News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by chx on Friday April 19, 2019 @06:39PM (#19703603)
This doesn't make the fundamental problem here go away: they arrested someone who was not in the United States when allegedly violated a law of the USA. The USA does not have jurisdiction over the entire world. If they thought they had a case, the right way to do this is to issue an arrest warrant and ask the UK to arrest and extradite him. If this was a thing, international travel would halt because you would need to countercheck everything you've ever done online with the laws of the country you are flying to.

Consider this fictionary tale: you fly to Budapest for a fun trip. You are jailed for posting the Soviet hammer and sickle on your Facebook two years ago -- it's a crime under Hungarian law to use that symbol. Do you think this is right?

Here's the law:

Any person who: a) distributes, b) uses before the public at large, or c) publicly exhibits, the swastika, the insignia of the SS, the arrow cross, the sickle and hammer, the five-pointed red star or any symbol depicting the above so as to breach public peace - especially in a way to offend the dignity of victims of totalitarian regimes and their right to sanctity - is guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by custodial arrest, insofar as the did not result in a more serious criminal offense.

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by jlarocco on Friday April 19, 2019 @06:54PM (#19703679)
I'm okay with how the US handled this. The crime he pleaded guilty to caused innocent people real financial harm, and it's not like the US sent FBI agents over to the UK to pick him up. He flew here on his own, knowing (presumably) that he had committed a crime that could get him arrested here.

Kinda stupid to commit crimes against people in a country and then travel to that country before the statute of limitations has expired.

I might have a different opinion for victimless crimes, but it's irrelevant to this discussion.

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by ryanlopl on Friday April 19, 2019 @07:06PM (#19703752)
FWIW his crimes didn't target any country specifically, so he could've faced trouble anywhere in the world.

There's not necessarily anything wrong with prosecuting him in the US, but presumably the US authorities could've just as well spared themselves the work and referred this to the UK authorities in whose jurisdiction the crimes were committed.

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by A2017U1 on Friday April 19, 2019 @10:39PM (#19704511)
I find it hard to believe anyone thinks it's reasonable "anywhere in the world" can keep prosecuting the guy until he dies.

Taken to the extreme with this logic he should be extradited across the globe for decades for any public prosecutor to go to town on, though I guess that type of fear is exactly the intended effect of witch trial justice.

The situation in reverse with a US citizen charged in a foreign country despite causing no harm to them is unlikely to garner the same response. American exceptionalism at it's finest.

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by chx on Friday April 19, 2019 @07:11PM (#19703777)
And that is fine, again, the so called Dread Pirate Roberts 2 was arrested and convincted in the UK mostly based on info the US handed to the UK. The problem is the US arresting someone who was. not. in. the. USA. when committing the crime (if he did).
Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by tptacek on Friday April 19, 2019 @07:15PM (#19703800)
If you hack a bunch of computers in China, and China figures it out, and then you visit China, bet that China will arrest and imprison you. I don't see what's out of the ordinary about the fact pattern we're talking about here.
[dead]
Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by metafex on Saturday April 20, 2019 @01:41AM (#19704977)
That's only half true. Chinese authorities will generally just not let you out of the country again, if the crime isn't severe enough. Also as a foreigner you won't necessarily be notified that there is even a court case against you and you can be fined/sentenced in your absence.
Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by Barrin92 on Friday April 19, 2019 @07:27PM (#19703864)
>The problem is the US arresting someone who was. not. in. the. USA. when committing the crime (if he did).

How is this a problem? if you cause material damages to Americans and you then go to the US the country is going to come after you.

Why would the US not protect its citizens to the best of its ability and prosecute people who harmed them, even if they harmed them from a place that wasn't the US. We're talking about global financial crimes, they don't know any borders to begin with.

If you kill someone outside of the US, and then you travel to the US, I'd be concerned if you wouldn't get arrested

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by ryanlopl on Friday April 19, 2019 @07:31PM (#19703887)
As far as I'm aware it is not alleged that Marcus Hutchins caused material damages to Americans, it is alleged that he sold his malware to Americans.

I could be wrong, but I don't think the federal government has ever claimed that any Americans were infected with Kronos.

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by celticninja on Saturday April 20, 2019 @06:13AM (#19705705)
Not even that, he sold his malware, not to Americans specifically, or targeted at Americans at all, but he sold malware that someone subsequently used against US citizens.

It's a stretch.

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by A2017U1 on Friday April 19, 2019 @10:33PM (#19704493)
I'd love to see someone name one US company that faced material damages as claimed in this comment. It really doesn't seem to be the case.

World police strikes again.

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by giancarlostoro on Friday April 19, 2019 @10:24PM (#19704465)
Killing someone outside the USA unless they are American I dont think it would end up that way. Unless it was in a US Embassy.
Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by jlarocco on Friday April 19, 2019 @07:27PM (#19703863)
It doesn't matter because (some of) his victims were in the United States when he committed crimes against them.

Now that I'm thinking about it more, I'd be upset if they didn't arrest him while he were here.

