So what happens when the behavior is the inherent wrong?
People want to stop gangs not because being in the gang is inherently wrong, but because of the violence and crime that normally surrounds membership in a gang. The same somewhat applies to drugs as well, as many people don't see the drug itself as being something bad as long as adults reasonably use it, but the problems drugs normally cause as the reason for banning them.
But what about actions that are bad in and of themselves. Should we socially include NAMBLA and stop prohibiting what they wish to legalize? I seriously question the wisdom of such a move.
The results certainly sound encouraging.
I'm curious though how people from those communities who tried to do the "right thing" and not get involved with gangs feel about this leniency.
I'd imagine there's a tipping point where too much forgiveness and inclusion for too many criminals leads to a lack of trust in the rule of law.
[1]: http://time.com/longform/portugal-drug-use-decriminalization...
Afrika Bambaataa also used this tactic to reduce gang violence in late 70s/early 80s New York.
It's pretty far from true legalization, but certainly better than 100% criminalized possession.
This very much makes me think of the distinction between motorcycle clubs and motorcycle gangs. The choice of word states if they are a group to be socially ostracized or a group expected to participate as part of the wider community.
It seems fairly obvious that "legalizing" these groups and incorporating them into the political process allows them to gain resources without violence.
Excellent quote. There's a lot of truth here. Social exclusion is at the heart of a lot of behavioural pathologies.
I submit that "criminal" is the wrong word, certainly when your focus is public order in the present day.
I think the goal is to reduce the later, attacking the former was just a way to try to do that.
Ecuador strat seems to work toward the second goal, just without tackling the first.
Let's see if how this goes.
If this is true, then I nominate David Brotherton for a Nobel Prize...
Also, I found this quote interesting: "...basically, when you want to stop a behavior, the worst thing you can do is prohibit it. Social inclusion is the most productive means of social control."
Interesting...