, with the exception of federal lands, it's the individual states that levy property tax in their territory. Allodial title is what it's called when you have no obligations on the property. Nevada allowed limited allodial title, but it only lasts for the life of the owner. The way the implemented it was they computed an estimated total property tax and the owner would buy out the state's interest for his lifetime[1]. It actually provides additional privileges besides property tax exemption. Liens can't be enforced on an allodium, among other privileges.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allodial_title#Nevada

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by thaumasiotes on Sunday April 28, 2019 @09:22PM (#19775077)
> The holder of an allodial title can voluntarily relinquish it at any time. The title shall be relinquished if the property is sold, leased or transferred by the allodial title holder; the allodial title holder no longer occupies the dwelling for 150 days; or the home is converted to anything other than a single-family dwelling occupied by the owner.

For having "no obligations on the property", those are some pretty substantial obligations.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by village-idiot on Sunday April 28, 2019 @02:50PM (#19772897)
It’s feudal because there are a number of people who own land and can extract an unusually high level of revenue from it purely because of who their parents were. That someone can own inherited land, collect rent, and pay a mere pittance in property tax purely because of who their parents were is as close to an aristocracy as we get in America.

It was never a requirement of feudalism that a land owner had 100% control over their land. Most feudal lords had a greater lord that expected tribute and support during war. In this metaphor land owners would be the lesser lords, not the king.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by nitrogen on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:04PM (#19772997)
Do inheritance loopholes apply to rental properties?

I've seen the counterpoint sentiment in this thread described as "right to place". Some have a deep instinct to want to stay where they grew up and continue to build it. Maybe we should find a way to support that dream as well as the needs of people moving from outside to take advantage of the growth produced by their predecessors, instead of vilifying anybody who has something we want.

Otherwise you end up with an entirely transient population with little sense of ownership, responsibility, or community.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by TulliusCicero on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:12PM (#19773062)
As someone from the bay area, if you think the setup there leads to 'natives' being able to stick around for the long term, I have some bad news: it's literally the exact opposite of that.

Out of my high school class, people who stuck around are actually somewhat uncommon. I mean, there's obviously still more there than any single other metro, but surprise surprise, most have moved somewhere much cheaper.

With saner density/zoning regulations, rents would be low enough to where more would have been able to stick around. Instead, very few have.

The current setup benefits homeowners who get in early. Their kids may well eventually benefit by inheriting that house, but in the meantime they've probably lived at least a few decades as adults elsewhere.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by Kalium on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:09PM (#19773033)
> Do inheritance loopholes apply to rental properties?

In California, it's all properties. Regardless of purpose. You can inherit dear old dad's office building and its tax assessment.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by seanmcdirmid on Sunday April 28, 2019 @04:49PM (#19773595)
Property taxes explicitly work against speculation (you can’t just buy property and sit on it, since property tax acts to depreciate its value), but not rent seeking (indeed, it even pushes people to use their property productively so they can lay their property taxes).
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by Gibbon1 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @10:27PM (#19775384)
The truth is property is worth basically nothing without public infrastructure and services. So taxes pay for the maintenance of the public infrastructure and services that give the land it's value.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by seanmcdirmid on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:20PM (#19775579)
There is that, but property taxes are also designed to discourage unproductive speculation. Many taxes have dual purposes like that (e.g. sin taxes).
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by Gibbon1 on Monday April 29, 2019 @12:47AM (#19775911)
Before property taxes you had things like the lord demanding a certain amount of labor per year. Plus some amount of goods. For a minor noble inability to supply that without reason would result in being replaced.

Taxes are less intrusive than say being press ganged to spread asphalt on I80 at 2am for a couple of weeks.

At least for me.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by solidsnack9000 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:56PM (#19775719)
There's nothing feudal about the absence of "allodial title" -- the absence of the possibility to "outright own your property". Empires, after all, never allowed that either; they were not feudal, though, they were empires.

