News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by oftenwrong on Monday April 22, 2019 @04:15AM (#19717331)
It is nice to be able to give up some living space in exchange for lower rent, or for a premium location. Tokyo allows this to a great degree. Where I live, in the US, the construction of small apartments is illegal, so the ability to make this trade is more limited.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by dfxm12 on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:09AM (#19718599)
I disagree that you can't do this in the US. Considering the UES in New York, just as an example, studio apartments are certainly cheaper than 1 bedroom apartments, which are cheaper than 2 bedroom apartments. Several people splitting a 2 bedroom living space will work out to be cheaper than a studio per person as well.

Also, the US is a big place with different local laws. Be careful about generalizing something across the whole country, because after a few Google searches, I couldn't find any Federal Laws about this.

Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by chucksmash on Monday April 22, 2019 @10:16AM (#19719084)
In NY, regulations went into effect in 1980s that required all new apartments to be >400 square feet.

You can live in a smaller space (I spent a year in a <200 sq ft studio) but as far as I know you can't build one nowadays.

I remember seeing talk about micro apartments in NY but I think they did a pilot program where they exempted a builder from the regulation rather than repealing it.

Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by oftenwrong on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @10:41AM (#19729068)
"you can't do this in the US"

vs

"Where I live ... the ability to make this trade is more limited"

Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by patrickg_zill on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:24AM (#19718694)
There are zoning laws in many, many parts of the country that prohibit housing under a certain size, usually about 700 square feet, which is enough for 2 bedrooms and 1.5 baths.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by needle0 on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:02AM (#19725520)
What were the rationales for those laws being enacted?
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by eecsninja on Monday April 22, 2019 @05:04AM (#19717495)
And parking minimum laws make it worse. Just look at all the new 2-bedroom apartments in North San Jose, that are inhabited by single people.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by oftenwrong on Monday April 22, 2019 @05:22AM (#19717546)
In my neighbourhood all residential units must have at least one off-street parking space. Even if the unit is next to a train station.

A parking space + aisles is basically the size of a microapartment.

http://usa.streetsblog.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/2013/0...

Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by mc32 on Monday April 22, 2019 @07:43AM (#19718101)
I don’t think that’s not without reason. Not everyone’s workplace is within a walk of a commuter train station.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by bluGill on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:13AM (#19718621)
Yes, but why does the LAW require me to have a parking place? Parking space is not free for anyone: the owner (landlord) has to pay to have it, plow snow. Then there is the opportunity cost: that land could be used for something else.

I'm fine with landlords offering parking as a perk of rent - but the next landlord can offer an apartment to those who don't need/want a parking spot at a discount (how much discount is an open question). The law doesn't all the market to decide.

Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by rootusrootus on Monday April 22, 2019 @10:20AM (#19719114)
The law has to plan for generalities, not specific renters, and parking spots are not created ad hoc. And the law also has to allow for people who might elect not to pay for a parking spot but then want to use street parking, which is a negative externality for the surrounding neighborhood.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by pwthornton on Monday April 22, 2019 @11:49AM (#19719845)
Then you charge for street parking permits, which you should if the street parking has value.

A lot of places do this, where they charge a few thousand a year to park on the street.

A lot of people don't need parking. And we are forcing them to pay for it. That's bad policy. My old condo had like $80,000 worth of parking attached to it with two spaces. I only needed one of the space.

Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by rootusrootus on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:11PM (#19720089)
Your very last sentence counters the rest of your point. A lot of people don't need parking... but you did. But only half of what was provided. How to plan for this in advance? The parking spots have to be planned in from the beginning, not created ad hoc, so requiring a certain number of spots per X building units is sensible. Ideally you get just to 100% utilization but no more. But that will vary depending on the mix of tenants at any given time.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by pwthornton on Monday April 22, 2019 @02:35PM (#19721487)
The parking was deeded to my unit. I didn’t intentionally pay for 2 parking spots. I was forced to buy two.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by scottlegrand2 on Monday April 22, 2019 @02:51PM (#19721667)
Then you should have sublet the space to someone who needed it, no?
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by bluGill on Monday April 22, 2019 @11:22AM (#19719575)
Why is street parking free? I think there is the root of your problem: street parking isn't properly charged.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by SECProto on Monday April 22, 2019 @11:45AM (#19719795)
on point: Japan doesn't allow street parking (or at least, it's very rare), but even the densest cities have parking available off street - charging market rates, sometimes using car-elevators, many solutions that more efficiently avoid the issues with using government-paved roads as free parking
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by wbl on Monday April 22, 2019 @10:35AM (#19719223)
They could have a permit system.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by ch4s3 on Monday April 22, 2019 @08:08AM (#19718228)
Shouldn’t people who can commute by train have the option to live in a place that isn’t made artificially expensive by parking minimums? Should the law require non-drivers to subsidize parking?
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by mhenr18 on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:14AM (#19718626)
Parking minimums in residential areas are one of the few times I think they can make sense.

Suppose there is enough on-street parking for other non-residential uses. You don't want these spaces being constantly used by car owners who are living in apartment complexes that aren't meant for them. As a local government, you have to play the game of not letting them park using parking restrictions while potentially also managing by-laws that allow residents to get parking permits that let them bypass some restrictions.

This doesn't really apply in high-density urban areas, but I could see it being tricky to manage in growing areas.

(Although, I guess from a non car-owner's point of view you wouldn't care about whether other drivers are being inconvenienced by a lack of parking, because the knock-on effects wouldn't affect you.)

Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by yardie on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:51AM (#19718901)
If this was a suburb or mid-urban than no one would care. But the complaints are about parking minimums in super dense urban zones. Where developers are marketing them as walk to work, commuter friendly residences. The reality is the streets are desolate canyons of parking garages. Where parking is an additional expense that you can't get out of.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by oftenwrong on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:16PM (#19730022)
Parking minimums cat still be damaging in not-so-dense areas. For example: https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/11/20/we-forbid-wha...
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by rootusrootus on Monday April 22, 2019 @10:21AM (#19719125)
In my city all the parking is below the building on several levels below ground, ground level is all mixed retail/residential. It sounds like you've got a problem with zoning, not parking.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by alistairSH on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:17PM (#19720131)
Even if that's the case, that parking is still priced into your rent whether you use it or not. The building needs to built taller or take up more of the plot. The parking needs maintained. It's bonkers for a city to require parking at buildings that are accessible by transit. This is a case where the market should be left alone to deal with supply/demand.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by nitrogen on Monday April 22, 2019 @05:07PM (#19722999)
Or, the building can rent the excess parking to daily/monthly parkers at market rates...

It's just as bonkers for a city to shut out everyone who can't use transit.

Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by oftenwrong on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @12:29PM (#19730160)
If the restaurants in my neighbourhood choose to not serve hamburgers, are they shutting out people who eat hamburgers? If hamburgers are in sufficient demand, a restaurant will choose to serve them. If the government forces all restaurants to make 1000 hamburgers a day, it will tank the market value of hamburgers, and force non-hamburger-eaters to pay more to cover the losses from making an excessive amount of hamburgers.

When the government forces all developers to build parking, and provides free or severely underpriced parking on streets, it lowers the market value of off-street parking. Developers are forced to price-in parking development and maintenance.

Developers will still build parking where residents need parking. If they didn't, they would have trouble selling/renting their property. There is no need to force them. In cities around the world, we still find private parking in absence of parking minimums.

Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by donretag on Monday April 22, 2019 @11:07AM (#19719460)
Not all soil types allow for underground construction. There are numerous cities in the US with no basements or other underground structures since the soil will not allow it.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by rootusrootus on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:06PM (#19720043)
So put the parking on the second level and keep the first floor for small retail. It's really not a hard problem to solve.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by SECProto on Monday April 22, 2019 @11:48AM (#19719828)
In my city the parking is below the building on several levels below ground, requiring months of blasting to get through the bedrock, and significantly driving up the cost of the building itself.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by rifung on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:44AM (#19718842)
I can understand your point of view but I'm not sure this is a sufficiently good reason to mandate that requirement.

If you need a parking spot, you should make sure you rent an apartment that has one.

Having a law that each unit has parking just increases rent and traffic.

Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by jrace on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:20PM (#19720707)
but then you must have a law that prohibits the renters from owning a car.

How do you enforce that?

Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by rifung on Monday April 22, 2019 @01:56PM (#19721058)
> but then you must have a law that prohibits the renters from owning a car.

Sorry I'm not sure I follow?

Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by jrace on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @11:02AM (#19729296)
Otherwise the occupant of the address could just purchase a car, but have nowhere to park it. Then they park on the street. Or take a previous occupants spot. Pretty soon you have cars taking up spaces that were not previously assigned to them causing a cascade of parking wars.

By preallocating a parking spot for each occupant you prevent this problem.

Just because the person did not think they needed a car when moving into the home does not mean they will never want to get a car.

perhaps a better solution is to make each residence come with a parking spot - that is essentially owned by the resident. Then if they do not need it they could rent it out until which time they do need it (if ever).

Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by rifung on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:30PM (#19741399)
> Otherwise the occupant of the address could just purchase a car, but have nowhere to park it. Then they park on the street. Or take a previous occupants spot. Pretty soon you have cars taking up spaces that were not previously assigned to them causing a cascade of parking wars.

I'm not sure where you've lived but I've never seen this happen? I live in the US. I've seen multiple ways to prevent this.

People who don't have a parking spot shouldn't have access to the parking lot.

Even if you do have access you have to register your car, and any cars that were not registered will get a warning then either a ticket or towed.

Another solution is to just have assigned parking.

Parking on the street is fine if that's legal? I don't see the issue with that.

> perhaps a better solution is to make each residence come with a parking spot - that is essentially owned by the resident. Then if they do not need it they could rent it out until which time they do need it (if ever).

This creates incentives to get a car though. You have to do more work to not drive and it's possible you can't find a "tenant" for the parking spot.

Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by Xylakant on Monday April 22, 2019 @03:13PM (#19721857)
Japan has that figured out, too: you can’t register a car unless you have proof of having a parking spot.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by yardie on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:44AM (#19718844)
I pay for parking at my condo whether I use it or not because of minimum parking requirements. Could you imagine having to also pay for landline service on your mobile plan?

If it's worth it to have parking I'd gladly pay for it. For the moment I'm renting it out just below my costs because this next generation of renters aren't even bothering to drive much less park. So there is more capacity than need.

Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by 6DM on Monday April 22, 2019 @09:54AM (#19718926)
To be fair, you're renting a condo. The one type of housing notorious for a large fee, on top of the cost of the mortgage. I guarantee it would be the same fee with or without the parking. In my opinion that's just how the fee is being justified to you.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by yardie on Monday April 22, 2019 @12:38PM (#19720338)
I don’t think so. If the garage did not exist that is more space for apartments and store fronts that would become available. There is also the noxious gases and flammable liquids that have to be dealt with.
Re:Downsized dwellings: Inside Tokyo's tiny living spaces by mcguire on Monday April 22, 2019 @10:46AM (#19719309)
95 sq ft for $650/mo.