Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page
by lukeschlather on Monday December 06, 2010 @05:23PM
(#1977074)
1. This use of fail is becoming a fairly standard colloquialism. I don't think it's too hard for the average person to conclude Moby Dick from context, since they've probably heard someone under the age of 25 use fail in a similar manner.
2. Google is renowned and even loved for their "unprofessional" home page logos. This is no different, and there's nothing wrong with a bit of whimsy.
3. As is all art.
Regarding item #2:
The home page doodles are interesting and unconventional, but not unprofessional.
This bastardization of English is not interesting, only unconventional in educated company, and certainly unprofessional.
Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page
by sdkmvx on Monday December 06, 2010 @06:55PM
(#1977363)
"All nouns can be verbed, and all verbs can be nouned." (JARGON file).
But seriously, this is how language evolves.
Re:"Whale Fail" - Google Books' Error Page
by wwortiz on Monday December 06, 2010 @05:28PM
(#1977088)
Well it is much nicer than the google default http://www.google.com/blalgalgal
Now while I enjoy the artwork here, and it’s clever, this error page strikes me as
1. Overly nerd-centric / in-joke (Edit: I am referring to the Twitter reference, not the use of the word “fail” here)
2. Unprofessional (the word “fail” used as a noun)
3. Derivative.