Under feudalism is actually when legal systems began to recognise allodial title as such. To the old fashioned kings, "land to which you have an absolute title" was just "land I haven't conquered yet".

When people talk about feudalism here, what they probably are referencing is the defacto inalienability of property under feudalism, and the consequent emergence of a small landed class who enjoyed revenues from a large labouring class.

The inalienability and concentration was not due to one law or institution, but typically several together. Some wills outright forbade the inheritor to sell any of the property, if they accepted the inheritance. In some parts of Europe, all of the property was inherited by one son -- primogeniture -- tending to concentration.

It was never the case under feudalism that there was no way to move into the landowning class -- some families moved in and some out -- but in practice families with land could very easily retain it. This changed only with the emergence of widespread trade and then industrialism, because these introduced much better ways to generate revenue from labor and led to a situation that might seem bizarre to us: poor gentry with vast landholdings and no money, and no way to generate revenue from the land since they couldn't invest in it, and no way to get outside investors because it was always "heads I win, tails you lose" when it came to collecting on the only asset of value the gentry had, the land.

What California is doing really is feudal, in the sense of encouraging the concentration of landholdings in a semi-permanent group of families.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by avar on Monday April 29, 2019 @02:53AM (#19776367)
> What California is doing really is feudal, in the sense of encouraging the concentration of landholdings in a semi-permanent group of families[...]

This history lesson really falls apart when you consider what preceded feudalism for the average person in medieval Europe, or what happened in parallel in other societies outside of Europe that never experienced feudalism.

In both cases it was the norm in agrarian societies that farmsteads would be owned by the same family for generations. Re-establishing that is the main effect of Proposition 13.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by solidsnack9000 on Monday April 29, 2019 @06:38PM (#19783277)
For families to hold land, and for them to concentrate it, are two very different things. Individual farmsteads are not what concentrative legislation like Proposition 13 encourages.

What legal situation in Europe or elsewhere are you actually describing? Many agrarian societies were imperial. Pre-feudal Europe involved a mix of Roman institutions and tribal institutions, and tribal societies generally have a vague concept of land ownership. Maybe you’re thinking about the Old West?

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by TulliusCicero on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:03PM (#19772990)
You do outright own it, though. It's just that outright ownership doesn't free you from all possible obligations or regulations.

You can own a dog, but that doesn't mean you're allowed to beat your dog. And if you beat your dog, the state may well come in and take it away (and also jail you).

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by aey on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:12PM (#19773058)
Not quite. A working family living in a city for generations shouldn’t be displaced by taxes on unrealized gains. If the city wants to tax at current prices, they should guarantee that price for 5 years.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by estebank on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:38PM (#19773198)
All you need is one or two of those generations to have more than one kid and the same dynamic that makes it unaffordable for everyone will make it unaffordable for at least one branch of that generational family.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by aey on Sunday April 28, 2019 @04:48PM (#19773586)
So why can’t FAANG build offices in Detroit? In the Bay Area the lack of affordability comes from concentration of high paying jobs in a small area. They have the economic clout to push the area to build more, or expand in another part of the country.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by rcpt on Sunday April 28, 2019 @09:41PM (#19775183)
Because relocating a trillion dollar business cluster to make some curmondgely homeowners happy is moronic
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by aey on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:04PM (#19775517)
Amazon just did it. Everyone doesn’t need to pack up and move.

Those homeowners seem to have a majority in the area. Seems moronic to run a trillion dollar company at odds with the local government.

NYC has an income tax. I bet SF will have one within 5 years.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by delackner on Wednesday May 01, 2019 @01:35PM (#19799545)
Actually no, the lack of affordability is 100% due to political decisionmaking that for the past 30+ years has failed to generate enough housing to match population growth. No supply + extreme demand -> massive increase in prices.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by scarejunba on Sunday April 28, 2019 @10:44PM (#19775429)
Usually you can bypass the problem by making it a transfer tax thing. When you sell, all your taxes come due through the change in price.

