News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Sauron – A web framework in Rust that adheres to... by eljimmy on Friday April 26, 2019 @09:10AM (#19757029)
Slightly off topic - I can’t imagine calling the framework Sauron and posting a photo from the LOTR movie is legal.
Re:Show HN: Sauron – A web framework in Rust that adheres to... by jrs95 on Friday April 26, 2019 @09:49AM (#19757414)
Probably not, technically, but it's sort of in that (Gandalf The) Grey area where nobody really gives a shit so you'll get away with it. This is just a random project on GitHub, it's not like a major corporation is putting this out. If they did, they could just remove the copyright images and possibly rename it if they felt it was really necessary.
Re:Show HN: Sauron – A web framework in Rust that adheres to... by zbentley on Friday April 26, 2019 @09:17AM (#19757088)
I’m not an expert, but that seems like an example of fair use to me.
Re:Show HN: Sauron – A web framework in Rust that adheres to... by jerf on Friday April 26, 2019 @10:07AM (#19757618)
Is that the Internet's idea of "fair use" which is "I can pretty much do whatever I want as long as I say 'fair use'", or the legal one?

Calling it Sauron is almost certainly OK. Using an image from the movie probably isn't, and the reason why isn't copyright, it's trademark. It makes it look like it may be officially related to the trademark owner. This may sound silly to you, but in a world where the New York Times has an active open source contribution page, along with other non-tech-companies that have put out open source like financial companies, audio companies, etc., the idea that a movie production company might put out a web framework is well within the bounds of possibility. For similar reasons, calling it Sauron is OK but I'd want to lean away from any obvious relationship to the Lord of the Rings, such as posting a satirical version of the ring's inscriptions. (A literary estate putting out a web framework is much less plausible, but on the other hand, they're well known to be on the litigious side, so personally I'd avoid it even so.)

On the plus side, the worst case plausible scenario is a cease and desist, which may never come. Things only get nasty if the project refuses after that.

Re:Show HN: Sauron – A web framework in Rust that adheres to... by xaqfox on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:18PM (#19759751)
The granting of trademarks is narrower than that. The protection only applies to products and services that are "identical or 'colourfully' similar to the "registered" products or services".

This is not to say that the holder would still not litigate out of fear of losing their mark, though.

Re:Show HN: Sauron – A web framework in Rust that adheres to... by jerf on Friday April 26, 2019 @01:58PM (#19760188)
That's for using the same word for different things. You can start a new company called Apple in other industries, no problem. You can not use the Apple computer company's logo as yours, though.

You can probably use Sauron, but you can not literally put up a picture of the Eye of Sauron as your project logo without making it appear that you are operating specifically as that trademark holder. With that picture, they're not just claiming to be "a" Sauron, they're implicitly claiming to be associated with whoever currently holds the rights to those movies.

(I'm only hedging on the "probably" because of the known litigiousness of the Tolkien estate. Normally it shouldn't be a problem.)

Re:Show HN: Sauron – A web framework in Rust that adheres to... by hartator on Friday April 26, 2019 @09:30AM (#19757213)
In Europe probably not. In the US it falls under first as fair use.