Re:P = NP Proofs: Advice to claimers
by neilv on Monday April 22, 2019 @05:20PM
(#19723113)
It's definitely intuitive to me that most all claims from outside the institution will be mistaken/naive. But, for really big wins that have thus far evaded the institution, what's the likelihood that the solution will come from within the institution rather than from outside? (I'm asking sincerely; I'm not a mathematician, and don't know.)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
There's only one example I've heard of (some Russian guy), but generally they tend to involve innovative approaches within the establishment.
(As said Russian guy proves, sometimes this heuristic fails; but your prior should be that it's likely correct.)
Re:P = NP Proofs: Advice to claimers
by schuyler2d on Monday April 22, 2019 @06:47PM
(#19723821)
If you are thinking of Perelman and the Poincare conjecture then I don't think his career really maps to the kind of "outsider" that is described in this thread:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grigori_Perelman#Early_life_...
He had a PhD in math with enough success to be offered faculty positions at Princeton and Stanford.
The fact that he recluded from academic life after that doesn't matter.
I was thinking of some Indian guy and (not as nice of an example) some patent officer in the Swiss patent office.
There also is the nice example of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marjorie_Rice
I was thinking of some Indian
Assuming you mean Ramanujan. Although he was self taught in mathematics and did much of his work outside the university setting, the vast majority of his significant discoveries and publications where made within the academic framework.