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by ryanlopl on Friday April 19, 2019 @07:33PM (#19703894)
Where is it alleged that some of his victims were in the United States? I'm sorry, I just can't find such a claim in the court documents.

In fact, the DOJ press release specifically names a bunch of countries that aren't the US https://www.justice.gov/usao-edwi/pr/man-charged-his-role-cr...

>According to publically available information, since it was created, Kronos has been configured to exfiltrate user credentials associated with banking systems located in Canada, Germany, Poland, France, and the United Kingdom, among others countries.

Of course, given the nature of the malware it's very likely that at least someone in the US was affected.

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by vertex-four on Friday April 19, 2019 @06:56PM (#19703691)
> If this was a thing, international travel would halt because you would need to countercheck everything you've ever done online with the laws of the country you are flying to.

I mean, for many of us that’s already a problem, and has been for a long time. Ever mentioned your same-sex partner somewhere a Government might be able to find it? There’s now a whole bunch of countries you can’t visit or pass through without being at risk of imprisonment or worse, yay.

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by chx on Friday April 19, 2019 @07:09PM (#19703773)
But -- while obviously I do not endorse such laws -- the difference is you are violating their law at that moment, where you stand by just being you. Once again: I fundamentally disagree with such laws but the situation is different.
Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by Godel_unicode on Friday April 19, 2019 @08:16PM (#19704061)
Not really. They arrest you, when you arrive in their country, for being gay. It's not like they're extraditing people from other countries for being gay.
Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by chx on Friday April 19, 2019 @10:18PM (#19704439)
That's exactly what I said: according to their laws you being gay is a crime -- a crime committed at the time when you are in the country by simply being you. It has nothing to do with Hutchins' arrest which was for a crime committed in the past while being elsewhere.
Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by MRD85 on Saturday April 20, 2019 @08:10PM (#19709724)
If their law makes it illegal to have same-sex sex and they arrest you based on previous evidence of being gay then you're arrested for prior acts.
Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by tedunangst on Friday April 19, 2019 @07:18PM (#19703815)
Hammer and sickle is just ridiculous, but what about calling somebody a horse? https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-47862596
Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by chx on Monday April 22, 2019 @03:46AM (#19717227)
Released two days later https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-47897214
Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by pg_bot on Friday April 19, 2019 @07:25PM (#19703856)
Your hypothetical "crime" would be immediately thrown out because you would not be able to prove damages. No crime was committed against a citizen of Hungary, and Facebook is not considered the public at large.

A more apt hypothetical would be if you were tricking people into distributing hate symbols from abroad. I think you could make a cogent argument for arrest in that case.

The victims of the malware were on American soil. If someone remotely takes control of your smart oven and burns your house down, you have standing to charge them with a crime. The difference is he violated a US law, against a US citizen, while that citizen was in the United States. If you do that and are currently in the US you should expect to be arrested.

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by jwatzman on Friday April 19, 2019 @07:00PM (#19703717)
For better or worse, the US is far from unique in this, e.g., this high-profile case here in the UK from the past few weeks: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-47847740
Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by chx on Monday April 22, 2019 @03:46AM (#19717226)
Released two days later https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-47897214
Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by pizzazzaro on Saturday April 20, 2019 @08:47AM (#19706249)
Its not like he's contributed to anything helpful afterwards - oh wait.

Lets be honest with ourselves - banks have a very specific role in the world economy, and have largely quit lending to businesses small enough to actually upset the market.

Sure VCs do what they do. But unless you're in something sexy or trendy? Good luck courting them.

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by marnett on Friday April 19, 2019 @06:46PM (#19703640)
american global hegemony is a thing. fair or not, it exists. if you want out of the purview of the US you have to go to one of its enemy superstates, Russia or China. Even small neutral/hostile nations are not safe forever (eg Assange in Ecuador).
Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by foobarbazetc on Friday April 19, 2019 @07:58PM (#19704007)
Not really. He travelled to the US.

Assange was using Ecuador’s protection and resources for free. At that point you’re at the whim of the Ecuadorian people and their elections. Nothing is forever.

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by ninth_ant on Friday April 19, 2019 @07:23PM (#19703845)
It’s not really about hegemony at all. The US does extradite people but this isn’t about that.

He was arrested in the US for his impact to people and companies inside the US.

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by rhino369 on Friday April 19, 2019 @08:03PM (#19704019)
If someone shot a missile from one country to the next should they be immune from prosecution.

Nobody cares that he wasn’t in the US when he caused harm in the US.

Re:Malware researcher Marcus Hutchins, known as ’MalwareTech... by Jerry2 on Friday April 19, 2019 @07:26PM (#19703861)
>The USA does not have jurisdiction over the entire world.

Maybe not the whole world but the US has the hegemony over countries where the US military bases reside. All of those countries have signed their sovereignty away through various extradition and trade treaties which give the US DoJ a massive reach over the citizens of those countries.

In 2019, if you were to try to escape the long arm of US law, your options are extremely limited. I can't think of a country that would not hand you over to the US because of a massive pressure that the US State Department would put on the host country. Just look at Ecuador which sold Assange for billions in aid.