I wonder too if its also someone who wanted to avoid the confrontation of having to make the decision. "We've noticed you've been under-performing and you haven't been meeting your quotas for the past x weeks" vs "The tracking system has determined that you have been under performing and so we have to let you go." It may seem close to the same, but its always easier to say it was someone else or something that decided instead of you.
Is it a competitive disadvantage - or just standard greed ?
If you can save two cents on each of 5 billion packages, you save $100 million per year. Most employers will give raises and promotions to people who deliver operational expense savings that large.
[1] https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1018724/000119312518... Five billion items to prime users
I think it utterly destroys the image of the company if it cannot act "humane".
It's fine to keep costs under control ..but..if you are then organizing super expensive meetings across the world it just looks bad.
50 millions packages that cost 5 cents more? Kind of big deal.
Someone at Amazon basically throught why does a human have to look at the statistics after a few months and replaced it with some code - but besides that, that tracking and pressure is probably common in almost all online retailer warehouses. Maybe some cynic asshole thought that not letting the team-lead to do firing prevents keeping employees that perform bad but have good reasons for it - like beeing older or having medical problems.