News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by johnnycab on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @08:01AM (#19727721)
In the section for 'Schengen Border Checks', under the image of the Russian passport, there is a picture of a scowling Gérard Depardieu[1], which is a thinly veiled attempt at a display of mirth and disdain in equal parts, by the Directorate General of EU Commission - Migration and Home Affairs.

Although, his body of work and extracurricular activities could provide a further source of fodder for ridicule. However, it reveals the general message from EU after this vote i.e. we don't care if you object and irrespective of your views, this project is going ahead [2].

[1] https://www.securityresearch-cou.eu/sites/default/files/02.R...

[2] https://www.gemalto.com/govt/coesys/eborder/entry-exit-syste...

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by christudor on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @09:59AM (#19728616)
"We don't care if you object and irrespective of your views, this project is going ahead."

The EU seems to have done this for at least twenty-five years, the prime example being their stubborn insistence on monetary union despite the mountains of expert opinion saying that monetary union made no sense economically.

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by raxxorrax on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @10:46AM (#19729122)
And those experts were pretty much on point. I doubt the EU will survive long with its attitude. I wouldn't mind, since something new is preferable to this.
Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by NotPaidToPost on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @11:19AM (#19729474)
This misses the point.

You could also say that monetary union between the US states makes no sense economically. The point is that the people decided to have a political union and to belong to the same country, the USA. Monetary union follows.

The aim is to have a federal union in Europe. In a way, going straight to monetary union is to 'force' further political union because they know full well that it requires it in order to work.

It's crucial to have the economics work but economics does not control culture and politics, it's the other way round.

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by franch on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:11PM (#19729982)
> The aim is to have a federal union in Europe. In a way, going straight to monetary union is to 'force' further political union because they know full well that it requires it in order to work.

Sorry, but I disagree. There is no consensus whatsoever in the EU about a federal Union. There is not even consensus on a budgetary union (as in shared debt, not just having a shared currency) because it will reflect badly on states that currently have stronger economies in the EU: https://www.reuters.com/article/germany-lithuania/merkel-say...

Actually, to be fair, every time there was a popular referendum even the EU Constitution has been rejected by the population (it only passed later by the parliament): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_French_European_Constitut... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_Dutch_European_Constituti...

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by NotPaidToPost on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:42PM (#19730310)
Ever closer political union has been the aim, publicly stated or not, since the early days of the treaty of Rome.

They know and knew that monetary union can only lead to further political union.

The main issue, or the benefit, is that it requires all countries to have a good governance. It will force Greece and friends to finally be serious.

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by winter_blue on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:59PM (#19731132)
> every time there was a popular referendum even the EU Constitution has been rejected by the population

That it was "rejected by the population" is a dishonest characterization. Referendums in Luxembourg and Spain were successful. Elected representatives in 16 other EU countries voted in favor of the Constitution. Yes, it was rejected by voters France and the Netherlands, and that killed the treaty, because establishing a Constitution requires unanimous support.

So, no, it wasn't rejected by "the population" (a term that it was always be inaccurate[1]). It was rejected by a minority. And the treaty being one that requires unanimous approval, failed because of that.

This Wikipedia page shows the full picture: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_establishing_a_Constitu...

[1] Anytime there's a characterization in the form of "the people" (or "the American people") it's dishonest and inaccurate, because the "people" of any large enough group hold diverse-enough opinions that you simply cannot characterize them with a broad brush. (Unless of course, you conduct referendum in which the question is affirmed unanimously by everyone in the group with a 100% quorum. Which gets quickly almost-impossible as the group's size increases.)

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by franch on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:09PM (#19731794)
> So, no, it wasn't rejected by "the population" (a term that it was always be inaccurate[1]). It was rejected by a minority. And the treaty being one that requires unanimous approval, failed because of that.

Uhm sorry no. Read the links. It was rejected by the majority of the voters both in France and the Netherlands.

What happened afterwards in France was to change it slightly and make it pass by parliamentary vote instead.

About the accuracy of the term "the population", I simply mean it "by the local rules for a nation wide referendum".

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by winter_blue on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:49PM (#19733293)
I meant a minority of the European people/countries. Whether you count by population, or by the number of countries.

(a) By number of states: 18 approved it, 2 rejected it, and the rest canceled/dropped efforts as it was effectively a failure (at that point).

(b) By population: Let's add together the populations of the 18 countries that approved of it, and the 2 that rejected it. I'm confident the total population of the 18 europhiles exceeds that of the 2 naysayers.

We don't know how things would have fared in the rest of the EU (that dropped/canceled referendums or legislative votes on this), but of those 20 countries, a majority of both people and countries were for the EU Constitution.

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by christudor on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:12PM (#19729995)
The big mistake the EU made was assuming: (i) that monetary union would foster political union, and (ii) the people of Europe actually wanted political union in the first place. I don't think either are true.

I think we more or less agree with each other, by the way. It's important that the political situation matches the economic situation. I just don't think you can use the economics to force the politics, if you see what I mean?

