E.g. human sizing of time is highly linked to physiological timing, may it only be heartbeat pace. More generally, all emotional input can gear reasoning (emotional intelligence).
Only my 2c on this. Not sure how accurate it is.
The amount of confusion I see between two people from different cultures speaking the same language is amazing. 70% of communication is body language. The rest appears to be shared assumptions about what the other person just said.
I don't think we'll ever be able to have a conversation with a dolphin. We know they talk to each other, we know they're able to interact with us, but how would we ever communicate with them? Their world is so different from ours. To use the example above, a dolphin cannot "fall down", so any language concepts that we have around "falling" will be impossible for them to grok. Likewise we won't have mental concepts around sonar that they use every day, and so won't understand what they mean when they refer to that. We may be able to get to "hello, my name is Alice", but beyond that... nope.
Same with "conversational" AI - it's going to need to understand what its like to have a body, so it can understand all the language around bodies. Simulating that, and being able to make references to "falling over" as a brain-in-a-box, is going to lead to misunderstanding, for exactly the reasons you describe.
I hadn't thought about the measurements aspect, but it's true. There's been some research into trees communicating - could be a classic example. They talk (via fungal networks in their roots, apparently), but so slowly that we can't hear them.
And yes, human emotion is linked to human physiology, and hormones. A lot of human communication is about recognising and empathising with human emotion. That's going to be a tough thing for a machine to do...
Human like intelligence is training a computer to recognize pixel patterns in images so it can make rules and inferences about what these images mean. This is human like intelligence as the resulting program can accomplish human like tasks of recognition without the need for context on what these images might mean. But there is no context involved about any kind of world, this is pure statistical training.
Actually, the research has found that new born infants can perceive all sorts of things, like human faces and emotional communication. There is also a lot of inborn knowledge about social interactions and causality. The embodied cognition idea is looking at how we experience all that.
By the way, Kant demonstrated a couple of centuries ago that the blank slate idea was unworkable.
yes, thats called sensory input.... a child deprived of sensory input when newborn can die because there is nothing there to show the baby of its existence, this the cause of crib death (notice that crib death is not called arm death because a baby doesnt die in the mothers arms)
>There is also a lot of inborn knowledge about social interactions and causality.
no, babies are not born with any knowledge at all of even the existence of society or beings. causality is learned from the result of human experience, causality is not known at birth
That's a very limited subset of what I mean by "human like intelligence". And within that specific subset, yes, AI/ML can and have achieved "human level" results. But that same ML model can recognize cats in vectors of pixels doesn't know anything about falling down. It's never tripped, stumbled, fallen, skinned it's palms, and felt the pain and seen the blood that results. It's never know the embarrassment of hearing the other AI kids laughing at it for falling, or the shame of having it's AI parent shake it's head and look away after it fell down. It's never been in love with the pretty girl AI (or pretty boy AI) and been had to wonder "did he/she see me fall and bust my ass?"
Now giving a computer program some part of the experience of falling we could do. We could load the AI into a shell of some sort, and pack it with sensors: GPS receiver, accelerometers, ultrasonic distance detectors, cameras, vibration sensors, microphones, barometric pressure sensor, temperature detector, etc., and then shove it off a shelf. Now it would "know" something about what falling actually is. And that's what I mean by the need for experiental learning in a situated / embodied setting.
While it might be possible in principle to get that knowledge into a program in some other way, my suspicion is that it would be prohibitively difficult to the point of being effectively impossible.
I think there is something (a lot) to this. Consider how much of our learning is experiential, and would be hard to put into a purely abstract symbol manipulating system. Taking "falling down" for example. We (past a certain age) know what it means to "fall", because we have fallen. We understand the idea of slipping, losing your balance, stumbling, and falling due to the pull of gravity. We know it hurts (at least potentially), we know that skinned elbows, knees, palms, etc. are a likely consequence, etc. And that experiential learning informs our use of the term "fall" in metaphors and analogies we use in other domains ("the market fell 200 points today, on news from China...") and so on.
This is one reason I like to make a distinction between "human level" intelligence and "human like" intelligence. Human level intelligence is, to my way of thinking, easier to achieve, and has arguably already been achieved depending on how you define intelligence. But human like intelligence, that features that understanding of the natural world, some of what we call "common sense", etc., seems like it would be very hard to achieve without an intelligence that experiences the world like we do.
Anyway, I'm probably way off on a tangent here, since I'm really talking about embodiment, which is related to, but not exact the same as, situated-ness. But that quote reminded me of this line of thinking for whatever reason.