For inheritances, you re-assess and consider it a sale. If the price went up lots, the kids can pay the tax and keep it, or they can sell the property and pay off the taxes.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by aey on Sunday April 28, 2019 @11:00PM (#19775498)
Transfer tax is totally fine.

But governments that try to get between families will end up on the loosing end. What inevitably happens is that the rich get loopholes and the middle class pays. At least in California everyone gets the same deal.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by scarejunba on Monday April 29, 2019 @12:13PM (#19779677)
In practice, California's method entrenches wealth.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by aey on Monday April 29, 2019 @10:21PM (#19784570)
Does it? Nothing to do with that massive tech industry? Seattle is a socialist paradise I take it?

If you can get all the Google engineers to go on strike unless Mountain View agrees to build 50,000 homes, it will be done over night.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by scarejunba on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @04:05AM (#19785971)
Honestly don't know what you're on about. Grandfathered-in property taxes definitely entrench wealth more than "everyone pays current rate" or "everyone pays past rate".

I'm not trying to explain housing prices here. I'm talking about the innate behaviour of Prop 13.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by enraged_camel on Sunday April 28, 2019 @03:41PM (#19773220)
>>A working family living in a city for generations shouldn’t be displaced by taxes on unrealized gains.

Why? What entitles someone to being in a certain location?

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by AdrianB1 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @04:50PM (#19773600)
The right to live and to have property that was legally acquired. Otherwise is just a new form of feudalism.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by Dylan16807 on Monday April 29, 2019 @03:00AM (#19776394)
"You might have to move every thirty years" is not exactly feudalism.

Also you get paid an enormous amount of money to move when the property value gets so high that you can't pay the percentage in taxes.

Go buy three houses somewhere else and don't pretend you're oppressed.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by aey on Monday April 29, 2019 @10:23PM (#19784580)
Do you have kids and a family? My parents couldn’t move to a home within reasonable distance to their kids and grandkids.
Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by Dylan16807 on Tuesday April 30, 2019 @07:58PM (#19793237)
For the specific situation of "parent currently lives near kids, kids can afford expensive house, parent can't afford a new house near them" I have sympathy. But it's kind of a niche case. If the parent lived anywhere else it would be equally sad, but locking tax rates wouldn't help them the tiniest bit. And anything that stagnates supply makes it harder not only on unlucky parents buying houses near kids, but on all the kids that want to buy houses near the parents.

If we were regularly pushing people out with huge paydays, and then putting in denser housing, they'd be able to afford to move right back in with the only downside being a smaller yard to offset their pile of cash. And people that didn't win the housing lottery would be able to move in too.

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by shados on Sunday April 28, 2019 @09:55PM (#19775251)
Out of curiosity (I dont know Cali's rules well), how does it work in Cali as you own the place (that is, lets take out the inheritance part for a sec).

If your taxes go up like crazy because property value increase, are you out of luck (like most other places), or do you get to keep a lower tax rate? Because I'll admit, being kicked out of the house you bought because rates skyrocketed and all of a sudden you can't afford it anymore kind of sucks. I live on the east coast, and just 2 years after I bought a place, my taxes basically doubled. I'm privileged enough that I was able to absorb it, but most people wouldn't be able to. Coupled with a bunch of heavy repairs I had to do shortly after getting the place, plus realtor fees, most people wouldn't even have been able to afford selling it, either. So bankruptcy they'd have gone.

One could say you should be sure you can absorb these hikes before you buy, but these are spikes that someone somewhere in city hall signed off on, not some kind of unpredictable random bad luck (the tax hike, not the repairs)

Re:Over 13% of the homes in Japan are abandoned by Gibbon1 on Sunday April 28, 2019 @10:16PM (#19775333)
Yeah when it was on the ballot I referred to it as the Aristocracy Act. You can inherit the Prop 13 tax advantage. And when you die your heirs also inherit it. Forever.