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by stjohnswarts on Sunday April 28, 2019 @09:41PM (#19775182)
I think people want an economic bloc with free trade and travel. I don't think they want a new European government controlling their lives.
Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by NotPaidToPost on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:43PM (#19730329)
Monetary union will lead to deeper political union. There is no choice. It already has.
Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by christudor on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @01:59PM (#19731135)
This is not the view of Ashoka Mody in his recent book Eurotragedy.
Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by NotPaidToPost on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:11PM (#19731246)
The fact is that the monetary union has brought closer political integration and will continue to do so because, again, that's the only way.

I think you're trying to ascribe more meaning to whatever book you've dropped the title of that it might have... (I haven't read that book but the author seems serious enough not to ignore facts)

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by christudor on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @02:44PM (#19731534)
I may be mistaken but it looks like you haven’t read the book but you’re confident in assuming I’ve somehow misunderstood it!

Here’s the relevant quote in full:

“British economist Nicholas Kaldor had warned as early as March 1971 that the fiscal governance system would deepen political divisions. In November 1997, Milton Friedman predicted that the euro’s flawed economics would “exacerbate political tensions by converting divergent shocks ... into divisive political issues.” The Europeans had it backward, Friedman concluded: “Political unity can pave the way for monetary unity. Monetary union imposed under unfavourable circumstances will prove a barrier to the achievement of political unity.””

[dead]
Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by tomhoward on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @11:32AM (#19739398)
It's not possible to downvote replies to your own comments, so you shouldn't accuse people of doing that.
Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by christudor on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @04:04PM (#19732308)
Fair enough, let's leave it there.

p.s. I don't actually have the ability to downvote comments, so that'll be someone else who's doing that.

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by blibble on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:05PM (#19731765)
> The fact is that the monetary union has brought closer political integration and will continue to do so because, again, that's the only way.

there's another alternative: the entire thing self-destructs

which seems more likely at this point than full fiscal and political union

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by NotPaidToPost on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @03:22PM (#19731950)
The Trumps and Farages of this world think that by repeating it again and again it will make it "seem more likely". But to me it seems more likely they will pass sooner than the Euro.

The reality is that France, Germany, the Netherlands, etc are not going back.

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by raxxorrax on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:50AM (#19736146)
There is always another way. And if that is the official strategy, there should be another way. In fact, any way would be better by definition.
Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by deugtniet on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @10:06AM (#19728692)
I don't see the point of disdain, Depardieu is a relatively well known Russian citizen and also a French public figure, so if you want someone from outside of the EU visa agreements, perhaps it's a good example of an individual like that?

In addition, there's substantial pressure from member states to secure the border, and make it as efficient as possible. The governments of Italy and Hungary have practically been screaming about border protection issues. It's not only limited to governments, many national and EP parties have publicly expressed the same viewpoint.

I also don't like these systems because of privacy concerns. But suggesting that it's disdainful or undemocratic, it is not. The democratic process is being followed. Perhaps you're seeing something that is not there, or you just really dislike the EU institutions for some reason.

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by johnnycab on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @11:31AM (#19729592)
>I don't see the point of disdain, Depardieu is a relatively well known Russian citizen and also a French public figure so if you want someone from outside of the EU visa agreements, perhaps it's a good example of an individual like that?

He famously gave up his French passport [1]. The official document features his picture issued via a legitimate Department/Executive agency [2]. If I didn't know any better, that looks like a meme!

You are implying that a department which is responsible for implementing the most wide-ranging project and whose sole remit is based around taxonomy of biometrics, has a totally legitimate right to use an image of any person in official documents, in order to promote certain values of it's member states and thereby circumventing it's own laws and directives like Art.17?

[1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-20750593

[2] https://ec.europa.eu/info/departments/migration-and-home-aff...

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by deugtniet on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @11:49AM (#19729756)
Actually, I’m not implying that. What I’m implying is that this department uses images of public figures for them to give good examples of individuals. As said in my previous comment, Depardieu is a well known public figure, and he allows the use of his images in other public places, so his use in government documents is justified.

Trump is on there as well. Do you also want to complain about his depiction?

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by johnnycab on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:00PM (#19729864)
I would genuinely like to see another example of public figures used in such a way in EU official documents?

D Trump is used generically, it is not asscociated either to a nationality or a figure. NO photograph is provided.

Edit: There is a thumbnail of Donald Trump. However, same principle applies.

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by _visgean on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @08:00PM (#19743731)
I am not sure that this is an official document, more like an internal presentation afaik.
Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by nothis on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @10:10AM (#19728728)
>"Smile, you're in Europe!"

This is under a section where they explain how they link your face biometrics into a universal database after taking your fingerprints. Wow.

Re:EU votes to create gigantic biometrics database by _visgean on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @10:53AM (#19729199)
They also use Donald Trump as an example. I suspect this presentation was done mainly to explain the plan to politicians finding the whole topic technical and boring and therefore they tried to entertain them a bit.